Essay on The Existence Of The Institution Of Government

Essay on The Existence Of The Institution Of Government

Length: 1649 words (4.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the first section of “Government” political theorist James Mill attempts to answer the question regarding the existence of the institution of government, as he believes that despite the abundance of literature regarding this topic, only few principles are well-established. Mill states that the reason for this is incorrect analysis, and existence of only a generalised conception, leading to endless disputes especially when deliberated upon.
Mill begins by stating that government is primarily a means to an end, the latter being described variedly, such as Locke’s “the public good,” and the utilitarian principle “the greatest happiness for the greatest numbers,” which he believes are fair, yet defective; and therefore, Mill writes that in order to understand collective happiness, the factors for the happiness of its individual members must be understood. Hence, in order to define this end, and establish a foundation for “the science of Government” human nature must be comprehensively studied.
In attempting to analyse human nature, Mill makes an assumption, which he deems necessary: the condition of a human being is based on the pleasurable and painful experiences they undergo, and their happiness is determined by the degree to which their pleasures outnumber their pains. Mill categorises the source of pains and pleasures produced into two — one, human factors, and two, natural factors, i.e., factors independent of human beings. The Government concerning itself with the first factor — increasing the pleasure and diminishing the pain that humans derive from each other.
The condition of human beings is dependent on nature for two reasons, which give rise to a large number of consequences — first, although the means of subsistence i...

... middle of paper ...

...Peace, Safety, and publick [sic] good of the People.”

Mill and Locke base the foundation of government to be human nature and the laws of nature, both of them agreeing that humans are selfish and the state of nature is that of anarchy and insufficient resources, due to which they form a union, referred to as “government.”
Mill’s theory lays foundation for the economic functions of a government, such distribution of wealth through taxes, labour rights and property rights. In this case, the end being “happiness” is a vague term, ironic that his criticisms of other defined ends of government is their vagueness.
Locke’s vision of government lays emphasis on its formation only upon voluntary mutual consent, and can be understood as a ‘night-watchman state’ where the function of government is to act only when there is a dispute between its members, laissez-faire in nature.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Government As An Institution Can Be Used For Benevolent Purposes Essay

- While government as an institution can be used for benevolent purposes, George Orwell’s novel 1984 contends that when taken to an excess in the form of totalitarianism, government becomes dangerously self-serving. It is clear that the government of Oceania in 1984 is self-serving, existing not to benefit its citizens or the elite Party members, but existing purely to exist and grow. Perhaps the most clear indication of this was O’Brien explaining the Party’s motives while torturing Winston. O’Brien explains that “the Party seeks power only for its own sake” and that “the object of power is power.” (185) This clearly indicates that the government of Oceania, a totalitarian state, seeks power...   [tags: Nineteen Eighty-Four, Totalitarianism]

Better Essays
918 words (2.6 pages)

The Existence Of A Democratic Deficit Within The European Union Essay

- The existence of a democratic deficit within the European Union (EU) is one of the most polarising issues of modern political discourse. ‘Democratic deficit’ is a term used by people who argue that the EU institutions and their decision-making procedures suffer from a lack of democracy and seem inaccessible to the ordinary citizen due to their complexity. The institutions most often talked about when discussing the idea of a democratic deficit are the three bodies at the heart of the ‘Ordinary Legislative Procedure’, these are: The European Commission, The European Parliament and The Council of The European Union....   [tags: European Union, European Parliament]

Better Essays
1209 words (3.5 pages)

Gains And Mills Contemporary Perspective Essay

- Gains and Mills Contemporary Perspective America in the seventies had social groups of powerful and the less powerful in America. Two writers in particular wrote works to illustrate the workings of society structure back then. These two authoggrs where Gans and Mills. Gain’s theory on poverty shows how the elites dominated the poor and Mill’s essay discusses the social institutions and their power in society both of which are similar. Gan’s theory on poverty implies the ruling elite and middle class benefit from the people in poverty....   [tags: Sociology, Institution, Working class]

Better Essays
909 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Government is Lawless

- Government is lawlessness, that’s the point. The state comes into existence and perpetuates it thus through acts of violence, be it theft (taxation), enslavement (conscription), counterfeiting (inflation), diplomacy (assassinations), or foreign policy (mass slaughter). Look at the numbers. Governments throughout history have killed far more people than anything else, save maybe old age. But this is excluding of course all that is unseen. If we really tally up the infinite ways in which the government makes not only makes our lives worse but in fact shortens them, government is clearly the greatest evil and most dangerous threat to humanity ever known....   [tags: taxation, arnarchy, power]

Better Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

The Sociological Perspective ( Or Imagination ), Cite Its Components, And Explain How They Were Defined By

- .Define the sociological perspective (or imagination), cite its components, and explain how they were defined by Wright Mills.. One can think of sociological perspective as our own personal choice and how the society plays a role in shaping our individual lives. Sociological perspective or imagination focuses not on individuals but their group, or society, and attempts to explain human social structures, including cultural and governmental institutions and forms of activity and interpersonal relations using social facts or social forces....   [tags: Sociology, Institution, Research, Social position]

Better Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

The Government Must Be An Ineffective Tool Essay

- In Paine’s opinion, the society should form first, then later will have a government. People need society to bring people together to produce happiness but when more people come together in the society the problem will arise, thereby they need a government. Government is an implement to control our wants and punish our vices. As time goes on, the system of government has gradually improved, in order to maintain social equality and security and bring felicity to people. Also, the government needs to be accountable to the society, if the government cannot solve or improve society, then the government will become an ineffective tool....   [tags: United States, Sociology, Political philosophy]

Better Essays
1049 words (3 pages)

Government Essay

- Thoreau starts his essay by supporting the motto- “that government is best which governs least” (177), which implies the reduction of governmental interference in everyday affairs by reducing the government’s capacity to tax for unpopular causes. A case in point is a poll tax – a “per head” tax imposed on all citizens to help support, what Thoreau considered an unjust war against Mexico, which would extend slavery into new US territories, organized by a small elite of persons who have manipulated government to their benefit against popular will (177)....   [tags: Analysis, Thoreau]

Better Essays
1245 words (3.6 pages)

The Case Against Monarchy Essay examples

- The Case Against Monarchy The idea that a monarchy is the ideal form of government is a fallacy. Al-Farabi and Aquinas’ ideas about government are wrong, and are filled with irreparable holes. In modern times, the idea of a monarchy has become counter-intuitive and counter-productive. A democratic republic paired with an educated and empowered middle-class is the solution to the quandary of how to create the perfect government. While the ideas of the Arabic philosophers are interesting, there ideas on the perfection of monocratic rule are outdated by both new technology and new ideas Al-Farabi says that, “what is intended by man's existence is that he attains supreme happiness (Bailey 285).”...   [tags: Government]

Better Essays
1620 words (4.6 pages)

Is Politics the Preserve of Government? Essay

-   Politics is a very emotive word and is used by different people to mean different things. There is no unifying theory of politics and hence no set boundaries of what can and cannot be said to be political. It is this ambiguity that makes it impossible to argue that politics is the preserve of government. This is so since preserve is such a precise word and there is always going to be a perspective that can illustrate an example of politics that is outside the governmental sphere.      In order that a meaningful conclusion to this question can be gained it is essential to initially define what the question is asking by laying down what definitions of the terms within are to be used....   [tags: What is Politics?]

Better Essays
2104 words (6 pages)

Government Affiliation and Cloning Essay

- Government Affiliation and Cloning Abstract The theory to alter and duplicate a human being first arose in the early 1900s. It became widely controversial since the entrance of the experiments on real animals by the 1990s. Influenced by its citizens, the governments all over the world stepped in to regulate the new process by establishing specific laws tackling the issue. Each government differed from the others, and hence, each national law varies from another. However, attempts were made to unify the regulations under international circumstances in organizations such as the United Nations....   [tags: Biology Medical Biomedical Clone]

Better Essays
1436 words (4.1 pages)