What Is The Relevance Of Braveheart Inaccurate Facts

543 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Braveheart movie analysis

Braveheart is an American middle age drama from 1995, produced and featured by Mel Gibson in the role of William Wallace. The movie is about the saga of Scotland’s struggle for freedom in the 13th century. When an English soldier executes Wallace’s wife, his own quest for revenge turns quickly into a passionate fight for his country’s independence. In this essay, I will write about some of the scenes in the movie and compare whether it was historically correct or not. In conclusion, I will reflect on why the director chose these changes.
Mel Gibson’s epic drama has several historical inaccurate facts. William Wallace was not a poor villager like he was portrayed but a landowner and knight. The movie starts in year 1276 were Scots are gathered in a meeting to select a new King after Alexander’s III death. In reality, Alexander III was an alive and healthy man. There had been peace between Scotland and England for almost 60 years until his death. …show more content…

At the beginning of the movie, he fell in love with Marrion and secretly married her. The married couple never had the opportunity to settle down and create a family before English men executed her. Then we have princess Isabella of France who was married to the Kings son, Edward II. He develops sexual relationship with her that lead to possible pregnancy. Isabelle also revealed and warned Wallace about the Kings plans. In reality, Wallace had never met Isabella. In matter of fact, she did not marry Edward II until 1308. Three years after the death of William Wallace. In addition, it is nearly impossible that William Wallace was the father of King Edward III because Isabella would have been 9 years old when she had affair with

Show More
Related

  • Concepts in Film Theory and Criticism. Robert Rosenstone states: "Film emotionalizes, personalizes, and dramatizes history. Through actors and his...

    761 Words  | 2 Pages

    A true representation of history in film is almost impossible to achieve, this is due to the limitations of source materials the filmmakers who create the films have. In the modern day, photographs and video footage of historical events are available but these resources don’t depict everything which has happened. Emotion and what happens in historical events are two of the main things that these resources do not depict, what happens in event and human emotion can only be experienced by either people who are involved in the historical event or by the person who is being portrayed. Even then the event experienced can be falsely accounted for due to time in terms of memory or quite simply human error. Another main problem with historical depiction in film is that many films, especially Hollywood films, have one main goal, to create profits. This is achieved by the entertainment value of a film, if a film is entertaining an audience will follow, which leads to the film creating revenue. One of the main arguments raised about historical films is that they distort the past. Many Hollywood films have to use certain techniques and convention to ensure that it makes revenue, these conventions lead to filmmakers adding more to history via film such as love interests, more appealing action sequences and changing the look of the events to make them more aesthetically pleasing. Hollywood, Historical war films which depict rivalries between nations have been affected by this method with has led to the films not being an honest representation of history. This essay will discuss how historical representation in the films Braveheart, Pearl Harbor and Lincoln has been falsely and honestly depicted to create a more narratively and visually entertai...

    Read More

  • Debunking Myths: Medieval Warfare Misconceptions

    1459 Words  | 3 Pages

    This article uses the technique of scholarly questions and answers to help readers understand the context of the article. One question raised in relation to the primary source the song of Roland is, “But are such pieces of literature – medieval though they are- reliable for their military history’? This question is asked after examining the primary source. The question asked was then explained by recalling “basic methodology pertaining to the primary source”. By the article raising questions it allows the reader to think deeper into the topic by allowing them to relate prior knowledge to what is being asked, making a correlation between given information, and prior understanding of the topic. Burkholder’s also uses primary sources, which could help develop a research paper. The use of primary sources in the article strengthens the author’s arguments. Some primary sources used are the song of Roland, Paul Davis’s 100 Decisive Battles, and De Re Militari. For each primary source Burkholder breaks down particular quotes and makes arguments with relevance to the thesis. This helps readers to check the reliability of the article, and use the primary sources to better understand how the information relates to the over all thesis. Additionally, the author cites with using primary sources specific movies such as King Authur (2004) and Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (2002), deconstructing how the two films relate directly to history and how accurate specific scenes in the movie are. One interesting technique used by the author is a critical analysis of how the entertainment industry is beneficial for history, and how it’s non-beneficial. In one interesting example Burkhodler provide three compelling reasons to illustrate how films are beneficial to an accurate appreciation of historical events. These points of view

    Read More

  • Materialism In Beowulf

    1315 Words  | 3 Pages

    We humans have come to the conclusion that we are forever evolving. Many literary works were created to preserve world views throughout the ages. Looking back, we learn about the values of the people who were before our time. There is a stark contrast between the cultures of the medieval world and those of modern civilization; in the fold epic Beowulf (Heaney) and the movie Beowulf and Grendel (Gunnarsson). In these, examples there are clear differences between the materialism and idealism of the past and present. The movie resembles how modern ideas of heroism can also mean feeling sympathy for one’s antagonist, while the epic representing past ideas entitle the hero to be ruthless; the differences are proof that every time period perceives situations such as good and evil with disparity. As values change, cultures change, and

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Peter Burkholder's Academic Journal Article Review

    1167 Words  | 3 Pages

    Peter Burkholder 's academic journal article is written and developed with a social approach. Burkholder 's article formulates connections between social aspects of the present generation with the medieval era through examples such as the 1995 film Braveheart and various video games that portray medieval battles. His analysis of the stereotypes society has of medieval warfare connects with a wider audience beyond the academic community since it incorporates examples of popular culture thus making the article more relatable to the reader. Since it is a journal article Burkholder uses academic terminology, however it is used sparingly. However, due to the article 's simplicity few primary sources aside from the Song of Roland are used, and the document is based heavily upon explanations rather than established facts. The Song of Roland acts as a prime example within Burkholder 's article of when entertainment value is placed above historical accuracy, thus resulting in confusion and academic misinterpretation. A source of this type would be useful for writing an article about medieval warfare aimed at a non-academic audience, or a paper on historical (in)accuracies within media and primary sources. Ideas such as Burkholder 's statement that the dominant

    Read More

  • Similar Themes in both Roger Malvin's Burial and The Minister's Black Veil by Nathaniel Hawthorne

    2631 Words  | 6 Pages

    Two men, Reuben Bourne and Roger Malvin, have survived the battle and are trying to make their way back home. Both are wounded. As they stop in a forest by “…a young and vigorous sapling stood…,” Malvin entreats Bourne to abandon him and save himself (20). The men are familiar with one another and, at fir...

    Read More

  • Free Hamlet Essays: Hamlet Interpreted

    517 Words  | 2 Pages

    The portrayal of the pirates as "merciful thieves" (Shakespeare, 124) and the fact that warlike Fortinbras succeeds in Poland and obtains the Kingdom of Denmark by play's end - may be a commentary on decisive, imperialistic behavior.

    Read More

  • Who Is The Protagonist In The Last Of The Mohicans

    408 Words  | 1 Pages

    The English’s superior toward the native and the colonist create an unstable relationship between the two. Major Duncan is appeared as someone that superior over others. His word and attitude make him a powerful man, but when the Huron party wipe out every single British soldier, they got save by a group of Mohicans. On their dangerous trip to Fort William, Major Duncan still

    Read More

  • The Mad Trapper by Rudy Weibe

    876 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the differences between the movie and the book lies in the settings or rather the surrounding in both the movie and the book. The book depicts an exemplary factual tale, one of mountain myths, situated in 1930's Northern parts of Canada. The book portrays an account of C...

    Read More

  • Macbeth vs Scotland, PA

    2343 Words  | 5 Pages

    William Shakespeare, one of the greatest English play writers, has had a profound influence upon different societies globally since the fifteenth century, for his plays inspire many contemporary artists to present new scopes reflecting their societies. Considered as one of Shakespeare’s greatest tragedies, Macbeth has a completely disparate interpretation of the movie Scotland, PA, which translates the original play into a black comedy. A Scottish royal and general, Macbeth the protagonist undergoes a demonic transformation in personality, in which he unethically takes the crown by murdering numerous characters. The director of the movie alters the plot while maintaining the basic semblance of power, ambition, and masculinity from Shakespeare’s work. In the movie, the alteration of the process Macbeth usurps the power of Duncan, including his internal and external incentives, gives the audience a fresh perspective on one of the English classical plays.

    Read More

  • How Power Corrupts in Macbeth

    2635 Words  | 6 Pages

    The essence of Macbeth lies not only in the fact that it is written by the universal talent William Shakespeare; the royal-conspiracy, the political unethical activity, the killin...

    Read More

  • Sir William Wallace

    697 Words  | 2 Pages

    and married her in the year 1272. There are many tales on how William Wallace

    Read More

  • Movie Essays - Filming the Epic of Gilgamesh

    1659 Words  | 4 Pages

    To preserve the storytelling style of the epic's author(s), I plan to employ a narrator to guide the action. A recognizable, intelligent, regal, and yet not overpowering voice should be chosen. This voice should give an air of importance to the narration without being so enthralling that the action is missed. I plan to seek out such Englishmen as Patrick Stewart, Sir Ian Mckellan, Sir Anthony Hopkins, and John Geilgud, and to offer them the opportunity of auditioning for this essential role. The selected actor's voice will begin and end the film, while covering breaks in the action and explaining confusing sections of the story.

    Read More

  • 300: Rise of an Empire

    525 Words  | 2 Pages

    In reality, movie's plot was changed in a lot of parts to impress the audience, make it dramatic and more engaging than what happened in history. “The real Darius wasn't at the Battle of Marathon, and Themistocles didn't kil...

    Read More

  • Robin Hood's Identity

    1117 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to legend, Wallace was a ?symbol of Scottish nationalism. ?It is said that ?he (William Wallace), was a Scottish knight who fought against English oppression until his brutal execution in 1305. Jennie Cohen shows the similarities between William Wallace and Robin Hood. They both had the symbol of a long bow. However, this could symbolize that they were both skilled archers. Like Robin?s Sherwood Forest, Wallace hid in Selkirk Forest in Scotland. William Wallace also had a wife. Her name was Mirren; Merren, in Scottish translates to Marien, which is the same as Robins Hood?s love infatuation. In addition, William was an outlaw. In addition there is the connection made between the sheriffs. For Robin, the Sheriff of Nottingham was his antagonist and for Wallace, a sheriff kidnapped his wife. Therefore, with these connections, it is very possible that William Wallace from Scotland, was the true story transformed into England?s Robin Hood. In the article, many points were made by Jennie Cohen. Her research seems adequate to show the connections with William Wallace and Robin

    Read More

  • Braveheart Movie Summary

    501 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1280 A.D. Edward I of England, known as "Longshanks," has occupied much of Scotland, and his oppressive rule there leads to the deaths of William Wallace's father and brother. Years later and after Wallace has grown up with his uncle outside of Scotland, the Scots continue to live under the harsh thumb of Longshanks' cruel laws. Wallace returns, intent on living as a farmer and avoiding involvement in the ongoing "Troubles." Wallace rekindles a romance with his childhood friend Murron after showing her the carefully preserved thistle she gave him as a child, and the two marry in secret to avoid the primae noctis decree the King has set forth. After Wallace beats up a group of English soldiers attempting to rape Murron, the village Sheriff publicly cuts her throat before Wallace is able to save her. An enraged Wallace, with the assistance of his fellow townsmen, slaughters the English soldiers at the encampment, killing the sheriff in the same manner that Murron was killed. He then orders the burning of the local English fort, and unintentionally kindles a Scottish rebellion.

    Read More

More about What Is The Relevance Of Braveheart Inaccurate Facts

Open Document