Mr. Middleton, a journalist, compiled an article describing, in his opinion, the flaws of the Endangered Species Act. He then attempts to back his opinion with studied analyses, researched facts, and testimonies. To summarize Middleton’s (2011) perspective, “Rather than provide incentives for conservation and environmental stewardship, the Endangered Species Act punishes those whose property contains land that might be used as habitat by endangered and threatened species” (p. 79). This quote is broad and generalized yet draws in readers and forces Middleton to spend the rest of the article backing this statement with more logic based facts.
The author reasons with his thesis by focusing on three main points: lenient standard for becoming a citizen plaintiff, litigation can bring handsome rewards, and endangered species act being imposed and all costs. In section titled The Endangered Species Act’s Lenient Standard for Becoming a Citizen Plaintiff Middleton (2011) paraphrases the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service by saying, “The Endangered Species Act’s otherwise minimal pleading requirements have resulted [in]… a ‘cycle of litigation’ that is ‘endless, and is very expensive, thus diverting resources ...
... middle of paper ...
...hor’s perspective. Hopefully they will be able to take away that the author cares about all species and just wants them to be defended properly without money getting in the way. Whether the reader agrees or disagrees with his suggested methods on fixing the issue isn’t nearly as important as realizing that endangered animals should be defended properly. The last point the reader may take away is that human lives are more important than animal lives, yet animal lives are more important than human convenience.
In conclusion, Middleton did an excellent job compiling an article describing the currently flaws in the Endangered Species Act. Despite the authors many good points, I believe his solutions were lacking and rewriting of the act is needed. However, it was nice to see an author coherently write on a subject he seemed well informed on in a fairly non-biased manner.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Endangered Species Act was established in 1973 to protect endangered species. Climate change, caused by anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions, has serious consequences for many species, but it is a great concern for polar bears. Polar bear populations are susceptible to climate change, hunting, and habitat alteration. They are the world’s largest terrestrial carnivore and because of their strength polar bears are the symbol of the Arctic. Their physical characteristics make polar bears a perfect fit for the arctic.... [tags: Endangered Species]
1288 words (3.7 pages)
- The Endangered Species Act of 1973 Our world is very unique. We share the world with all sorts of creatures from animals of all sizes, and shapes. Creatures that crawl, slide, run, swim, fly, or burrow. As scientists expand their knowledge about the world they unmask many types of species living on this planet. Scientist has discovered about 1.7 million species, and 13,000 more species are being found every year. It is very rare to know that there are many unknown animals, such as large birds or even mammals, but there could be million little creatures wanting to be discovered such as insects, spiders, shellfish, and even worms.... [tags: Endangered species, Extinction, Species, Hunting]
2418 words (6.9 pages)
- In the year 1973, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) was instituted in order to bring attention to the issue of species that are in danger of extinction as well as to provide conservation of species that are endangered or threatened. Currently, there are around 2,245 species that the Endangered Species Act lists as either endangered or threatened throughout the world, many of which are found in the United States ecosystems and a handful that are only found in foreign ecosystems (Ehrlich 12). Because of the considerable number of endangered species, people should be aware of endangered species and help to protect these creatures society, as their unnatural extinction due to our actions and negl... [tags: Extinction, Endangered species, Biodiversity]
2151 words (6.1 pages)
- A species of plant or animal classified as endangered is a species that faces the risk extinction. Their possible extinction can be attributed to human activity, climate change, critical habitat loss, disruption in predator/prey ratio, and many other factors. The Endangered Species Act (ESA), established in 1973, is a federal mandate that requires the endangered species to be listed and subsequently protected to avoid future extinction of the species - included is the protection of their critical habitat.... [tags: Endangered species, Species, IUCN Red List]
864 words (2.5 pages)
- The latter half of the twentieth century was host to the greatest and most widespread advancements in environmental awareness in human history. It was during this time that people began to consider the effects of their polluting cars and their wasteful habits. People began to realize that something must be done to curb humans’ negative impacts on their surroundings and thus the environmental movement was born. One of the most important factors that resulted from this expansion of environmental consciousness occurring over the last several decades has been the protection of endangered species.... [tags: CITES, Endangered Species Act ]
2291 words (6.5 pages)
- Protecting the Endangered The beautiful species of the wild are being endangered more and more each day. Because of the increase of endangered wildlife society now faces several extinctions therefore, to prevent this problem, the government should pass laws or policies that provide greater protection and preservation, provide more information about endangered species, give more publicity to the issue and support charities. “An endangered species is one whose numbers are so small that it is at risk of extinction” (Do Something 2015).... [tags: Endangered species, Extinction, Species, Plant]
1548 words (4.4 pages)
- When the congress passed the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in 1973, it recognized that ecological and scientific valued our nation and its people. It also expressed concern that many of our nation’s native plants and animals were in danger of becoming extinct. The purpose of ESA is to protect and recover species in their ecosystems, for which they have lived on. Under the ESA, species are specified into two categories; endangered or threatened. ‘Endangered’ means a species that is in danger of becoming extinct and has exceeded all of its range.... [tags: Endangered Species Act, effectiveness, extinct]
1408 words (4 pages)
- Have you ever seen a Philippine eagle flying graciously through the wild and lush jungles of the Philippines. Have you ever caught a glimpse of the alluring, pristine and stunning Kakapo bird flying freely in the small island of New Zealand before. If not, then you are fortunate as these marvellous birds are slowly recovering from their severe endangerment. However, many beautiful and ravishing animals that reside in the United States may never be seen again. This is because the United States Government does not provide adequate, efficient or productive methods to save these species and the government desperately needs to improve their methods and ways.... [tags: Animals, Endangered Species]
1601 words (4.6 pages)
- The earth has experienced many unexpected outcomes over the years. The changes on earth have affected many animals, plants, and ecosystems. Different kinds of species stay involved with the dramatic changes the earth has went through. The past includes climate changes, distinctions, meteorites, and evolution processes. The changes on earth will always impact different species no matter where the species occupies. The changes on earth have led to many species becoming endangered. Endangered species continue to increase and without help, earth’s species will become distinct.... [tags: Species, Extinction, Endangered species, Hunting]
984 words (2.8 pages)
- Code of Ethics In order to make certain that the animals are treated in a humane and ethical way, researchers are regulated and monitored by various government agencies. The US Department of Agriculture is responsible for enforcing the Animal Welfare Act and conducts unannounced inspections of research facilities. If the research is a grant recipient, the National Institutes of Health would be responsible for the regulation as well. The American Association for the Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care (AAALAC) is responsible for setting the standards for research institutions.... [tags: Papers]
790 words (2.3 pages)
- A Study Of The Behavior Of Individuals And Their Mental Processes
- What Makes A Good Writer Great?
- Unionization Of The Nursing Staff
- The Importance Of An Organization 's Message
- Effective Leadership Is Not About Making Speeches Or Being Liked
- The Mentoring Process At A Four Year University Teacher Training Program