1.4 Evaluating and Analyzing Ethical Dilemmas: Case 1
Case #1 Ethical Dilemma
“A social worker employed in a county social services department as an eligibility worker has learned that local welfare reform direct that she reports any new children born to current welfare recipients. She fears the new reporting requirement could prevent children born into welfare families from receiving income supports later in their lives. The worker is aware of the requirement that social workers should comply with the law. However, she is convinced that reporting newborns might preclude future essential services. The social worker also believes that the new regulations will create a new class of citizens (children born to welfare mothers) that might be discriminated against in various ways. She feels caught between complying with the law and ignoring the law to prevent what she views as likely injustice” (Cummins, Sevel, & Pedrick, 2012, p.33).
What are the ethic...
... middle of paper ...
..., L. K., Sevel, J. A., & Pedrick, L. (2012). Social Work Skills for Beginning Direct
Practice: Text, Workbook, and Interactive Web-Based Case Studies (3rd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.
National Association of Social Workers. (2015). Code of Ethics. Retrieved from
Steinmetz, K. (2016). More States Ditch Family Caps on Welfare Assistance. Retrieved from
U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, ASPE. (2012, Dec.3). Table III: Family Cap
Policies by State. Retrieved from https://aspe.hhs.gov/legacy-page/table-iii-family-cap-policies-state-152371
Wiltz, T. (2016, July 13). Welfare Caps: More Harm than Good? Retrieved from
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- When working with this population, if a client is withholding their diagnosis from their sexual partners and having unprotected sex the social worker faces an ethical dilemma. Confidentiality is a major concern but so is duty to warn and the duty to protect. According to Granich (2012), “Mental health professionals do not have the legal right to disclose that a person is HIV-positive to another person. This is at the discretion of physicians in many states. However, social workers and mental health professionals must struggle with this legal situation if a client insists on potentially harming another person through risk of transmission of HIV”.... [tags: Sociology, Social work, Social justice]
1002 words (2.9 pages)
- Shaniya Robinson arrives at the County Human Services Authority for her monthly appointment with her social worker. Ms. Robinson is a 25 year old African American female who is receiving treatment for schizophrenia from the adult behavioral health services program. During a session the client reports that she is under a great deal of stress because she is having difficulty adjusting to being a new mother. Her five month old baby girl Shanice is teething and cries frequently. Ms. Robinson is also struggling financially because she is currently unemployed; her mental illness makes it difficult to sustain employment long term.... [tags: Social Work Essays]
1082 words (3.1 pages)
- The ethical dilemma in my conflict is that I, as an individual providing information and listening to the stories of domestic violence survivors, do not allow my past life experience effect the outcomes of clients. Being that my agency oversees the eighteen domestic violence agencies in the State of Connecticut, I work with a very diverse population and at times encounter situations where self-disclosure is a complex issue. Self-disclosure to clients raises numerous boundary issues which in turn can result in conflicts of interest with a relationship with a client.... [tags: Sociology, Social work, Ethics]
1331 words (3.8 pages)
- In this essay, I am going to talk about an ethical dilemma which I encountered during my second practice placement during year three of my social work degree. An ethical dilemma is a situation occurs that a social worker is faced with, there are conflicting issues. The social worker may not always make the right decision. However, the decision is made by the social worker on the basis of reducing harm (REF). My placement was placed with the social services department for Learning disabilities that provide support for adults and their carers.... [tags: Ethics, Social work, Decision making, Sociology]
2314 words (6.6 pages)
- Introduction The path to becoming a clinical social worker has been as rewarding as it has been challenging. I have enjoyed every moment of learning as it has helped shape me into the person and professional I want to be. My original career path was not that of a Social Worker but once I had chosen the path of becoming a Social Worker everything started to make sense. I felt like I had found a place to belong and a feeling of “rightness”. I feel I still have a lot to learn when it comes to being a clinical Social Worker.... [tags: Social work, Sociology, Psychotherapy]
2090 words (6 pages)
- Ethical Dilemma Gina Mathew Chamberlain College of Nursing As a health care worker, it is evident that we come across certain situations where it is difficult to make a choice regarding a patient’s care. Many dilemmas arise in healthcare, but it is our obligation to make sure that the patient is given the best care possible. In order to make the most optimal decision, we have to weigh the pros and cons to both choices and pick the best, particularly for that patient. It is crucial for any healthcare worker to put his or her own judgments, values, and beliefs aside and understand the patient’s values and beliefs to guide the decision making in the right direction.... [tags: Nursing, Health care, Health care provider]
1291 words (3.7 pages)
- The Fatal Choice Choosing to Terminate the Pregnancy Termination and the Ethical Dilemma While a number of families choose to continue the pregnancy, despite a fatal diagnosis by the physician, there are also countless reasons why families choose to terminate. A few of the determining factors in this decision are, considering the quality of life of the child if they are born, the effect of this on both the family and the child, the severity of the abnormality, and the woman’s age (Lyus, R., Creed, K., Fisher, J., & McKeon, L.... [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Fetus, Obstetrics]
1954 words (5.6 pages)
- Summary Ms. Morter was licensed as a Clinical Social Worker, and was also certified as an Advanced Practice Social Worker. The Respondent worked as a psychotherapist at Sheboygan County Health and Human Services. As a psychotherapist, her duties included psychosocial evaluation and treatment services, outreach and prevention programs, referral services, and crisis intervention. On May 15, 2008 to July 29, 2009 Ms. Morter provided individual psychotherapy and case management services to Client T.R.... [tags: Ethics, Social work, Psychotherapy, Psychology]
1332 words (3.8 pages)
- Ms. Morter was licensed as a Clinical Social Worker, and was also certified as an Advanced Practice Social Worker. The Respondent worked as a psychotherapist at Sheboygan County Health and Human Services. As a psychotherapist, her duties included psychosocial evaluation and treatment services, outreach and prevention programs, referral services, and crisis intervention. On May 15, 2008 to July 29, 2009 Ms. Morter provided individual psychotherapy and case management services to Client T.R. On July 18, 2009 Ms.... [tags: Psychotherapy, Social work, Ethics, Psychology]
1763 words (5 pages)
- Social workers will face ethical dilemmas when working with clients throughout their career. As a social work intern, it is important to understand the ethical standards of the profession in order to make the best possible decision in regards to any dilemma that might be encountered. Relevant to social workers today, especially in regards to working in a school setting with clients who are minors, there seems to be a conflict that exists between the standards of self-determination/confidentiality and professional conduct.... [tags: Ethics, Social work, Risk, Decision making]
1152 words (3.3 pages)