What Is Chimpanzee Infanticide?
opinion Essay
1165 words
Introduction
In this paper I will try to explain some of the differences and similarities that occur in both human and chimpanzee cultures concerning infanticide. I will first explain some of the reasons that chimpanzees practice infanticide and share a few examples of such. Then, I will do the same for human cultures which may not be as prominent as we believe but is still happening. Finally, I will compare the similarities and differences between the two, and show how chimpanzees and humans may not be that different after all in this regard.
Chimpanzee Infanticide
Chimpanzees react to infanticide in ways that may seem surprising to us. In fact, they often oppose it but there are differing hypotheses for this such as they share their disapproval
…show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Explains the differences and similarities that occur in both human and chimpanzee cultures regarding infanticide.
- Explains that chimpanzees react to infanticide in ways that may seem surprising to us.
- Explains that infanticide is more prevalent than most people think. it occurs when parents and doctors stop treatment and/or food supplies to young infants to cause their deaths.
- Compares the practice of infanticide between chimpanzees and humans, stating that there is no prevalence for either males or females committing the act.
- Opines that humans and chimpanzees are similar in infanticide, and that people blame it on different cultures and claim that they are better than them.
For example, it has been noted that in times when food or other resources are scarce that parents may in fact commit infanticide to lessen the burden of trying to provide more food for, according to Lund, “the least productive members of society,” (Lund 1985: 2). Infanticide is generally much more hidden in our society and actually happens in the hospitals, specifically the neonatal units(Lund 1985: 3). Infanticide occurs here when parents and doctors elect to stop treatment and or food supplies to young infants to cause their deaths when they deem that they would either not have a fulfilling live due to mental impairment or to a serious disease, such as spina bifida (Lund 1985: 3-5). There was one case of infanticide that caught the media’s attention several years ago. The case was about Baby Doe who suffered from Down Syndrome and an esophageal problem that led to him needing surgery to be able to eat, this is a fairly routine surgery that is common with children affected by Down Syndrome (Lund 1985: 21). The parents opted to not go through with the surgery while also opting to not feed their child through a feeding tube, thus causing his death of starvation (Lund 1985: 21). Lund also argues that, “the most common cases of infanticide concern the phenomenon of premature and low weight babies,” where parents and doctors elect not to treat …show more content…
Many people would like to believe that we are vastly superior to chimpanzees, but based on these cases we are very similar to each other. When people discuss infanticide in chimpanzees they often think of them as primitive or incredibly violent, but when they hear of human individuals are committing infanticide, they blame it on different cultures and claim that they are better than that culture. No matter what they believe, infanticide is something that happens throughout the world both in human populations and other primate
Related
- explanatory
- analytical
- comparative
- Monkey Babies Research Paperexplanatory essayAs examples, researchers turn away dozens of monkey babies from their mothers in order to cause these small creatures a mental trauma, deprivation and most of them do not see their mothers any more. These monkey babies are confused and suffer from fear, helplessness, anxiety what is more it leads to diarrhea, hair loss and self-mutilation. In one shocking test, the scientists put a monkey mother with its baby into the one cage, but the monkey mother was under sleeping pills. The baby was in deprivation, screaming and trying to wake up its mother. Another cruel experiments on animals are carried out in military training exercises. Training instructors break and cut off the limbs of live goats and pigs and what is more sometimes trainers put
In this essay, the author
- Explains that researchers turn away monkey babies from their mothers to cause them mental trauma, deprivation, diarrhea, hair loss, and self-mutilation. other cruel experiments on animals are carried out in military training exercises.
- Explains that scientists use animals for experiments with drugs, but these tests are not reliable. 92 percent of all drugs are proven to be safe and not dangerous to animals, whereas during the experimentation on humans it was a failure.
204 wordsRead More - Understanding Infanticide in Context Michelle Oberman’s article, Understanding Infanticide in Context: Mothers Who Kill, 1870 – 1930 and Today, focuses on the social facts in America in regards to the mother figure. Breaking down this concept, Oberman provides the readers with two labels, infanticide and neonaticide. Both fall under the umbrella definition of, killing one’s own child/children. What separates this two labels is that neomaticide is, “.babies who were killed within the first twenty-four hours of life”(Oberman). Infanticide is a more general term that encompasses the, “death of infants any time after the first twenty-four hours” (Oberman).
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how oberman's article, understanding infanticide in context: mothers who kill, 1870 – 1930 and today, focuses on the social facts in america in regards to the mother figure.
- Analyzes how finds a pattern in research that sets neonaticide deaths apart from any other cases dealing with infanticide.
- Explains the factors that lead to infanticide, including acute or chronic mental illness, postpartum psychosis or schizophrenia, and death resulting from a mother's chronic abuse or neglect of her child.
- Analyzes how oberman's article shows how society officiates people who commit infanticide and neonaticide, and how they are punished.
- Analyzes oberman's argument that neonaticide isn't a random, unpredictable crime. she uses cases and people as her support along with her own testimony.
- Analyzes how fairfield mother accused of killing her newborn fits pattern, by colin ellis, is an article about pregnant women who suffer from mental illness and lack of understanding.
- Analyzes michelle oberman's research in infanticide, and phillip resnick, the man who coined the word neonaticide and formed a five-point structure for why parents kill
- Analyzes how the mother kills a child believing it is in the child’s best interest. death is not the intended outcome, but is likely the result of abuse or neglect.
- Analyzes how oberman and resnick are aligned and used as support in the article to reinforce ellis point about pregnant women who are not capable of the responsibility of a pregnancy.
- Analyzes how ellis' article focuses on a pattern of young women who suffer from clinical denial. denial combined with their environment causes toxic combination.
1124 wordsRead More - Direct Infanticide Research Paperexplanatory essayAbortion is a commonly talked about subject, but infanticide is not brought up nearly as often. Infanticide is the killing of a child who is less than a year old, often by his or her own parents. There are a few different forms of infanticide, and the ones that will be discussed in this essay are partial-birth abortion, direct infanticide, and indirect infanticide.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that abortion is a common topic, but infanticide isn't brought up as often. there are three different forms of abortion: partial-birth abortion, direct and indirect.
- Defines partial-birth abortion as an abortion that doesn't take full course on the baby, thus killing it during birth.
- Explains that direct infanticide is the deliberate killing of an infant by starvation, dehydration or suffocation. reasons include religious beliefs, other than christianity, and population control
- Explains that indirect infanticide starts when a baby's nutrition needs aren't met. neglect and careless parenting contribute to it, especially when an unwanted baby becomes sick.
- Explains that infanticide is a way of killing defenseless children. jesus loves children no less than anyone else and welcomes them into his arms.
- Urges christians to stand firm in their faith and speak up for what they believe in. all lives have value, no matter how old.
521 wordsRead More - Summary Of Primates And Personhoodanalytical essayIn the article, “Of Primates and Personhood: Will According Rights and “Dignity” to Nonhuman Organisms Halt Research?”, author Ed Yong demonstrates the process of attempting rights for nonhuman creatures. He begins to create his claim by mentioning the Great Ape Project, and how much they have struggled so much with establishing rights for certain creatures that they just began to focus only on apes. Yong continues with the notions of others having a great dislike towards ape rights but makes a point by mentioning they are the most similar animals to us than any other. It seems that the US is the one to blame for stopping the rights but many continue to argue that they know how to protect each one and another, just as humans. His purpose is
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes ed yong's article, "of primates and personhood: will according rights and "dignity" to nonhuman organisms halt research?
- Opines that ed yong is thoughtful about improving thoughts for ape rights, but what about other creatures?
253 wordsRead More - The Singer All Animals Are Equal Summaryexplanatory essayHuman infants display the same characteristics of animals, they are both innocent and cannot refuse what is happening to them. Although experimenting on human infants is wrong in a society, animals or non-humans would argue for equality. Singer explains, “The basic principle of equality, is equality of consideration, and equal consideration for different beings may lead to different treatment and different rights” (Singer 531). Equality can be defined as the state of being equal, especially in status, rights, and opportunities. Singer argues that when it comes to experimenting on animals and non-humans they have different rights when it comes to human infants. Singer explains, “It is an implication of this principle of equality that our concern for others ought not to depend on what they are like, or what abilities they possess – although precisely what this concern requires us to do many vary according to the characteristics of those affected by what we do”
In this essay, the author
- Explains that in the article "all animals are equal", there will come a point where we will face discrimination, but when it comes to animals, they are not given the same choice.
- Explains that discrimination can be defined as the unjust prejudicial treatment of different categories of people or things, especially on the grounds of race, age, or sex.
- Explains that the principle of equality of human beings is not a description of an alleged actual equality among humans.
- Opines that it is unjustifiable that discrimination should exist in society amongst humans although we come from the same species. discrimination can change someone’s morals, intelligence, and character as a person.
848 wordsRead More - Sexism: Modern Day Societycomparative essayNelson, V. S. (1978). Infanticide and the value of life. (pp. 100-105). Buffalo, NY: Wiley Subscription Services.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the horror movie cliché has a vast amount of stereotypical archetypes such as the dumb jock, promiscuous female, geek, and innocent virgin.
- Explains that human resources are a group of people that are present in all places of business. human resource management oversees the organization.
- Explains that the battle of the sexes and racism in the work-place is an example of an ideology.
- Explains that a child is given an apgar rating as he or she enters the world from their mother's womb. this is due to the preference of having male children over female offspring.
- Concludes that sexism has been an ageless topic of discussion since the genesis of the world in reference to religion and in the scientific-beliefs of evolution.
- Explains that the apgar score revisited: influence of gestational age.
- Cites joyce, sharlet, and lerner, g., in "hillary's prayer: hillary clinton’s religion and politics".
1346 wordsRead More - Argumentative Essay On Abortionexplanatory essayIn certain cases, the fetuses have relatively severe disorders such that death is obvious prior to or immediately after birth (Lopez 517). Examples of such cases include anencephaly, whereby the brain happens to be missing together with the limb-body wall complex whereby some organs are formed outside the body’s cavity. In that regard, they consider it as being cruel to compel women to carry such pregnancies to full term. Additionally, even with the nonfatal conditions, like the Down syndrome, it is more likely that the parents may not be in the position of caring for the severely disabled child. In addition, they assert that there is no any need of letting a baby get into this world unwanted. This is due to the fact that siring a child is a vital decision which requires not only consideration but also preparation, as well as, planning. Research indicates that unwanted pregnancies are linked with maternal depression, birth defects, lower education attainment, lower rates of breastfeeding, and a higher risk of infant abuse (Bostdorff 301). Additionally, the pro-choice supporters allege that ladies who are prevented from securing abortions are likely to remain unemployed, survive on public welfare, live below poverty line, as well as, become domestic violence victims. Besides, majority of the women who opt to abort their
In this essay, the author
- Explains that abortion is one of the hotly debated, as well as, politically divisive issues. it has a considerably rich history within this country.
- Explains that pro-choice proponents argue that choosing abortion is a right which should not be restricted by either governmental or even religious authority and it outweighs any of the fetus’ rights.
- Explains that abortion offers pregnant women the option of choosing not to bring to full term fetuses that have profound abnormalities.
- Explains that pro-life opponents of abortion argue that abortion is the immoral murdering of innocent humans. scalia argues that the privacy right defended in roe v. wade is utterly idiotic and cannot be considered as a binding precedent.
- Opines that abortions should not be legalized because it is contrary to the christian teachings.
1128 wordsRead More - gattacaanalytical essayThe author here raises the ethical question about the Baby Theresa case notably; is it acceptable to sacrifice a life with no prospects for a future in order to save another life or several other lives? The author seems to point to the possible altruistic act on the part of the parents in having the baby’s life ended before her life would have ended surely and eventually anyway due to a rare and fatal condition with no possibility of recovery or reversal of this fate. Many physicians agreed with the parents and they recognized the need for organs for other infants, who might otherwise perish. Professional “ethicists” did not agree with this decision and used basic philosophical tenets to hold no life as more important than the life of another. As well, Florida law was on the side of these ethicists and law did no allow for the newborn’s organs to be harvested before natural death occurred. The problem here was that the newborn was going to die anyway and when she did nine days later, the organs had deteriorated to the point of being of no use to other newborns in need. However there are other questions as to the motives of the parents and the doctors, as well as the stance of most of the ethicists that align with the law.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how raises the ethical question about the baby theresa case — is it acceptable to sacrifice a life to save another life or several other lives?
- Analyzes how is surprised when the ethicists disagree with the decision that the parents make and the physicians agree upon the case.
- Opines that it is never appropriate for one life to be taken to save another life or lives because it's a slippery slope that could lead to other acts that have moral implications that are similarly, inherently unnatural and horrendous.
673 wordsRead More - What Is Abortion's Partner In Crimeexplanatory essayMost people know about abortion, but many people do not know about infanticide. Infanticide is defined as "the crime of killing a child" (dictionary.cambridge.org), typically under a year of age. Infanticide could be described as abortion's partner in crime, as it is often the second option. This essay will explain why infanticide can be called abortion's partner in crime, the reasons parents may kill their children, and why the crime is not justified.
In this essay, the author
- Explains infanticide as abortion's partner in crime, the reasons parents may kill their children, and why the crime isn't justified.
- Explains why infanticide goes hand in hand with abortion, and why mothers choose to abort the baby again or let nurses take care of it.
- Explains that children are more likely to be killed in their first day of life than any other day. the parents may not feel ready for a child, but not have enough money for an abortion.
- Opines that christians value the lives of the unborn more than anyone else, and they need to be the voice for them.
558 wordsRead More - Even pro-choice advocates disagree on the circumstances that validate abortion. There is little or no argument against the current abortion of fetuses with genes for Down Syndrome. I speculate that controversy would ensue if the abortion of fetuses with fatal but less debilitating diseases, such as diabetes, became commonplace. I propose the following question: what makes a genetic disease or disability severe enough to validate selective abortion of an affected fetus? Pernick discusses the meaning of health, indicating that an individual who is unable to complete a physical or mental task that others can do has a disability. If people with below-average IQ have low probability of obtaining jobs with above-average salaries in spite of their efforts, are they unhealthy (Lemonick 57-8)? In our society, are homosexuals considered diseased (Henry 3,6)? Is an ugly person who cannot find a mate, in a sense, disabled? The abortion of individuals who do not exhibit desirable aesthetic traits may seem extreme. However, with no laws regulating such abortions, I speculate that some would take place. Because I believe that unwanted children should not be born regardless of their health status, I do not propose laws that disallow abortions of fetuses deemed healthy by medical standards. Instead, I propose laws regulating pre-natal screening. We should only screen embryos and fetuses for 'abortion-worthy' diseases. These "abortion-worthy" diseases should be designated by a national bioethics committee not unlike the one currently headed by Kass (Gibbs). While every condition should be analyzed independently, all should have common, identifying characteristics.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that craig ventor completed sequencing human dna in june 2000, accomplishing the first major endeavor of the human genome project (hgp).
- Argues that even pro-choice advocates disagree on the circumstances that validate abortion. they propose a national bioethics committee to screen embryos and fetuses for 'abortion-worthy' diseases.
- Opines that pre-natal genetic screening is the pinnacle and culmination of preventative medicine, but the genetic model for disease is not this simple.
- Argues that genetic screening should be used after birth to elucidate probability of acquiring genetic diseases and debilitating conditions.
- Argues that it is not a viable solution for post-natal screening because individuals aware of their genetic predispositions may react in self-destructive manner.
- Argues that genetic screening should be used to complement family histories and/or medical examinations to prevent or deter onset of diseases.
1507 wordsRead More