Ethical Issues Behind Transgender Or Gender Reassignment Surgery Essay

Ethical Issues Behind Transgender Or Gender Reassignment Surgery Essay

Length: 1302 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What are the ethical issues behind transgender or gender reassignment surgery? Gender reassignment surgery, commonly known as GRS is “a procedure that changes a person’s external genital organs from those of one gender to those of the other.” (thefreedictionary.com) There are two main purposes for altering genital organs. First, newborns with intersex deformities must be assigned to one of the sexes early in life. These deformities be caused by abnormalities during the early stages of development when the growing fetus develops either the female genitals or male genitals as determined by the lack or presence of male hormone stimulation, respectively. Secondly, both men and women occasionally believe they are mentally a different gender than they are physically. In some people, this belief is so conclusive that they are willing to be surgically altered to match their physical characteristics with their psychological identity. This condition is known as gender identity disorder or gender dysphoria (thefreedictionary.org) and is more common in men than women.
As gender altering surgery becomes more popular and more socially accepted, it raises serious ethical questions. Is gender change truly a solution to gender dysphoria? Are the consequences of a gender surgery worth the procedure? Where do we draw the line when it comes to “playing God”?
There are several arguments that proponents of transgender surgery pose in support of gender reassignment surgery. One of the main issues transgender supporters cite in support of GRS is the protection of autonomic rights. This basically concludes that it is each person’s right to decide what he or she wants to do with his or her body, and because of this they shouldn’t be restricted when it co...


... middle of paper ...


...we are “playing god” and taking physical alteration too far. Taking a physically healthy person and performing an entire change of identity because he or she is uncomfortable with the way he or she looks teaches people to be intolerant of problems instead of pushing through them and supports fighting the very way we were created. Lastly, with such alarming rates of people who ultimately were unhappy with their physical appearance and emotional state following the surgery, there doesn’t seem to be a countervailing benefit to such a physically and emotionally scaring surgery. If almost 50 percent of “successful” surgeries end with the patient being depressed to the point of attempting suicide, perhaps it’s time to scale back the recent trend toward supporting the surgery and explore other options that will ultimately lead the realized happiness of this group of people.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Gender Reassignment Surgery ( Chaz Bono )

- Gender Reassignment Surgery Chaz Bono, a three time writer and transgender once said, “There 's a gender in your brain and a gender in your body. For 99 percent of people, those things are in alignment. For transgender people, they 're mismatched. That 's all it is. It 's not complicated, it 's not a neurosis. It 's a mix-up. It 's a birth defect, like a cleft palate.” Identifying as transgender can be nerve wrecking for anyone;being transgender in today’s time can be ever more terrifying, especially for the transgender youth....   [tags: Transgender, Sex reassignment surgery, Suicide]

Strong Essays
1461 words (4.2 pages)

Gender Dysphoria and Gender Reassignment: Analysis of a Policy Issue Essay

- 1. Introduction Sexuality and gender identity issues have had a long history in the fields of mental health and public policy. There has been much debate surrounding the inclusion of issues related to gender and sexual identity in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual since its initial stages of development (Drescher, 2010). Debates in this field of interest have been fragmented between several stakeholders (Ehrbar, 2010). This fragmentation has created complications in the process of developing United States policies that are inclusive of individuals with gender identities that do not match the gender to which they were assigned at birth....   [tags: gender identity, mental health, sexuality]

Strong Essays
3347 words (9.6 pages)

Gender Dysphori An Ethical Question Essay

- Gender Dysphoria in Adolescents: An Ethical Question According to Dr. Norman Spack, a specialist in gender identity, it is estimated that nearly 700,000 adolescents under the age of eighteen in the world have a disorder known as “gender dysphoria” (Sex Change Treatment for Children is on the Rise). Gender dysphoria, or GD, is defined as “discomfort or anxiety that arises and persists when there is discordance between assigned sex at birth and internal experience of gender that results in an impairment of function (Olson 374)....   [tags: Transgender, Sex reassignment surgery]

Strong Essays
1409 words (4 pages)

Essay on Gender Reassignment & Female Genital Mutilation

- According to Milton Diamond, children with genital impairments at birth are being reassigned to surgery to be transformed physically into women (1997, p.1). But where has the psychological part of these individuals left behind. Is this newly made up female capable to embody society’s expectations about women. Will these individuals be able to conduct themselves as women in an intimate relationship. Female gender mutilation and gender reassignment surgery seem to be about fixing the problem momentously on the outside, but as a human being is composed of body and spirit, shouldn’t there be a correlation between the two components....   [tags: genital impairments at birth]

Strong Essays
1757 words (5 pages)

Gender Reassignment Surgery for Inmates at the Taxpayer's Expense Essay

- All citizens have the unalienable right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, but what happens when a citizen commits a heinous act such as murder. Should the pursuit of their happiness be granted even though they took the life of another. Are we as a society to take their feelings into consideration and grant them the right to live their life as they wish. A major issue within the United States is the healthcare programs for inmates. One of the largest disputes when it comes to medical treatments/surgeries within the penal system is the sexual reassignment of inmates with gender dysphoria....   [tags: gender dysphoria in prisons]

Strong Essays
1402 words (4 pages)

Gender Reassignment Surgery Essay

- Gender Reassignment Surgery Gone Wrong Gender reassignment is a very controversial topic. Does it really work, can surgery really change your gender. People will always tell you about all the things that go right with surgery, but does anyone truly pay attention to the significant problems that this surgery can cause. Gender reassignment surgery (GRS) is a surgical procedure by which a person’s physical appearance and function of their existing sexual characteristics are altered to resemble that of the other sex....   [tags: GID, Caution, Reconsidering]

Strong Essays
962 words (2.7 pages)

Gender Is Not A Mental Disorder Essay

- The American Psychological Association states that they recognize that gender nonconformity itself is not a mental disorder and what makes it a disorder is the presence of significant distress associated with the condition. As we have learned in class, something becomes diagnosed if it interferes with the patient’s everyday life. Gender Dysphoria has to be present for 6 or more months in order to be diagnosed and there must be a “marked difference between the individuals expressed/experienced gender and the genders others would assign him or her (DSM-V, APA).” Gender Dysphoria was added to the DSM-V as an effort to remove some stigma associated with the diagnosis....   [tags: Transgender, Gender, Sex reassignment surgery]

Strong Essays
1262 words (3.6 pages)

What Is Gender Dysphoria? Essay

- What is Gender Dysphoria. A clinical definition may be, “The condition of feeling one 's emotional and psychological identity as male or female to be opposite to one 's biological sex.” There is a growing amount of scientific research that suggests gender identity develops at a very early age. So, what are the ethical considerations of gender-reassignment treatments for minors suffering from gender dysphoria. Children can be diagnosed with GD as early as age five. Following, most girls start puberty when they are between the ages of eight and thirteen years old....   [tags: Transgender, Sex reassignment surgery, Gender]

Strong Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

Gender Dysphoria On Adolescents And Adults Essay

- Gender Dysphoria in Adolescents and Adults PSYC 140 Abnormal Psychology Worthy Pegram Salem College Gender Dysphoria in Adolescents and Adults Gender dysphoria in adolescents and adults is noted by a confliction in expressed and assigned gender (APA, 2013). It is believed that people have experienced gender dysphoria for thousands of years, possibly since the beginning of mankind, though it just recently became more commonly studied in the last 200 years (Feinberg, 1996). Gender dysphoria symptoms vary among children, adolescents, and adults; they also vary between natal males and natal females....   [tags: Transgender, Gender, Sex, Sex reassignment surgery]

Strong Essays
1870 words (5.3 pages)

Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Essay

- Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Ian Buruma was born in the Netherlands in 1951. He went to school in both Holland and Japan, and he has spent a great deal of time in Japan. Ian Buruma is an author, journalist and a professor at Bard College in New York. He sometimes writes for the New York Review of Books, the New York Times Magazine, the New Republic, the New Yorker, and the Guardian. The book, Behind the Mask, was a very interesting one. This book is filled with lots of Japans history that most people know nothing about....   [tags: Ian Buruma Behind the Mask]

Free Essays
468 words (1.3 pages)