Examining the Validity of Holocaust Sources Essay

Examining the Validity of Holocaust Sources Essay

Length: 1602 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There are multiple sources with divergent advantages and strategies, which allow humanity to have a clearer understanding of the holocaust; when compared, the resources’ limitations become apparent. The graphic novel Maus appears less valid compared to the diary, Night with its heinous detailed experience of life in a concentration camp. Conversely, Maus exhibits a strong expression of themes throughout the novel; comparably, this is a restriction in the textbook, Europe in the Contemporary world. Primary sources also aid in having an in-depth understanding of the holocaust, Smith’s text, contains, documented diaries and poems which each respectably uses techniques for the reader to grasp the execrable treatment of Jews. In conjunction, films present a different perspective of the holocaust; comparatively, the documentary Night and Fog seemingly has more credibility than the modern movie Defiance, although both films have their advantages. Furthermore, a combination of films and written works will yield a greater understanding of the holocaust. When examining such works as, Maus, and Night, each source uses different methods for the reader to comprehend the Nazi’s monstrous actions.
The graphic novel Maus has the advantage of showing the reader exactly what is happening without fear of misinterpretation from its message. It cleverly depicts each ethnicity as a different animal according to their stereotypical view during the holocaust . By drawing Jews and mice and Nazis as Cats, it simplifies conventional perspectives of past ethnicities. This allows the reader to understand the Nazi perspective of Jewish inferiority and reasons for anti-Semitism; the analogy is overt, cats kill mice. Graphic novels also have the advantage of ...


... middle of paper ...


...each other giving preeminent understanding. Each resource has its own strengths and weakness being more or less prevalent when compared to each other.




Works Cited
Defiance. Film. Directed by Edward Zwick. United States: Paramount Vantage, 2008.
Night and Fog. Film. Directed by Alain Resnais. France : Argos Films, 1955.
Smith, Bonnie G.. Europe in the contemporary world, 1900 to the present: a narrative history with documents. Boston: Bedford / St. Martin's, 2007.
Spiegelman, Art. Maus: a survivor's tale. New York: Pantheon Books, 19861991.
Spiegelman, Art. Maus II: a survivor's tale : and here my troubles began. New York: Pantheon Books, 1991.

Tammes, Peter. Survival of Jews during the Holocaust: the importance of different types of social resources
Int. J. Epidemiol. 2007 36: 330-335.
Wiesel, Elie. Night. Bantam ed. New York: Bantam Books, 1982.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Greatest Sources Of Information About The Holocaust Essay examples

- One of the best sources of information about the Holocaust is from someone who survived it, and we were lucky enough to hear 103 year-old Marko Feingold speak in Salzburg, Austria. The theme of his story was faith, and that eventually good people will be rewarded for their actions. I found an interview with him from 2012 where he describes his story in more detail. Marko was born in Vienna and moved with his brother to Italy in 1932, but was arrested by the Nazis in 1938 while he was visiting his family (Treves-Tchelet)....   [tags: Nazi Germany, Antisemitism, The Holocaust]

Powerful Essays
1015 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Advancing the Individual's Knowledge of the Holocaust

- By comparing, analyzing and questioning the validity of Maus I and II, Night, Night and Fog, nonfictional historical accounts and a poem, called Already Embraced by the Arm of Heavenly Solace, found in Europe in the Contemporary World, Schindler’s List and the Return to Auschwitz we may determine to what degree these sources serve to advance humanity’s understanding of the holocaust. The holocaust can be explained as the historical event in which the Nazi’s, who came to power in Germany in January 1933, and its collaborators murdered and persecuted approximately six million Jews....   [tags: Holocaust ]

Powerful Essays
2300 words (6.6 pages)

Argument And Validity Of Validity And Soundness Essay examples

- Paper Topic 3 For this paper I will break down the following argument in terms of validity and soundness: If an argument has a true conclusion, then it is both valid and sound. If an argument is sound, then it is valid. An argument will have a true conclusion if it is sound. An argument has a false conclusion only if it is valid. If an argument has a false conclusion, then it is invalid. An argument is both valid and invalid. Therefore, an argument is sound if and only if it is sound. I have prepared a dictionary to more clearly distinguish the different premises....   [tags: Logic, Argument, Validity, Soundness]

Powerful Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

Internal And External Validity Of A Research Study Essay

- Define internal and external validity. Discuss the importance of each. Internal validity refers to whether the effects observed in a study are due to the manipulation of the independent variable and not some other factor. In other words there is a causal relationship between the independent and dependent variable. External validity is the validity of generalized (causal) inferences in scientific research, usually based on experiments as experimental validity. In other words, it is the extent to which the results of a study can be generalized to other situations and to other people....   [tags: Scientific method, Validity, Reliability]

Powerful Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Reliability and Validity of Methods Used to Gather Evidence Essay

- There is no denying that students are bombarded daily with an exorbitant amount of data. It comes at them in every direction and it does not look like it will be lessening any time soon. As a matter of fact, I predict it will only get worse. More and more data is flung at them every day. With the Internet being a highly enriched source of information where one can find information about anything from cartoons to x-rays, determining what information is credible and what is not is a time-consuming task....   [tags: sources on information on the internet]

Powerful Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Causes of the Holocaust Essay examples

- Because of anti Semitism, Nazi propaganda, and the rise of Hitler’s message, the citizens of Germany embraced the Nazi Regime believing the allegations against the “unwanted Jews;” therefore, they were bystanders to the Holocaust by yielding the party power to move forward and annihilate the Jews. The German citizens made Jews their scapegoat for their economic and political problems. People like the Germans find others to blame other than themselves.This helped create Anti Semitism. David Downing suggest that, Jews were viewed as “ Christ killers”....   [tags: Holocaust Essays]

Powerful Essays
1564 words (4.5 pages)

Female Holocaust Experiences Essay

- The Holocaust continues to exist as a black mark in the history of Germany; through the government supported torture and extermination of both men and women, more than 6 million lost their lives. As a consequence of the collective tragedy for both sexes, there has been much debate pertaining to the focus of gender specific suffering in Holocaust literature; for this reason, the Holocaust accounts of women writers were largely ignored prior to the 1970’s. Many historians still refute disparities existed between the male and female experience....   [tags: Holocaust ]

Powerful Essays
2263 words (6.5 pages)

The Holocaust Essay

- When I visited the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, I was sickened to learn of horrifying Nazi activities intended to improve the Aryan race and to learn about the human body.� While many people are aware that the Nazis had these goals, most are uninformed of the means used to reach them.� I was also ignorant of the extent of their attempts to establish themselves as ideal specimens of the human race.� They used many unforgivable methods to accomplish these aims, some of which were revealed to me during my visit to the museum....   [tags: Holocaust Essays, The Nazis]

Free Essays
672 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on The Holocaust

- The Holocaust      When you think of the holocaust, what do you think about. Is it the millions of Jews lives that were taken. Or is it a great, but wicked speaker named Adolph Hitler. Adolph Hitler, Auschwitz, and American involvement are some key roles in the holocaust.      Adolph Hitler is probably one of the worst people ever to live. When people talk of evil deeds he is at the top of the list. He was a man of words, and could use them to his advantage. He had an ability to talk and make the Germans believe that the Jews were the reason for the problems in their country; so he gave them the idea to move them out....   [tags: Jewish Holocaust]

Free Essays
402 words (1.1 pages)

The Holocaust Essay

- The Holocaust The Holocaust, what is the true depth of the word. As sad as it may seem, it affected the lives of millions because of the hate inside of one certain group of people, the Nazi’s. Dehumanization is to deprive human qualities such as individuality or compassion. Victims of the Holocaust went through dehumanization simply to make the killing of others psychologically easy for the Nazi’s.      Many victims of the Holocaust suffered from various experiments which eventually led to the death....   [tags: Jewsish Holocaust Hitler Dehumanization Essays]

Powerful Essays
813 words (2.3 pages)