What are your thoughts on Andrew Carnegie and his way of incorporating the word “Gospel” in his work? Does this automatically make him a person who seems to emphasize morality and ethics? Carnegie believed that industrialization was the beginning of the distinction between the “wealthy” and the “poor” social classes. Robert Reich and Carnegie would most likely agree on the average man having the opportunity to thrive. However, Carl Marx and Carnegie views on property, wealth, and competition were complete opposites. Both writers agreed on issues regarding the common man in the industrial era and its problems. Marx claimed that changing history in the industrial era would bring a new era. On the other hand, Carnegie believed that there should be no changes and that society should just learn to accept it. Carl Marx would regard Carnegie as a person who could care less about the improvement of the common people. In other words, Carnegie was not a person who was concerned about questions of morality and ethical behavior.
Andrew Carnegie was a member of America’s upper-class. He immigrated from Scotland and later opened up his own Steel business, which opened up a series of opportunities for him to prosper and become wealthy. Carnegie was aware of the different social classes, but was certain that it was not a threat to the people of the American society. He exclaims, “ …But good, has come to the race from the accumulation of wealth by those who have the ability and energy that produce it” (Jacobus 488). As a person who is biased on the wealthy community, he placed little regard for the issues that the “common man” had to endure. For instance, he claims, “ Of every thousand dollars spent in so-called charity to-d...
... middle of paper ...
...common property, into the property of all members of society, personal property is not thereby transformed into social property. The social character of the property is changed and it loses its class-character.” (Jacobus 463). Losing class- character would help dissolve the potential superiorness of the bourgeoisie class. This would possibly lead to a society that cares about everyone, or in other words a society that could care less about economic and social class.
In conclusion, all these ideas and opinions consist of a consistent message that Andrew Carnegie is a person who could care less about the ethical and moral behavior invested upon the ideas of the common man and their position in society. On the other hand, Marx is a person who cares more about the improvement of all people in society to become someone who is wealthy and can possibly better the economy.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- To Have Wealth There Is a Long Way, Let Me Start Walking. Between poverty and success are many steps that people have to overcome to be successful. People who live in poverty have to solve first base things such as food, health, the place to live, and so on. Compered poor people with other people who have base things, poor people have a big challenge to be successful. Living in poverty can affect the way people think, their motivation led to them to lack goals because the see the big way to be successful.... [tags: Poverty, Want, Andrew Carnegie]
1738 words (5 pages)
- Andrew Carnegie, Henry Clay Frick and the Homestead Strike Industrialists Andrew Carnegie and Henry Clay Frick could not have come from more different backgrounds. Carnegie was born in the Scottish town of Dunfermline to a very poor family in 1835. When he was 12 years old, his father, a weaver, decided to move the family to the United States in search of better prospects, arriving at what was then the municipality of Allegheny, Pennsylvania, now part of Pittsburgh’s North Side. By that time, Pittsburgh was already known as a major center for the production of steel and other metals.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Homestead Strike]
1024 words (2.9 pages)
- The beginning was very meager for young Andrew Carnegie born in a small town named Dunfermline in Scotland on November 25th 1835. His father was a hand loom weaver with an immense shroud of pride in his trade and his mother a seamstress who worked with local shoemakers. (Bio. A&E Television Networks) The family was able to survive comfortably for the early years of young Andrews’s life by working in the trades they were skilled in until industry spread to Dunfermline. Andrew’s morals and personality was developed early on in life.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Homestead Strike]
2092 words (6 pages)
- “A hero is someone who has given their life to something bigger than oneself.” Andrew Carnegie, a philanthropist who has helped hundreds. But there is a side of him that not many knew. Is Andrew Carnegie a hero. Andrew Carnegie was born in Dunfermline, Scotland. He and his family were in poverty, living in an attic of a weavers cottage. For a better life, his family moved to America. There Carnegie started working as a bobbin boy. Carnegie later became locally famous, and was later given a well paying job.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Warren Buffett, Carnegie library]
796 words (2.3 pages)
- During the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the strength of the U.S. economy began transitioning from agricultural to industry. A variety of factors sparked this industrial revolution, but the genius industrial leaders, particularly Andrew Carnegie, allowed big business to take over and dominate the economy. As evidenced in Andrew Carnegie and the Rise of Big Business by Harold C. Livesay, Carnegie mastered and understood the organizational structures and technological factors necessary to run a profitable business.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Homestead Strike]
1192 words (3.4 pages)
- “You cannot push anyone up a ladder unless he be willing to climb a little himself.” This was Andrew Carnegie’s theory that gave him his rise to power in the late 1800’s as well as his immense wealth. Although a native of Scotland, Carnegie moved to America at age 12 on borrowed money with his mother, father, and younger brother. Throughout his life, he constantly worked hard to provide for his impoverished family, saving money little by little to pay back the money they owed for their voyage to America.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Carnegie Steel Company]
1827 words (5.2 pages)
- Andrew Carnegie was a multimillionaire tycoon who, along with the likes of John Rockefeller and J.P. Morgan, is ranked highly in the pantheon of American industrialists. He innovated and perfected the process of “horizontal integration” in industry and made a fortune selling his massively successful Carnegie Steel Corporation at the turn of the 20th century. However, there is more that paints the picture of this man’s success than his industrial pursuits. His origins as an obscure dream seeker from Scotland are what make his rise to fame and fortune all the more endearing.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie, Philanthropy]
708 words (2 pages)
- What is the American Dream. According to Webster the American Dream is the ideal according to which equality of opportunity permits any American to aspire to high attainment and material success. Andrew Carnegie is the epitome of the American Dream because he is a classic example of rags to riches success story. He seemed to be touched by an angel. No matter what was wrong with the world, Andrew Carnegie was to consistently capitalize on success. Andrew Carnegie was born in Dunfermline, Scotland, in 1835.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie]
1051 words (3 pages)
- What is the American Dream. There are a myriad of aspects to it, but one general idea: the ideal life. It is making a lot of money, being respected, and triumphing difficult situations. The American Dream has been pursued by many, but only few make it all the way. One very good example of the American Dream is Andrew Carnegie, the founder of what is known as U.S. Steel. Carnegie was born in Scotland to a poor family. As a teen, he emigrated from Scotland to the United States. He was portrayed as a hard working individual who was very intelligent and disciplined.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie]
380 words (1.1 pages)
- Biography of Andrew Carnegie Andrew Carnegie was born into a poor working class family living in the town of Dunfermline, Scotland, in 1835. His father operated a small hand looming business located in the family home. The Carnegies was literate, well read, and active in the politics of the day. It was a time of repression of the Scottish worker by the Government, the employers, and the culture. Rebellious in thought as well as actively participating in protests was part of the Carnegie family life style.... [tags: Andrew Carnegie Management Wealth Essays]
3956 words (11.3 pages)