Eugenic Decision-Making Essay

Eugenic Decision-Making Essay

Length: 1482 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Eugenics is defined, in some way or the other, as the process of reshaping the human race by determining the kinds of people who will be born. As such, there is much debate in the field of eugenics, with authors, like Philip Kitcher, who support laissez-faire or a minimalist approach of eugenics in which eugenic decision-making should be limited only to avoid neurological illnesses and in which parental free choice is valued. Gregory Stock’s essay, The Enhanced and Un-Enhanced, presents otherwise by supporting the position of maximalist eugenics, allowing individuals the full extent in the selection of genes. On the other hand, the film, Gattaca, raises major ethical problems by illustrating a dystopian society resulted by extensive eugenic decision-making. While both opposing views presents reasonable and valid arguments, the critique of eugenics will be well-debated in the foreseeable future, and as we will examine, drawing a discrete line between these two positions is no simple task.
In the book, The Lives to Come, Philip Kitcher presents his view of laissez-faire eugenics in which eugenic decisions should be made primarily by a minimal regulated market of individuals without any government coercion. In defending his position of minimalist and responsible eugenic decisions, Kitcher wants to avoid the dangers that accompany with a laissez-faire or parental free choice eugenic approach. One problem involves a systematic prejudice of society due to a lack of government regulation. Laissez-faire eugenics calls for total reproductive freedom in which parents are able to make decisions concerning what traits they want their children to have according to personal preferences (1, Kitcher, p.197). Their values can be bias in which t...


... middle of paper ...


... the privileged and the under-privileged. This would inevitably open a channel to discrimination and violation of basic human rights, as presented by the dangers of laissez-faire eugenics that Kitcher wants to avoid. A minimalist approach accompanied by Kitcher’s view of a responsible and utopian eugenic decision-making will be the most effective way to prevent such dangers by providing equal opportunity for all individuals to achieve their goals and aspirations.
Society needs to come to an overall understanding that striving for a utopian world without any ethical or moral guidelines will only bring about consequences such as discrimination or a violation of individual freedom. However, with responsible eugenic decision-making, society is better able to address these issues and dangers in a future that is characterized by an expansion of science and technology.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Decision Making As A Decision

- Decision making is something every manager has to deal with in the workplace. It is one of the main components of their job and they need to possess the knowledge to make effective decisions for the organization. Dessler (2012) defines decision making as “the process of developing and analyzing alternatives and making a choice (Dessler, 2012). In the process of making decisions, the manager must be aware of the impact the decision will have on the organization and the employees. Yukl (1990) states that “before making a decision, a manager must determine whether to involve other people in the decision process” (Yukl 1990)....   [tags: Decision making, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
843 words (2.4 pages)

Decision Making Process For Making Decisions Essay

- It does not matter what company you work for or what career path you choose you have to have a standard way of making decisions. Decision making can be identified as the thought process which results in the selection of a course of action among numerous alternative scenarios (Pennino, 2002). Each decision making process generates a final choice that may or may not bring about action. For that reason, decision making process is the majority critical process in any organization. Decision making is one of the most important activities of management and is an enormous part of any process of implementation....   [tags: Decision making, Cognition]

Strong Essays
709 words (2 pages)

Decision Making : Decision Quality Essay

- In order for employees to be empowered, there are some decisions that must be made. The first factor is the importance of decision quality. Importance of decision quality is used when determining If one decision will be better than another. An of this would be if a supervisor decided to sign a letter using black or blue ink. The decision on whether he will use Black or blue ink probably not make a difference in the organization. This importance of decision quality is low and needs little time to be addressed....   [tags: Decision making, Decision theory, Risk]

Strong Essays
726 words (2.1 pages)

Decision Making : Making An Individual Essay

- DECISION MAKING STYLE Decision making is picking best alternative out of numerous after cautious thought that best suits the reason. It is a piece of psychological deduction in which best option is picked in view of the experience, instinct or information of an individual. In this way, it additionally implies choosing the option with more chance of being successful, so that risk in the future could be declined. (Ahmed, Omotunde, Habeeb, 2012) Creative decision making is the best way to stay ahead of adversaries.( It is described as the way individuals utilize sources, knowledge, methods and think of a superior method to accomplish something....   [tags: Decision making, Cognition, Critical thinking]

Strong Essays
913 words (2.6 pages)

Ethical Decision Making And Ethical Decisions Essay example

- Introduction It is essential for workers in health and social services to apply critical thinking skills in decision making. In particular, social workers have to make decisions on daily basis (Dolgoff, Harrington, & Loewenberg, 2012). Often, choices that confront social workers all contain positive and negative features, and it is upon one to weight and assess the known options and outcomes prior to choosing the one that is seemingly most ethical (Chase, 2015). The case of Jordan Knight, the counsellor, and Bruce Bane, his client, provides an example of case where making ethical judgements would raise interest in practice....   [tags: Ethics, Decision making, Decision making software]

Strong Essays
1752 words (5 pages)

Essay on The Family Decision Making Model

- The EHDI Family Decision-Making Model (Figure 1) was created to provide a graphic illustration of the study findings, and to synthesize concepts, categories and relationships. Our first research question asked, “How do decisions relate to the family context of perspective, priorities, values, personality and resources?” In the EHDI Family Decision-Making Model, the context of family is the system, or environment, in which decision-making operates, represented by a core circle. Demographic features related to decision-making included the family’s socio-economic level, the child’s level of hearing, and availability of services....   [tags: Decision making, Decision making software]

Strong Essays
1586 words (4.5 pages)

Evaluating The Decision Making Process Essay

- Hitting roadblocks and problems while attempting to accomplish a task or while conducting business is a fact of life. Managers and leaders have numerous responsibilities and decisions that they face each day during the normal course of business. Some of these decisions are small, such as delegating a task to an appropriate subordinate. Other decisions are large, such as formulating a strategy that can affect the lives of thousands of employees within the organization and companies up and down the supply chain....   [tags: Decision making, Decision theory]

Strong Essays
1068 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Decision Making

- Decision making can be described as a process of making a decision or decisions, based on choices made amongst two or more competing course of actions. The ‘Decision making’ also requires making a define choice between two or more alternatives course of actions that are available. In every decision making, there is said to be a positive and negative outcome as future consequence(s). The importance of decision making in individual daily life and in organization level was demonstrated by two scientists, Arkes and Hammond (1992), in ‘Judgment and Decision making’ indentified the four types of information which decision maker requires constructing a decision tree....   [tags: Decision Making]

Strong Essays
3072 words (8.8 pages)

Decision-Making Models Essay

- Decision-Making Models Negotiations and decisions are a part of everyday business. In order to make a successful decision, it is necessary to understand how to make rational and sound decisions. Decisions that are rash, made on snap judgments, and past experiences can prove detrimental to a business. A deficit in basic thinking and decision making is felt at all levels of an organization (Gary, 1997). Decisions can have long term and short term impacts on organizations and their world in which they exist (Turner & Dean, 2008)....   [tags: Decision Making]

Strong Essays
971 words (2.8 pages)

Decision Making Essay example

- Decision-making models, or the path that one would choose in his or her decision-making, is heavily relied on the information one has received. By having all the correct information available, decision-making becomes an easier task. The model in which one would base his or her decision-making upon can be analyzed into six different factors: the problem at hand, the goals that want to be reached, alternatives, pros and cons, decision(s), and reason(s) behind the decision(s). According to Richard W....   [tags: Business Decision Making]

Strong Essays
836 words (2.4 pages)