The Evolution of Law of Medical Negligence Essays

The Evolution of Law of Medical Negligence Essays

Length: 2104 words (6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

That the negligence is a relatively new legal concept is evident in that it was in 1883 when the foundation of negligence law was laid in Heaven v Pender (1,2), and only as late as in 1932 were all of its essential components came into definitive and widely acceptable shape in decision of the famous case of Donoghue v Stevenson (2, 3). Ever since then, the legal responsibilities embedded in and the scope and categories of negligence have been so constantly evolving and being expanded, that it is hardly to be overlooked that its relevancy and application to medical malpractice have assumed a significant role in modern medico-legal issues and centred on the debate. Nevertheless, it is beyond dispute that the progression of conception of medical negligence and expansion of corresponding legal responsibility have always been intimately intertwined with and subject to the transforming interaction of public policy and values, social conditions and sentiment, and community expectations. Lack of precise legal definition as contract or property and fraught with subjective terminology as reasonability, rationality and responsibility, negligence law (4) inevitably depends on interpretation on every constituent factor, rendering it prone to influential force of variable, even subtle, contemporary social and political values, change of which, resulted from novel circumstances as social development and technology advance, gives rise to the uncertainty and changes to the negligence law since it emergence (5).
Back to the 19th century, legal liability was restricted to actions, or actus reus, causing “direct and immediate injury to the person or damage to property as in a case of trespass”. (2) Beyond such liable action, most of damage raised u...


... middle of paper ...


...vers R. Litigation and the medical indemnity crisis. J Law Med. 2004 Nov;12(2):178-87.
40. Kessler DP, Summerton N, Graham JR. Effects of the medical liability system in Australia, the UK, and the USA. Lancet. 2006 Jul 15;368(9531):240-6.
41. Ipp DA, Australia. Dept. of the T. Review of the law of negligence: final report. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2002.
42. Derrington HD. Theory of negligence advanced in the High Court of Australia. The Australian Law Journal. 2004;78:595-611.
43. Sullivan v Moody (2001) 207 CLR 562
44. Kalokerinos v Burnet (1996) unreported, NSWCA, BC9600037.
45. Young v Central Aboriginal Congress Inc [2008] NTSC 47.
46. Millenson ML. Pushing the profession: how the news media turned patient safety into a priority. Qual Saf Health Care. 2002 Mar;11(1):57-63.
47. Alcock v Chief Constable of South Yorkshire Police [1992] AC 310.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Negligence Based On Tort Law Essay

- Issue To determine based on the case facts, if Alma can sue Norma for negligence based on tort law or not. Rule To establish negligence, it is imperative that three main conditions are to be satisfied. Firstly, it needs to be proved that the defendant had a duty to care directed towards the plaintiff. Secondly, there needs to be a breach of this duty due to the negligent conduct of the defendant. Thirdly, the plaintiff should have suffered harm due to the duty to care being breached by the defendant (Lindgren, 2011)....   [tags: Negligence, Tort, Tort law, Duty of care]

Term Papers
1035 words (3 pages)

Essay about The Ethics Of Negligence And Negligence

- Issue: Are the agents G Shepherd & Co. and the loose asbestos insulation assessor, Basil, liable in negligence for harm that has occurred to Roland and Belle’s family. Relevant Rules or law: The Tort of Negligence: The Negligence is the failure for someone to take reasonable care to prevent foreseeable injury, loss or damage to other people. It also contains both intended and unintended acts and omission. The Negligence action can only be liable to the plaintiff by counting the following three elements which are based on the balance of probabilities under common law and statute : 1 Duty of care The duty of care exists in the relevant situation where risk of harm or injury to plaintiffs was ‘...   [tags: Tort, Tort law, Negligence, Duty of care]

Term Papers
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Negligence, An Unintentional Careless Act Essay

- Negligence, as defined in Pearson’s Business Law in Canada, is an unintentional careless act or omission that causes injury to another. Negligence consists of four parts, of which the plaintiff has to prove to be able to have a successful lawsuit and potentially obtain compensation. First there is a duty of care: Who is one responsible for. Secondly there is breach of standard of care: What did the defendant do that was careless. Thirdly there is causation: Did the alleged careless act actually cause the harm....   [tags: Tort, Negligence, Tort law, Duty of care]

Term Papers
935 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about The Tort Of Negligence Case

- Tort of negligence QUESTION 1 ISSUE: Will Kim be successful in suing the Ipswich council. RULE: Under tort of negligence, in order to be successful, claim must require the following properties as per Law in Commerce (5th edition) Sweeney, B., O’Reilly, J. and Coleman, A. PRIVITY OF CONTRACT: According to law, suit can only be filed by the contracting parties. Third party (i.e. party not a part of contract) cannot file a suit except in certain specified situations such as in case of principal agency relationship....   [tags: Tort, Law, Negligence, Contract]

Term Papers
1327 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Tort Of Negligence And Vicarious Liability

- In this essay we are able to identify the Law of tort and present a case from New Zealand covering tort of negligence and vicarious liability. The word ‘tort’ is derived from the Latin term tortem to twist and implies conduct which is twisted or tortious. It now means a breach of some duty independent of contract giving rise to a civil cause of action and for which compensation is recoverable. A Tort is a species of civil injury or wrong no civil injury is to be classed as a tort unless the appropriate remedy for it is an action for damages....   [tags: Tort, Tort law, Negligence, Strict liability]

Term Papers
909 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on A Brief Note On The Tort Of Negligence

- Deceit is purposeful lying that causes a loss for the claimant or gain for the defendant. Conversely, a negligent misstatement is an incorrect, careless statement that causes loss for the claimant, in which the defendant acts on unreasonable grounds. In order to establish a negligent misstatement, the misstatement must fulfil the requirements for negligence. The tort of negligence involves three components: duty of care, breach of duty, and damages. Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932) is the origin of the tort of negligence in modern English law....   [tags: Tort, Tort law, Duty of care, Negligence]

Term Papers
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Negligence Should Not Be Classified As A Mens Rea Essay

- There are several disagreements over the meaning of negligence, but it can be said to occur when the defendant has behaved in the way in which a reasonable person would not . There exists numerous crimes for which the mens rea is negligence, although some argue negligence should not be classified as a mens rea, where most of these are minor crimes of a regulatory nature . The concept of negligence is undoubtedly complex due to the fact that it is not certain whether it deserves criminal punishment....   [tags: Crime, Criminal law, Criminology, Negligence]

Term Papers
1636 words (4.7 pages)

Medicine and the Law of Negligence Essay

- 1.0 Introduction The tort of negligence is designed to give citizens of society protection from personal injury damages caused by negligent action of someone else. The reform of negligence adopted from the ‘Ipp Report’ in 2003, have gone too far in trying to decrease the number of negligence claims against professionals. Due to these reforms of 2003, citizens who have legitimate claim to compensation, are now left with less chance to hold a professional liable for the damage caused. The reforms, which now make up the current law, must be again reformed to balance the litigation in favour of no one and to make sure that there are fair and just outcomes in the courts....   [tags: liability, reform, professionals]

Term Papers
1396 words (4 pages)

The Tort Of Negligence Is Unfair Essay example

- ‘Assumption of responsibility as the basis of liability for omissions in the tort of negligence is unfair’. Critically discuss by reference to one, or more, of the following theories of Tort law: deterrence, corrective justice, and distributive justice. In English law, there is no duty of the courts to impose liability for an omission or failure to act, despite the fact that there are compelling moral judgments for prevention of harm to another. The tort of negligence signifies that a person who causes damage by carelessness to others may be held liable to pay compensation....   [tags: Tort, Negligence, Duty of care, Contract]

Term Papers
1077 words (3.1 pages)

Evolution of Law Essay

- Evolution of Law The government our nation has established today has come a long way from its roots. Starting with the Napoleonic Code and eventually ending with the Ratified Constitution of the United States. Rome came to England bringing the Roman Code, thus law begins. The Roman Code was a rigid code that in reality did not change much. It required ample detail and was difficult to understand at times. For example, if there where five different murders all using five different colored knives....   [tags: Law]

Term Papers
832 words (2.4 pages)