Experimentation: Necessary or Unnecessary? Essay

Experimentation: Necessary or Unnecessary? Essay

Length: 711 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The recent debate on whether or not animal experimentation should be allowed has sparked uproar. When scientists think they have what they claim to be a “wonder drug,” they need a way to test the safety of the drug before it is safe for human use. At this point scientists turn to animals, because of their close resemblance to humans. With drug companies reducing experimentations and using alternatives, some people may wonder why animals undergo experimentation in the first place. While there are advantages to animal experimentation, it does not ensure success in human clinical trials, there is no law protecting any animal from cruel experimentation, and some animals should not have to live in cruel facilities.
According to several studies, animals have played a crucial role in medical advancement over the last century. The article “Alas, Animal Experiments are Still Needed,” explains that animals have been used for testing the safety of drugs and vaccines from common pain-killers to anti-cancer treatment. The article points out, “They may not be perfect and human trials are also vital, but without animals medical advances would seriously be hampered” (qtd. in “Alas” P2). The article suggests that animals are crucial to medical research because they test the safety of a drug. While it may be true that animals play a vital role in experiments, in reality, some animals do not get a second chance to live and have fun because if they are harmed, recovery takes time and is not guaranteed. The website People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) explains that nine out of ten (92%) drugs and vaccines that are tested on animals work for them, yet fail in human clinical trials. The author mentions, “They argue the potential benefits ...


... middle of paper ...


... of just how cruel experiments can be comes to mind.



Works Cited

"Alas, Animal Experiments Are Still Needed." The Independent. 21 Jun. 2011: p.2. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 12 Nov. 2013.
"The Top Ten Questions." AMP. Americans for Medical Progress, n.d. Web. 11 Nov. 2013.
Kretzer, Michelle Sherrow Michelle. “Top Five Shocking Animal Experimentation Facts.” PETA, People for the Ethnical Treatment of Animals. PETA, n.d. Web. 12 Nov. 2013.
Rose, Stephen. “Proud to be Speciests.” Forming a Critical Perspective. Ed. Ann Spurlock. New York: Learning Solutions, 2006. 106-8. Print. 12 Nov. 2013.
Vastag, Brian. "Maryland Lab's Chimpanzee Testing Draws to a Close." Washington Post. 01 July 2012: A.3. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 12 Nov. 2013.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Ethical Treatment Of Animal Experimentation

- In discussions of animal rights, one controversial issue has been animal experimentation. On the one hand, advocates argue that all animals have the right to not be exploited for experimentation. On the other hand, skeptics contend that animal experimentation is necessary in order to improve human health. I strongly believe that animal experimentation is unnecessary as it can be unreliable and cruel. Animals should not be forced to suffer for research. Alternatives for animal experimentation are on the rise and eventually these experimentations will come to an end for the better....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
2243 words (6.4 pages)

Animal Experimentation is Necessary Essay

-      A contingent of those against the dog labs at the university protested last month, waving signs that read, "Kill. Heal. What's It Gonna Be?" and "The U Kills Dogs."  A fairly recent article in the Washington Post ("A Terminal Learning Environment"; Nov.  5, 2000) manages to move beyond the emotion and sloganeering used by these protesters to some of the real arguments of those in opposition; that the dog labs are "cruel, unnecessary and a waste of money" and that they "should be eliminated."1   However, the arguments used by the Washington Post (and ultimately, those in opposition) are insufficient to justify the termination of the dog labs at university.  The claim that the dog labs a...   [tags: Argumentative, Synthesis Essay Examples]

Better Essays
1598 words (4.6 pages)

Animal Ethics And Animal Experimentation Essay

- A major ethical concern that has been under speculation for many of years is focused around animal ethics, and whether or not certain animal practices are just or inhuman. There are many questions that focus around fundamental issues concerning the moral status of animals. It is critical to understand the difference between a concern for animal welfare and a concern for animal rights. A current issue that is important to understand and analyze is animal experimentation, and although many consider it to be an unethical practice, there are many pros and cons to the controversial topic....   [tags: Animal rights]

Better Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Animal Experimentation Should Be Banned Essay

- Although many pro-test members claim that animal experimentation is a necessary proceeding, these practices should be removed from the research process. The statistics from numerous researches and investigations have revealed what many are refusing to see, that the outcome of these experiments is vague and indefinite. Cosmetic companies and health institutions kill millions of animals each year. Animal testing is imprecise, expensive, unethical, unnecessary and ancient science that should be punished severely....   [tags: Human, Mammal, Species, Hominidae]

Better Essays
714 words (2 pages)

Animal Experimentation Should Be Banned Essay

- Although many pro-test members claim that animal experimentation is a necessary proceeding, these practices should be removed from the research process. The statistics from numerous researches and investigations have revealed what many are refusing to see, that the outcome of these experiments is vague and indefinite. Cosmetic companies and health institutions kill millions of animals each year. Animal testing is imprecise, expensive, unethical, unnecessary and ancient science that should be punished severely....   [tags: Human, Mammal, Animal rights, Science]

Better Essays
1283 words (3.7 pages)

The Ethics Of Animal Experimentation Essay

- At the turn of the new century, activists begun to protest the morality of animal experimentation: “… such methodology is far too cruel on beast, it cannot better mankind, but its lead to it demise…” Despite the rising concern for animal safety in laboratory research, federal legislations approved the practice. According to the federal bureaucrats, it is an essential tool to improve our current medical knowledge. Hence, most of the tested animals have a relatively shorter life span than human....   [tags: Animal rights, Human, Primate, Animal testing]

Better Essays
755 words (2.2 pages)

Morality of Animal Experimentation Essay

- Today’s society is based on anthropocentrism, a world view that human being have priority. Members of other species are used daily today for many things. Animal flesh, eggs and milk are used as a means of consumption. Some are used as pets for companionship, for hunting and plowing on farms, and can even be used as entertainment at shows and circuses. Police, and residents also use dogs for protection from others and the skin and wool of animals are used for unnecessary items such as clothing, wallets, purses and shoes....   [tags: Anthropocentrism, Human Priority]

Better Essays
1117 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Animal Experimentation

- Animal experimentation is a controversial topic and may what to stop the use of animal in experiments. Experimenting with animals helps save human life but innocents animal pay the consequences. The "pro" and "con" positions on animal experimentation have proven suitable for stating extreme opinions, but unhelpful at exploring the broader ethical questions of animal based research (Wolff, 2009). Human and animals are very similar, for scientific is easy to use animals to find cures for humans decease....   [tags: Ethical Issues, Persuasive]

Free Essays
978 words (2.8 pages)

Animal Experimentation Essay

- Clang. A metal cage is opened and a rat inside scurries to the other end, knowing the fate that will soon come to it. An intimidating gloved hand reaches inside and grabs the cowering creature despite its desperate struggles. Not long after, the rat is dead, another victim of animal experimentation. While there are some benefits of testing animals for medical purposes, there are also alternative means that are possible and could be even more effective. Scientists and researchers around the world claim that many people owe their health to animal research....   [tags: Animal Research]

Better Essays
1295 words (3.7 pages)

Animal Experimentation Essays

- Every year, over a million animals are tested on across the world. Animal experimentation is one of the most controversial issues. Animal testing is the use of non-human animals in research and development projects, especially for purposes of determining the safety of substances such as foods or drugs. Some people believe that animal testing is unnecessary and there are more efficient alternatives. Others believe that animal testing is crucial to the development of new products and cures. According to the Science of Toxicology, “Research involving laboratory animals is necessary to ensure and enhance human and animal health and protection of the environment”(1)....   [tags: Science Experiment, Legal Issues ]

Better Essays
1717 words (4.9 pages)