The Ethics Of The Sports Council Mandate Genome Editing Essay

The Ethics Of The Sports Council Mandate Genome Editing Essay

Length: 767 words (2.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

With human germline editing also emerges another significant ethical issue of eugenics. With use of CRISPR /Cas9 intervention many phenotypic characteristics that has a genetic component, apart from environment could be altered. For example, the technique could be used to enhance performance of athletes or alter colour of the eye. Generally, gene therapy looks to improve the health of a patient for his/her own benefit, but it may happen in the future that the sports council mandate genome editing of genes related to athletes and enhancing their skills (Rodriguez,2016). The ethical debate stems from the fact that since the intervention is done during development and it is questionable that who gets to decide (Gebelhoff, 2016 ; Cyranoski, 2015). Further, there will be a problem if some populations or individually may be enhanced genetically. These enhanced people will have advantage over others creating an unequal society (Roderiguez,2016; Cyranoski, 2015). However, the larger discussion needs to address whether these gene editing interventions on human lives will lead to reemergence of eugenics. Eugenics, is a social philosophy advocating the improvement of human genetic traits through the promotion of higher rates of sexual reproduction for people with desired traits (positive eugenics), or reduced rates of sexual reproduction and sterilization of people with less-desired or undesired traits (negative eugenics) (Rodriguez,2016). With gene editing technology scientists are confident that someday they can eliminate genetic disorders in humans. For claims like this there are dozens of daunting ethical questions - Wouldn’t editing out inheritable traits from the human population simply amount to eugenics? Could there be unanticipate...


... middle of paper ...


...s a disease, we will begin to lose the genetic diversity of humanity, which has enabled the valuable and eccentric contributions of the differently abled to society (Wesley, 2016). Some familiar names of people thought to have had some form of defect (example autism) include Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Thomas Jefferson, Isaac Newton, and Michelangelo. Disability is a social construct and so is eugenics that stigmatizes those who differ from general populace (Weintraub, 2015). We should not be picking and choosing the aspects of a person that we deem to be valuable. We should accept the entire person for who they are, without trying to make them more like ourselves. This is not to say that we should shy away from CRISPR genetic editing altogether, but rather that we should be very careful about situations in which we choose to employ it.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Human Genome Project ( Hgp ) Essay

- The Human Genome Project (HGP) is a Multinational, collaborative research program whose goal was to complete mapping and understanding of all the genes present in the human being. The commencement of Human Genome Project began in 1988, with the support of the National Institute of Health (NIH) and Department of Energy (DOE). The Initial phase of the Human Genome Project (1990’s) relied on the findings and techniques such as Site-specific Restriction enzymes, positional cloning, Polymerase chain reaction, Fluorescence In-Situ Hybridization (FISH ) and STS ( sequence Tagged site )determination, used in early 1970-1980’s, to study and sequence genes....   [tags: DNA, Genetics, Human Genome Project, Human genome]

Better Essays
1091 words (3.1 pages)

The Phoenix City Council Meeting Essay

- The Phoenix City Council Meeting The Phoenix City Council meeting stood packed with attendees ranging from council men and women, lawyers, (basically elderly) interested citizens, neighborhood representatives, owners of businesses, and many others firm on playing a undeviating role in the due process of local government. The meeting began with an invocation from the pastor of a local church invited to pray by the Mayor Stanton. Then following was a pledge to the flag and then the mayor carries the motion....   [tags: elderly, mayor, council]

Better Essays
1426 words (4.1 pages)

The Genome Surgery, By Susan Young Essay

- Eight percent of our genome is made up of retrovirus DNA. These are viruses that have been passed down for so long that most have mutated and are held powerless in your system. But some retroviruses can take on new life, such as in people with HIV and several viruses that trigger cancer. It’s as been a mission and a mystery for the scientists to find the cure for the deadliest diseases. Which leads to the genome surgery and genome editing to help in the process of finding an alternative to manipulate the DNA to stop the disease before it started....   [tags: DNA, Genetics, Gene, Genome]

Better Essays
731 words (2.1 pages)

The Ability to Map a Human Genome Essay

- Science is a field of study that is always evolving and changing with time and new discoveries. New studies in medicine are constantly improving, such as the flu shot, which changes every year to protect America’s population against influenza. With all the adventure into the unknown comes the worry of taking science too far. Also, not letting people’s bodies and life take its natural course is a fear of genetic testing. While others believe the improvements to using genetic tests will benefit society drastically....   [tags: genome, genetics, genetic testing]

Better Essays
2574 words (7.4 pages)

The Human Genome Project Commenced Essay example

- The Human Genome Project commenced in 1990, with the goal of sequencing the entire human genome within 25 years. This was successfully completed in the early 2000s due to widespread research efforts and advancements in computing technology (4). With this knowledge, researchers shifted their focus to individual genes; particularly, the function of the proteins they coded for. “Gene knockout” is the general term used for synthetically inactivating a gene of interest. There are three basic approaches for gene-inactivation: [i] take a normal (wild type) gene and replace it with a nonfunctional sequence (which will be discussed below), [ii] express another allele that codes for an inhibitory prot...   [tags: DNA, Gene, Genetics, Genome]

Better Essays
919 words (2.6 pages)

The Council Of Trent : Ayik Malual Essay

- The Council of Trent - Ayik Malual The Council of Trent played a significant role in determining the result of the reformation. It was a gathering of the Priests, Bishops and Cardinals to discuss our matters of faith and determined the changes. It was held between december 1545-1563 under the support of three different Popes. (Paul III, Julius IIII, and Pius IV) in Trento & Bologna (Italy). The council being formed was a response to the protestants reformation, so they read and listened to their propositions....   [tags: Catholic Church, Christianity, Council of Trent]

Better Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

The Debate For Modifying The Human Genome Essay

- Perhaps one of the most controversial topics to be addressed in the modern age concerns the ethicality of being able to “edit” our species. The debate for modifying the human genome asks us to consider the very core of our nature and the morality behind deliberately changing our written genetic code to produce “superior” offspring. For example, what kinds of consequences could result from altering the precise code of our DNA. Some scientists ask whether altering the genome of fetuses or adults will produce unwanted results that could end up being passed down through generations, causing more harm than good....   [tags: DNA, Genetics, Gene, Human genome]

Better Essays
2449 words (7 pages)

Essay on The Security Council As A Global Security

- This would allow small countries to bring issues to the global stage that would allow communication to occur among the security council members to either decide to create a resolution to fix it or not considerate as a global security issue. Having this communication among the council, it allows more of a focus on world peace instead of what the main six council members consider as threats to them. Some critics have said that the Security Council is rather limiting from the larger United Nations body by not reforming and allowing more countries that are more influential today or need the support of a global audience to ensure global peace and their ideals (Monteleone)....   [tags: United Nations, United Nations Security Council]

Better Essays
1775 words (5.1 pages)

Essay about Morality And The Human Genome Project

- Morality and the Human Genome Project      Does the Human Genome Project affect the moral standards of society. Can the information produced by it become a beneficial asset or a moral evil. For example, in a genetic race or class distinction the use of the X chromosome markers can be used for the identification of a persons ethnicity or class (Murphy,34). A seemingly harmless collection of information from the advancement of the Human Genome Project. But, lets assume this information is used to explore ways to deny entry into countries, determine social class, or even who gets preferential treatment....   [tags: Science Human Genome Ethics Essays]

Better Essays
1359 words (3.9 pages)

The Human Genome Project Essay

- The Human Genome Project Now more than ever it is not uncommon to hear of scientific barriers being crossed. This is seen through, "a scientific research effort . . . currently under way which is unlike anything ever before attempted. International in its scope, it is enormously expensive and, if successful, could lead to our ultimate control of human disease, aging, and death. It is nothing short of a revolution against the way science has traditionally progressed"1 . This statement of Thomas Lee refers to a massive scientific undertaking known as the human genome project, an endeavor that aims to discover each and every intricacy of human genetics....   [tags: Genome Science biology Essays]

Better Essays
2348 words (6.7 pages)