Ethical Judgments Limit the Methods Available in the Production of Knowledge

Ethical Judgments Limit the Methods Available in the Production of Knowledge

Length: 1411 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Knowledge is defined as the “information, understanding, or skill that you get from experience or education” (“Knowledge”). The methods of production of knowledge in the areas of arts and natural sciences are similar in some views, and different in others. Artists produce knowledge through their use of emotion and perception, while scientists and researchers produce knowledge through reason. Ethical judgment limits these methods available to both artists and scientists.
In the production of knowledge in arts, there are highly controversial methods used mainly because art can firstly be done through mimicking. Artists are a group of people that present a version of truth through their artwork. Knowledge in the arts is that of a technique that can generate emotion from the audience, for example through the composition of a sculpture. The interpretation of pieces of art by the audience is a combination of the artist’s input as well as the audience’s personal connotations or emotions. Emotions influence interpretation.
The movie Last Tango in Paris that was released in 1973, contained a sex scene in which the director, Bernardo Bertolucci, had the actors perform live in front of the camera. The director believed that by having the actor, Marlon Brando, perform a sexual act on Maria Schneider live, that the scene would look more real. This scene wasn’t in the original script, and the director added the scene later on, and only told the actress right before filming the scene. Both the actor and the actress felt “raped” and “manipulated” by the film and the director. The actor also said he felt “utterly violated” and the actress felt that the director stole her youth (Das). Because emotion is used in judging art, the artist thought t...

... middle of paper ...

... them or not. However, in the arts, emotion should not be considered of highest importance, and the same goes for reason in science, as they can be misleading filters which leads to ‘unethical’ methods used to produce knowledge.

Works Cited

Das, Lina. "I Felt Raped by Brando." Mail Online. N.p., 19 Jul 2007. Web. 12 Mar 2014.
"Knowledge." Merriam-Webster Dictionary. N.p.. Web. 12 Mar 2014.
"The Resurrection Men- Body Snatching in 19th Century Britain." HubPages. N.p., n.d. Web.
12 Mar 2014.
Unruh, Brandon, and Walter Robinson. "The Hepatitis Experiments at the Willowbrook State
School." A Selected History of Research with Humans. N.p.. Web. 12 Mar 2014.
"U.S. Public Health Service Syphilis Study at Tuskegee." Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. N.p., 10 Dec 2013. Web. 12 Mar 2014.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Ethical Judgments Limit the Pursuit of Knowledge Essay

- “The end justifies the means” is the famous quote of Machiavelli (Viroli, 1998) which puts the emphasis of morality on the finale results rather than the actions undertaken to achieve them. Is this claim true in the field of the natural sciences. Whether atomic bombings, as a mean used to end World War II, justifies the death of civilians in Hiroshima and Nagasaki. What is moral limitation in the acquisition of knowledge in the natural sciences. How is art constrained by moral judgment. Is it applicable to various works of art....   [tags: Ethics vs Knowledge]

Strong Essays
1323 words (3.8 pages)

Ethical Judgments and the Production of Knowledge Essay

- Humans are rational and emotional creatures whose intellect allows for the evaluation of behaviors and actions. These evaluations help humans rule over actions and create ethical judgments. Ethical judgments dictate over what should be done and restrict the way of being of individuals. Ethical judgments have an impact in the methods available in the production of knowledge, but are not considered hindrances since they affirm the principles of human morality and are needed to judge knowledge claims....   [tags: The Stem Cell Debate]

Strong Essays
1232 words (3.5 pages)

Ethical Judgments in the Arts and the Natural Sciences Essay

- Ethical judgments limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in both the arts and the natural sciences. Discuss. When talking about ethics we have to take in account that it is based on the socially standardized concept of some things being good and some things being bad. Therefore what might be seen as socially unethical arts for some people, in another society or in another time, it probably won’t be so. The same is true for the natural sciences. And even if we take our western society as a base, there are some aspects of ethics and some specific topics of which people do not have a standardized opinion....   [tags: Ethics Essays]

Strong Essays
1298 words (3.7 pages)

Discussing Ethical Judgments in the Production of Knowledge in Both Arts and Sciences

- Ethical judgements limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in both the arts and the natural sciences. Discuss. To a certain degree, ethics can be considered a matter of one’s heart, the source of emotional life, as well as their head, the center of a human being’s faculty of intellect and reasoning. Ethics, or moral philosophy, is a set of ideas that are systemized, defended, recommended in differentiating behaviour as either right or wrong prescribed by social and cultural taboos....   [tags: ethics vs production of knowledge]

Strong Essays
2508 words (7.2 pages)

Essay about Ethical Judgements Limiting the Production of Arts and Sciences

- ... We could call this a type of pseudo-art with hidden ideologies trying to percolate into people’s minds. The forms of art they have been producing adulate a leader, an ideal, passing the direct opinion of the leader or the ruling party to their followers, or try to harvest ideologies in the minds of potential future adherents. Their art plays with people’s emotions, inducing opinions, through propaganda, through presenting things in a specific way. Specific examples for this type of artworks would be the “Der ewige juden” anti-Semitic film, from 1940 by Fritz Hippler, the president of the Reich Film Chamber who directed this film with input from German Minister of Propaganda Joseph Goebbe...   [tags: perspective, symbolism, experimements]

Strong Essays
1360 words (3.9 pages)

Ethical Judgement and the Production of Knowledge Essay

- Ethical judgment is not a definite restriction for the method and production of knowledge in art field, but it does relatively limit the production of knowledge in the natural science fields. Since the ethical judgment is an authority in a majority of people’s notion and mind, people tend to follow ethical standards and harder to develop the further knowledge. In addition, reason is one of the ways of knowing and moral principle is a crucial factor that shapes the pursuit of knowledge. The extreme cases in the natural science and in distinctive areas of knowledge violate the reason that undermines the moral obligation....   [tags: Essays on Ethical Judgement]

Strong Essays
994 words (2.8 pages)

Methods of Experimentation and Research in the Natural Sciences that are Limited due to Ethical Considerations

- The production of knowledge, the theoretical or practical understanding of a subject (New Oxford), has constantly been accomplished throughout the history of man as a result of the characteristics of creativity and curiosity. These attributes, besides ethics, have set humans apart from the other species allowing for constant and rapid development. According to (Rest), an ethical judgment is the process by which an individual determines that one alternative is morally right and another alternative is morally wrong....   [tags: eugenics, animal testing, ethical judgement]

Strong Essays
1459 words (4.2 pages)

Ethical Judgements in the Arts and Sciences Essay

- Both the arts and the sciences have completely different methods to create knowledge, thus the effects ethical judgments have on the arts and the science are different. Ethics limits the production of knowledge in both the arts and natural sciences, however, in the arts ethical judgments do not limit the methods available in the production of knowledge, rather it limits the propagation of knowledge. On the other hand, ethical judgements do limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in the natural sciences, because ethical judgments are self regulated in the natural sciences by reason because of the role of ethics in the methods....   [tags: Emotion, Reason]

Strong Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)

Ethical Judgements Limit Knowledge Essay

- Ethical judgements limit the methods available in the production of knowledge in both, the arts and the natural sciences. The aforementioned question incorporates a clear sense of direction and purpose, laying out the fundamentals of the Theory Of Knowledge by visibly stating the Areas of Knowledge that are supposed to be further delved into; in this case ethics, arts and natural sciences. The topic aims to denote that ethics are directly correlated to arts and natural sciences, the three being interdependent on each other and influencing one another in some way or the other....   [tags: Theory of Knowledge]

Strong Essays
1401 words (4 pages)

Essay about The Production of Knowledge in both the Arts and the Natural Sciences

- Production of knowledge is generally seen in a positive light. However, when ethics and morality become involved in the process of production, judgements will undoubtedly be made that may seem to limit the availability of that knowledge. Ethical judgements are made by the combination of a knower, his or her standard of value, and the situation itself. In the field of the arts and natural sciences, ethics plays a crucial role in the extent one may possibly be allowed to go to when discovering new knowledge....   [tags: ethical judgements, methods, limits]

Strong Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)