What Happened Next in Rip Van Winkle ?

922 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Characterization essay of rip van winkle

What Happened Next in Rip Van Winkle ?

Rip Van Winkle acquired a belief the day he fell asleep---July 3, 1766, say---a belief that that day was a fine day. He held this belief under the character ``Today [the day of this thought] is nice.'' Then he slept for twenty years and two days, until July 5, 1786, and walked back to town. What happened next?

The possibility that struck Kaplan and Evans is that Rip merely updated his belief. On July 3rd he never forms any explicit belief other than ``Today [the day of this thought] is a nice day''. When he awakes on July 5th, the belief is updated, due to his awareness of having slept through a night, and his lack of awareness of having slept twenty additinal years, to ``Yesterday [the day before the day of this thought] was a nice day.'' He falls out of epsitemic contact with the current day when he falls asleep, but has a ready-made character in mind for when he wakes up. But then what is there left of the original belief except the false one about July 4th? But the false belief can not be the true belief, so hasn't Rip lost the belief in question? This seems to be the argument that threatened Kaplan and appealed to Evans.

But even in the case of such thin updating, there are backup characters for Rip to hold his belief under. When Rip believes, towards evening, as it grows dark, ``Today [the day of this thought] was a nice day,'' he has memories of seeing the flowers and feeling the sun, and so forth. So the character, ``That day [the day I remember] is or was a nice day'' is available to sustain his belief, when the attempt at updating goes awry. Even if these memories fade, there is the character, ``That day [the day this belief was acquired] is or was a nice day.''

So my view is this. When he awakes on July 5th, Rip updates his belief according to his view of how the context has changed. His view about the change of context is mistaken, and the new character, ``Yesterday [the day before the day of this thought] was nice'' is not a way of believing the original content. But that is no reason to say that Rip has lost his original belief.

Show More
Related

  • Important Quotes From The Things They Carried

    661 Words  | 2 Pages

    In a written story, the details are permanent. One can not will the words to change in every copy of the same story. The author’s words are fixed and how the author created the story is how the story will always go. While it is true a reader -- or even the author -- could create an alternate reality where the story divulges from the original plot, the people in the story are typically the same. In fact, the more people think about the character, the more the character seems to come alive. Tim O’Brien gave his fallen comrades and even his first love a second life in his novel. In the final chapter Linda says “Once you’re alive… you can’t ever be dead” (O’Brien 244). When a person is alive, they interact with a variety of individuals and become a central part in some of their memories. Those random encounters create a link to the living after they have passed away. The people remember and tell others of the fun

    Read More

  • An Allegorical Reading of Rip Van Winkle

    1509 Words  | 4 Pages

    Irving, Washington. “Rip Van Winkle.” The Norton Anthology of American Literature. Ed. Nina Bayn. New York: Norton & Company, 1999.

    Read More

  • Whitney Elizabeth Houston's Life and Achievements

    648 Words  | 2 Pages

    During The 90’s, Whitney focused on her acting and appeared in ‘Waiting To Exhale’ in 1995 as a TV producer in love with married man. In 1996, Whitney starred in ‘The Preacher’s Wife’ with Denzel Washington. ‘My Love Is Your Love’ in 1998 didn’t sell much, but it has been a long time since Whitney’s last album in 1985...

    Read More

  • Summary Of Response To Zena Young's Questions On Axolotls

    452 Words  | 1 Pages

    Explain which reality was true and which was a dream? I feel that neither was true because like he said at the end he was living a lie and mocking his dream. Its normal for people to be in shock and denial and these situations and wanted to die a glorious death as mentioned with the sick boy in our previous story.

    Read More

  • How Does Rip Van Winkle Relate To Self Reliance

    693 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “Rip Van Winkle” by Washington Irving he writes about a simple man, Rip Van Winkle, who does just enough to get by in life. He lives in a village by the catskill mountains, and is loved by everyone in the village. He is an easy going man, who spends most of his days at the village inn talking with his neighbors, fishing all day, and wandering the mountains with his dog to refuge from his wife the thorn on his side. On one of his trips to the mountains Rip Van Winkle stumbles upon a group of men who offer him a drink, and that drink changes everything for Van Winkle. He later wakes up, twenty years later, and returns to his village were he notices nothing is the same from when he left. He learns that King George III is no longer in charge,

    Read More

  • Should Welfare Have More Restrictions?

    1423 Words  | 3 Pages

    My views towards welfare have somewhat changed during the process of research. When I first started researching “welfare” I only thought about all the people who cheat the system. But, then I realized how many people need and do get support from welfare. There are more people receiving help from welfare, then people hurting it. Yes, there is a group of people who scam welfare, but there is a side that relies on welfare.

    Read More

  • The Nuclear Inventions During the Cold War

    931 Words  | 2 Pages

    The major inventions during the Cold War included the Hydrogen Bomb, the Nuclear Powered Submarine, and the Computer Guided Intercontinental Nuclear Missiles. The Hydrogen Bomb was first tested in 1952; it explodes violently when reacted with an intense amount of heat. Unlike the Atomic Bombs used on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in World War II, these Hydrogen Bombs are much stronger with intent to damage anything within a one-mile radius. Moreover, heavy particles of radiation will fall to the ground, affecting the environment and healt...

    Read More

  • Is Professional Rugby Union Becoming too Dangerous?

    686 Words  | 2 Pages

    The equipment worn by the players contribute to making the sport of rugby union much safer. Mouth guards are worn; this is a piece of plastic that fits to the players upper set of teeth, to prevent the teeth clashing. Teeth clashing can cause concussion; therefore, mouth guards are worn to stop this danger. Secondly, post pads are placed around the rugby posts to stop the players hitting into them and causing a very serious injury, as the posts are made from metal. Although not mandatory, scrum caps are likely to be the most commonly used accessories in the game. This piece of equipment involves a cloth helmet that covers the head but leaves the face uncovered; the cap is filled with small pockets of soft material, usually foam. This also helps to stop the game being so dangerous. There are many pieces of equipment that contribute to making the sport of rugby much safer. However, there are many reasons why the...

    Read More

  • Description of Saint Paul's Cathedral in England

    769 Words  | 2 Pages

    Directly above the doorway was a three level carving. The first, on the bottom, was of common people, all facing towar...

    Read More

  • Summary: The United States Welfare System

    638 Words  | 2 Pages

    The United States government’s welfare program is potentially sending the government down the drain. The U.S. alone is in millions of dollars of debt, and the welfare program is not helping to get the country out of debt but further into debt. Over half of the American population is currently receiving some sort of benefit, and not every person receiving these benefits needs the money. We live in a selfish society. A society where we would do anything and everything to gain a little extra money so we will not have to work for it. The welfare system the United States currently runs is not proper or right. The welfare system is corrupted and full with cheats and frauds benefitting from taxpayers money.

    Read More

  • Why is Family Important so Important

    681 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...do. One cannot pick a family to be with, but you have to make the best of it, and love them for who they are. “Friends come and go, but family is always there.” –Melissa Pate

    Read More

  • Illusions of Reality

    1352 Words  | 3 Pages

    There are many points in my life that, when I look back on them, I will have noticed a change that was made. Whether it is when I accepted the Jesus into my life, or experienced a drug for the first time. We shall all be that way. What I’m experiencing right now is real and tangible to me, but maybe I will look back on this time of my life someday and realize that this reality was just a step to another, and that reality another step, then another. What we are experiencing now will eventually be a memory.

    Read More

  • The Round, Flat, and Stock Characters of Rip Van Winkle

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    One particular criterion character effectively supports the central idea in “Rip Van Winkle” by Washington Irving. The character's type develops with the personality development throughout the story. Three types of characters: round, flat, and stock, appear in most stories. The round character displays a fully developed personality and full emotions. Flat characters, also known as supporting characters, do not develop fully or express complex emotions. A stock character, also known as a stereotype, fits an established characterization from real life or literature. With these three types of characters leading the reader through the story, the reader learns the events taking place as well as the changes in the character’s lives. The author keeps the reader informed of the changes affecting the characters throughout the narrative through style. When a character undergoes a fundamental change in nature or personality during the story, the character has dynamic style. However, a character without change defines a static character. Although all characters have a style and type sometimes understanding the differences appears complicated. A chart often helps establish a better understanding of character type and style.

    Read More

  • Reflection in Iris Murdoch's Under the Net

    2319 Words  | 5 Pages

    ...e made up of moments which pass and become nothing. Yet through this shaft of nothings we drive onward with that miraculous vitality that creates our precarious habitations in the past and the future. So we live; a spirit broods and hovers over the continual death of time, the lost meaning, the unrecaptured moment, the unremembered face, until the final chop that ends all our moments and plunges that spirit back into the void from which it came. (p244)

    Read More

  • Learning How To Become A Leader

    666 Words  | 2 Pages

    This information allows me to better understand my unique talents because it shows me what kind of a person I am. I now understand that I am a person that needs balance in life and that I like predictability. I have realized that I am a fixer and that I like to problem-solve. I think that I understand myself better and I can look back on my life and understand why I have a few very close friends and why I have made decisions a certain way before.

    Read More

More about What Happened Next in Rip Van Winkle ?

Open Document