At the turn of the new century, activists begun to protest the morality of animal experimentation: “… such methodology is far too cruel on beast, it cannot better mankind, but its lead to it demise…” Despite the rising concern for animal safety in laboratory research, federal legislations approved the practice. According to the federal bureaucrats, it is an essential tool to improve our current medical knowledge. Hence, most of the tested animals have a relatively shorter life span than human. Thus, it allows to test long-term disease in a smaller timeframe. Nonetheless, animal enthusiast request the banishment of animal experimentation in laboratory. Ergo, with our current technology, researchers are capable to reproduce the same result using alternative methods, such as stem cell manipulation. However, regardless of the modern innovation, the Tories suggest the continuation of the practice. They argue: “ animal testing is a necessary evil to further mankind’s knowledge, and nothing more.” Nevertheless, both views are extreme, and prevent a constructive discussion on the subject matter. Therefore, it is imperative to consider a common ground in the debate and achieves a mutual respect between the test subjects and the researchers, which is the sole basis of this essay. Albeit, the determinant of a just ethic for animal experimentation is vague, and it is easily sway according to the whim of an individual.
For instance, conservative researchers underestimate animal intelligence, as such they considers a creature’s moral status to be equivalent to an inanimate object. Hence, unlike human, beast cannot weigh the consequences of its actions. Simply, beasts do not have the leisure to choose. Following such train of though, it is t...
... middle of paper ...
...oes the respect is mutual toward non-animal being, such as bacteria, or virus? Subsequently, these particular question acknowledges the weaknesses in the new conclusion of the debate. From the vast species of the animal kingdom, few primates and rodents species are chosen because these creatures are not domesticated by human. Evidently, it means that society does not have any cultural attachment to them, unlike others animal. As such, there isn’t any incentive to protect their rights. Likewise, microscopic organism, such as bacteria or virus are demonized as a pest, thus their moral rights are not values as well. However, it is far from the truth. Knowing the ongoing directions of the debate, it is imperative to better define the moral status of not only animal, but any living being altogether in order to establish a general code of conduct for future researchers.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- At the turn of the new century, activists begun to protest the morality of animal experimentation: “… such methodology is far too cruel on beast, it cannot better mankind, but its lead to it demise…” Despite the rising concern for animal safety in laboratory research, federal legislations approved the practice. According to the federal bureaucrats, it is an essential tool to improve our current medical knowledge. Hence, most of the tested animals have a relatively shorter life span than human.... [tags: Animal rights, Human, Primate, Animal testing]
755 words (2.2 pages)
- An ongoing conflict among the human species is that of animal cruelty, whether it be by scientific experiments, tests, or research. I frequently wonder, do the individuals performing these atrocious tasks ask themselves if what he/she is doing is ethically correct. I believe that it is not right to treat animals in such an inhumane manner, but to treat them as our own kind, for they are clever, spirited beings. These helpless animals cannot defend themselves against abuse. In my opinion, it is morally appropriate to grant the same rights to animals as we human beings acquire and to end, or even just to minimize, animal cruelty in laboratories.... [tags: ethics, animal rights, rhetorical]
731 words (2.1 pages)
- Animals have long been used for research and testing purposes dating back to as early as the nineteenth century() . Animals are often the subjects of experiments in the field of science in order to gain further knowledge about human disease as well as testing the safety of potential human treatments. Animals such as mice and rats are amongst the most commonly used subjects due to their physiological and genetic similarities with humans, which is why using animals for these scientific purposes can be tremendously helpful for furthering advancement in the medical field.... [tags: Ethics, Morality, Immanuel Kant, Animal rights]
1176 words (3.4 pages)
- Two months ago I went to see the film “Rise of the Planet of Apes” at the theater. This film was about chimpanzees that were exposed to animal research to find a cure for Alzheimer’s disease. Consequently, one of the chimpanzees tested with the Alzheimer’s cure developed an enhanced genetic intelligence that lead to the freedom of the other captive chimpanzees. Although this film was a science fiction movie, during the film, there were scenes that depicted cruelty towards chimpanzees. These scenes made me concerned about how inhumane people are towards research chimpanzees.... [tags: Ethics, Animal Cruelty, Chimpanzees]
1546 words (4.4 pages)
- The moral status of animals is an issue of much debate in Science. According to The Royal Society, the oldest scientific academy nowadays, it would have been impossible for science and medicine to develop so without animal research (“The Use of Non-Human Animals in Research”, 2004). Nevertheless, do the human medical benefits really justify the animal suffering in animal research. If so, what should are the possible considerations and limitations related to the matter. It appears to be a challenge to find common ground concerning the above questions.... [tags: animals, suffering, health, experimentation, moral]
1540 words (4.4 pages)
- Every year, a number of animals are locked up and subjected to tests that cause them pain and even death. Animal experimentation is a procedure whereby non-animals are tested and used to develop treatments, check the safety of products for human use, and other commercial and biomedical uses (Woods 24). It is estimated that, over 26 million animals are used every year in the United States for animal experiments. Animal testing is a controversial topic and like any other contentious subject, it faces a great number of support and opposition depending on human perception.... [tags: ethics, morality, research]
1020 words (2.9 pages)
- For centuries mankind has experimented on animals for a number of different reasons. Early experimentation with animals was originally born out of curiosity but eventually became a necessity to find medicines to cure viruses and a myriad of illnesses. If not for the existence of animals, humans would be left to experiment on themselves at a high rate which would create a worldwide moral dilemma. Such a dilemma could be dictated based on the question of who should be chosen for experimentation; should it be a particular race or class of people.... [tags: Biology, Animal, Testing, Ethics]
1212 words (3.5 pages)
- Sabiha Yasmeen Khan Workshop Leader: Betsy Rogers ENGL 109: Introduction to Academic Writing Section 105 Comparison Essay: The Pain of Animals & Enemies of Science For centuries scientists have used animals to study the causes of diseases; to test drugs, vaccines and surgical techniques; and to evaluate the safety of chemicals used in pesticides, cosmetics and other products. However, many scientists amongst animal- right activists forbid the use of animals in scientific research regardless how many illnesses are eliminated through the use of animals in scientific research.... [tags: Ethics]
940 words (2.7 pages)
- Animal Experimentation and Research In the basement of the psychology department here, a poster hangs on the wall; on it is a picture of two white lab rats and a caption that reads, ?They?ve saved more lives than 911.. This poster hangs on the wall of the room where I performed brain surgery on a rat. Many people would be morally opposed to this and any other form of animal research and experimentation and feel that it should be banned. This heated debate has been going on for centuries with each side possessing strong arguments.... [tags: Ethics Morals Essays Papers]
2489 words (7.1 pages)
- The ethics behind using animals for experiments and tests has been questioned and debated for years. Many people believe that animal experimentations can be crucial towards medical breakthroughs such as the cure for cancer, HIV/AIDS or asthma. Meanwhile others argue that animals that are used to test cosmetics such as make-up and perfumes are inhuman because is not going to help improve the human race. Animals suffer through multiple types of torture such as being forced to ingest poisonous chemicals, blinded, burned, stapled, and infected with disease viruses.... [tags: ethics, experimentation, cosmetics, medicine]
1121 words (3.2 pages)