The Excessive Power of the Canadian Prime Minister Essay

The Excessive Power of the Canadian Prime Minister Essay

Length: 687 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

As the leader of the majority party, the Prime Minister of Canada acts as the spokesperson for the party, alongside appointing and allocating Members of Parliament and their responsibilities (Matheson, 2012). Additionally, the Prime Minister extends their powers to the Crown, whereby they nominate a candidate to the role of the Governor General. Meanwhile, the Governor General is responsible for the appointment of judges to Canada’s Supreme Court, upon the advice of the Prime Minister (Library of Parliament, 2013). Hence, the Prime Minister probes in virtually every branch of the Canadian government. It is quite unambiguous then, that the Canadian Prime Minister’s spearheading of the government at the federal level makes them too powerful. In fact, O’Malley’s study found that out of twenty-two parliamentary democracies surveyed across the globe, Canada’s Prime Minister had the most prime ministerial power (2007). Moreover, while the Canadian constitution comprises of binding conventions that constrain the exercise of legislative power by the government, the courts do not ordain these conventions (Leishman, 2005). To elaborate further, in order to mitigate the power held by the Canadian Prime Minister, party discipline should be abated in order to allow for Members of Parliament to efficaciously represent their constituents, and the three branches of government should be separated exclusively to prevent the engulfment of the Prime Minister’s influence upon every aspect of the government.

While the electorate vote for Members of Parliament that should hypothetically representing their constituents, MP’s are instead adhering to the objectives set out by the Prime Minister’s Office. Indeed, while former Canadian Prime Minister, Pier...


... middle of paper ...


...'Malley, (2007). The Power of Prime Ministers: Results of an Expert Survey.International Political Science Review. 28 (1), pp.7-27


Rory Leishman, (2005). Against Judicial Activism: The Decline of Freedom and Democracy in Canada. 1st ed. Quebec: McGill-Queen's University Press.


Donald Savoie, (1999). The Rise of Court Government in Canada. Canadian Journal of Political Science. 32 (4), pp.635-664


Kim Mackrael (2013). 'Behave and obey:' How party discipline hurts politics. [ONLINE] Available at: 'Behave and obey:' How party discipline hurts politics. [Last Accessed November 10, 2013].


Maxwell A. Cameron (2004). Federalism and the Separation of Powers at the Subnational level. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.politics.ubc.ca/fileadmin/user_upload/poli_sci/Faculty/cameron/Federalism_and_the_Separation_of_Powers_Aug11-04b1.pdf. [Last Accessed November 10, 2013].

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about The Prime Minister

- Thesis Statement There are very minimal checks on the Prime Minister’s authority and power has therefore become progressively concentrated within his possession. This has been intensified with the minimization of the role of the crown in Canada, as the role of the Queen has become mostly symbolic. There are also many forces that strengthen the autonomy of the Prime Minister and he monopolizes power on fiscal matters. Finally, he uses party discipline to his advantage, making sure that each member adheres to his own agenda....   [tags: Prime minister, Westminster system]

Better Essays
861 words (2.5 pages)

Limitations of the Canadian Prime Minister Essay

- Canada’s parliamentary system is designed to preclude the formation of absolute power. Critics and followers of Canadian politics argue that the Prime Minister of Canada stands alone from the rest of the government. The powers vested in the prime minister, along with the persistent media attention given to the position, reinforce the Prime Minister of Canada’s superior role both in the House of Commons and in the public. The result has led to concerns regarding the power of the prime minister. Hugh Mellon argues that the prime minister of Canada is indeed too powerful....   [tags: Canadian Government]

Better Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

Essay on Canadian Electoral System

- Parliamentary democracy comes to mind when many think about Canada’s political system. Parliamentary democracy is a political system in which the federal government’s power is distributed throughout the body of its citizens. This system will allow the public to vote a party to power in which the leader of that party will become the prime minister. However, Canada’s democracy is often questioned as it is diminishing from the hands of the common people and growing in the hands of the elites; elites being the wealthy and powerful individuals and/or corporations....   [tags: democracy, political system]

Better Essays
1957 words (5.6 pages)

Issues with Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Canadian Parliament Essay

- Prime Minister Stephen Harper is not a true representative of the people. Neither an academic nor an average Canadian, Mr. Harper is, first and foremost, a political tactician. He climbed his way to Parliament Hill and the position of Prime Minister along with a minority government in 2006 and has, ever since, used all means necessary to keep that – ever striving for a majority, which was finally achieved in the spring of 2011. However, in 2008 Harper was the source of a prorogation crisis, in which he, out of fear of losing the confidence of the House and giving up his role for an unstable coalition government, requested to then-Governor General Michaelle Jean that Parliament be prorogued i...   [tags: canadian studies, canada]

Better Essays
1981 words (5.7 pages)

A Comparison and contrast of Canadian Prime Ministers Essay

- The Prime Minister in Canada is the head of government and is appointed by the Governor General. Canada is the northern neighbor to the United States, and the Queen of England is its head of state. These powerful countries being so closely tied to Canada makes it a major player on the world stage, and gives considerable power to its Prime Ministers.There have been twenty-two Prime Ministers, with John Diefenbaker being the thirteenth, serving from 1957-1963, and Pierre Trudeau the fifteenth, who served 1968-1979 and again 1980-1984....   [tags: Political Science]

Better Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on United states president vs canadian prime minister

- The US president wields a lot of power both domestically and in the international scene. These powers are granted by a number of statutes, amendments, the Constitution, congressional acts, and numerous influences and soft power by virtue of his position as the leader. On the other hand, Canada does not have a president and is instead led by a prime minister. Although the two countries are almost equal in size, their leaders exhibit vast differences in the amount of power they hold domestically (Dickerson et al., 2009: 47)....   [tags: Government]

Better Essays
1160 words (3.3 pages)

The Rise of Canadian Prime Ministerial Powers Essay

- The factors that gave rise to Canadian prime ministerial powers is the very structure of Canada’s Westminster system and its effect on the legal powers of the Prime Minister, unwritten conventions and the decline in the Crown’s power. Firstly, the powers of the Prime Minister in its very nature are much wide spread in terms of what he can do as an executive power. Secondly, the history and development of unwritten conventions have created a tradition in which very few sources of constraints can be enacted on the Prime Minister within the parliamentary system....   [tags: canadian politics, executive branch]

Better Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Mackenzie King - Canadian Prime Minister

- The greatest Prime Minister of Canada was. Mackenzie King our 10thPrime Minister of Canada and by far one of our greatest. William Lyon Mackenzie King accomplished a lot in his twenty-0ne years of ministering our Country Canada. "It is what we prevent, rather than what we do that counts most in Government." (Mackenzie King august 26, 1936) This statement sums up the best secrets of Mackenzie King's success as prime minister, and perhaps, the key to governing Canada effectively. King's record of prime minister is sometimes difficult to judge....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1039 words (3 pages)

Essay about The Prime Minister of Canada

- The Prime Minister of Canada has an integral role within the Canadian parliament. In the political Parliamentary system of Canada, the Prime Minister wields the executive responsibility. He is accountable for an assortment of administrative, managerial, and supervisory decisions in effect across the country. The executive role is the branch of government that is generally responsible for creating laws, and enforcing the regulations to ensure these laws are observed. The Prime Minister is the Head of Government in Canada....   [tags: Politics, Canada]

Better Essays
2331 words (6.7 pages)

John Diefenbaker Essay

- In the year 1957, Canada elected its first Prime minister without English or French root, John Diefenbaker. While growing up in the city of Toronto, because of his German name, he was often teased. [1] He grew up as an outcast, and so he was able to relate to the discrimination and inequality many of the minorities in Canada felt. This essay will attempt to answer the question: To what extent did Prime Minister John Diefenbaker help promote equality to the minority communities. . The minorities in this time period were the women, aboriginals, and immigrants....   [tags: canadian history, prime minister]

Better Essays
998 words (2.9 pages)