Essay on Ethical Limitations Of Genetic Engineering

Essay on Ethical Limitations Of Genetic Engineering

Length: 2155 words (6.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Dan W. Brock ambitiously sets out to see if there are conditions under the idea if genetically engineering humans offspring is morally permissible and if there are any moral limitations that constrain the use of genetic engineering. In “Genetic Engineering”, he defines the obvious complications first and foremost on this topic. He states that since this is a new medical experiment, there is still an enormous amount of work that lies ahead to understand the specific genes that not only contribute to human disease and disability, but also the multitude of complex physical, cognitive, emotional, and behavioral traits of a normal, functioning human being. He then goes on to state the various uses of genetic engineering, which include the preventative to diseases, the overall extinction of disabilities, the enhancement of normal human functions, and the general impact of genetic engineering on the norms of fairness and inequality. However, there are cases that defy these implications. “No one can confidently predict the rate at which that understanding will be achieved in the future nor the ultimate limits on it. The way in which genes interact with other genes with different environments only multiples what we still, for the most part, do not understand” (Brock 1). In this paper, I will show how his concepts of genetic engineering are not morally permissible and the moral limitations they outweigh the beneficial aspects of this topic. In order for this idea to be true and hold for argument 's sake, these terms must be defined properly and fit into “real world” situations and scenarios, and they must be independent rules for understanding our world that we live in today.
“With the advent of genetic engineering, the time required for t...


... middle of paper ...


...e moral limitations the cannot outweigh the beneficial aspects of this topic. Although it can be used to cure diseases and illnesses, eliminate physical and mental disabilities, and expand the human race as a whole. However, the negative consequence outweighs these benefits. Not only does it have potential medical and health consequences, it also has many ethical and moral dilemmas. Like quoted before, “no one can confidently predict the rate at which that understanding will be achieved in the future nor the ultimate limits on it. The way in which genes interact with other genes with different environments only multiples what we still, for the most part, do not understand” (Brock 1), so why begin to mess with our genomes now? Why try to defy the inevitable and avoid death? Why try to create a race of super humans that could result in mass destruction of our species?

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Genetic Engineering Is Not Ethical

- For many years, genetic engineering has been a topic in heated debates. Scientists propose that genetic engineering far outweighs its risks in benefits and should be further studied. Politicians argue that genetic engineering is largely unethical, harmful, and needs to have strong limitations. Although genetic engineering may reap benefits to modern civilization, it raises questions of human ethics, morality, and the limitations we need to set to protect humanity.      Though there is harsh criticism from politicians, scientists continue to press forward saying that genetic engineering is of utmost importance to help and improve society....   [tags: Genetic Engineering is Immoral ]

Better Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

Genetic Engineering: The End of Life as We Know It Essay

- Prior to 1982, genetic engineering was a relatively new branch of science. Today, scientists have a firm understanding of genetics and its importance to the living world. Genetic engineering allows us to influence the laws of nature in ways favorable to ourselves. Although promising in its achievements, it also has the potential for abuse. If engineering of this caliber were to be used for anything other than the advancement of the human race, the effects could be devastating. If precautions are not implemented on this science, parents might use it solely for eugenic purposes....   [tags: Genetic Engineering Essays]

Better Essays
773 words (2.2 pages)

Designer Babies or Superheroes?: Ethical Considerations Essay

- Do you remember when you were young and always wanted to be a superhero. Today, you can virtually create your own child superhero by genetic engineering and designer babies. What color eyes and hair would it have. Would you make it smart, athletic, or both. These are all possible if you choose designer babies instead of natural conception. Herbert Boyer and Stanley Cohen first established genetic engineering in 1973 (Bellis 1). It wasn’t until around 1996 when they first started to allow parents to choose their babies gender....   [tags: genetic engineering, gene therapy]

Better Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Designer Babies: What is Ethical? Essay

- Designer Babies: What is Ethical. Imagine a parent walking into what looks like a conference room. A sheet of paper waits on a table with numerous questions many people wish they had control over. Options such as hair color, skin color, personality traits and other physical appearances are mapped out across the page. When the questions are filled out, a baby appears as he or she was described moments before. The baby is the picture of health, and looks perfect in every way. This scenario seems only to exist in a dream, however, the option to design a child has already become a reality in the near future....   [tags: Genetic Engineering, argumentative, persuasive, Go]

Better Essays
992 words (2.8 pages)

Genetic Engineering Essay

- Genetic Engineering Since the discovery of DNA in the late 1950´s, the possibility of genetic modification of animals and plants has become a reality. However is the reality of designer babies going to far. The term designer baby refers to the genetic modification of the child in it´s early fetal life. The issue has been argued in the media for a considerable amount of time, but is time for the debate now running out. We are led to believe that deep in central Europe, it has been rumored to have already occurred....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
771 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on A Case for Clones

- Humans have used cloning techniques for thousands of years. We have taken plant stems or part of it’s root and developed those parts into a separate but genetically identical plants. These methods of cloning are not seen as strange. In fact, many vegetable and fruits are grown using these cloning methods to produce offsprings identical to an exceptional plant. However, cloning, which started as a farming method, has now become a major source of debate due to breakthroughs in the biology field. When scientist created Dolly the sheep, cloning took a giant step forward....   [tags: genetic engineering]

Better Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

Attention Deficit : The Brain Syndrome Of Our Era Essay

- As the advent of the scientific era already came, people use technology as much as they can. Technologies give people a lot of advantages. However, they never concern about the bad influences that bring with technologies. In the essay “Attention Deficit: The Brain Syndrome of Our Era”, Richard Restak examines the brain’s ability to multitask and the consequences of multitasking as the result of technological impacts. He realizes technology makes people lose the ability to create happiness, because multitasking forces individuals’ brains to process ever-increasing amounts of information at ever-increasing rates....   [tags: Morality, Value, Technology, Genetic engineering]

Better Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

Vitro Fertilization And Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis Essay

- In vitro fertilization and preimplantation genetic diagnosis are often referred to in tandem. Preimplantation is dependent on in vitro fertilization. The ability to view and manipulate genetic destiny of sex cells must be done outside the body and then implanted back in afterwards. Although PGD is dependent on In vitro fertilization the reverse is not true. In Vitro has applications beyond PGD and by extension separate ethical issues that must be addressed. The concept of In vitro fertilization is simple in principle....   [tags: In vitro fertilisation]

Better Essays
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Is the Use of Transgeneric Organisms Essential to the Advancement of Therapeutic Medicine?

- ... Statistics in the article state that this method of malaria prevention is the most successful and goes on to imply that it will be of much benefit to the malaria plagued areas of the world. It is stated that mosquitoes are one of the biggest causes of human deaths. By using this method to stop the transmission of mosquito to human, the human death count will decrease considerably. Even though this article is short, it offers a large amount of useful information that will be valuable in assessing the benefits that this type of genetic modification will have for the advancement of therapeutic medicine....   [tags: genetic modification advantages]

Better Essays
1324 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Genetic Manipulation

- Genetic Manipulation Genes, being part of the basic building blocks of man, control all aspects of one's life. They control how tall you are, what color your eyes are, and what diseases might afflict you in the future. Therefore, the manipulation of such genes can be a controversial topic. The controversy most likely stems from the ethical and social questions that are raised by this procedure. Jean Dausset, author of "Scientific Knowledge and Human Dignity," and George B. Kutukdjian, author of "UNESCO and Bioethics," both discuss the topic of genetic manipulation....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1136 words (3.2 pages)