What Great Books Do for Children by Arthur Schlesinger Junior

1083 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The effect of fairy tales on human development

Critique of “Fairy Tales”

The most well authored articles must have a combination of understanding, organization correct grammar and several other components. These articles ought to have a superb thesis and refer to meta-discourse. All great essays must make the reader feel something whether they agree with the article or not. Arthur Schlesinger Junior’s “What Great Books Do For Children” is not an excellent example of an brilliant essay. It does not have enough development, thesis is not structured well, his arguments are obvious, and his conclusion is incorrect.

The essay explains how children perceive books they read. The author tells the story about how his mother used to read to him and how much he loved imagining things from these stories He explained how children do not see books as a “behavioral” standpoint, such as opinions on racism, sexism, classism and others, but they use their imagination and make it grow. They enjoy imagining about dragons, ogres, or a princes journey to find a long lost damsel in distress (Kingsley, Squire & Mars, 2000).

Schlesinger Jr.’s article does not use enough development in his essay. His argument is that children are not being taught behavioral problems while reading books, but they are expanding their imagination. Though this sentence itself seems to be fine, he doesn’t expand on it. He does not explain why books expand children’s imagination. Nor does the essay explain why children’s books do not promote “good or bad behavior”. The only support is his personal experiences when he was a young child and the fact that “behavioral” books do not last as long as folklore ones do. The argument would be better supported if Schlesinger would give examples of books on both sides explaining why...

... middle of paper ...

... article is that the arguments are completely obvious and have little to do with his primary argument. He needs to research and come up with real reasons why he believes that he is right; otherwise, the article is not legitimate and cannot be relied on. There is also the conclusion. It states things that were not in the article and therefore does not work. He could use these phrases in his paper, and then put them into the conclusion, but it does not need to be there otherwise. Again, this article is not terrible. If it was worked on, it would have an excellent point. However, at its current arrangement, the paper does not have all the requirements it needs.

References
Grimm, J., & Grimm, W. (2007). Fairy tales. Cleveland: World.

Kingsley, C., Squire, M. H., & Mars, E. (2000). The heroes: Or, Greek fairy tales for my

children. New York: Schocken Books

Show More
Related

  • Summary Chapter 2

    247 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Chapter 2 of Children’s Books in Children’s Hands: A Brief Introduction to their Literature, the authors talk about the 12 main elements of a literary work: genre, plot, setting, characterization, theme, point of view, intersexuality, tone, mood, style, voice, and the stance of the implied reader (Temple, Martinez, and Yokota 24). All of these literary elements capture the reader’s imagination and creates a successful piece of literature. However, the authors stress the importance of genre in Chapter 2, so I will briefly go over the different types of genres there are in literature and how it affects the readers greatly.

    Read More

  • Jim Hancock's Raising Adults

    582 Words  | 2 Pages

    After covering 262 pages of Raising Adults: A Humane Guide for Parenting in the New World, the reader would read four chapters, with plenty of subtopics, that enlightens him or her concerning teenagers and how to approach them. The author, Jim Hancock, fulfills his purpose within this book: to cultivate “people determined to be more intentional, more skillful, more realistic, more effective” concerning their relationships with teenagers. He successfully fulfilled his purpose by structurally discussing the current cultural composition of teenagers, and previous generations; strong relational skills that may aid an adult into becoming an effective parent; and practical strategies to raise adults. Although this book is extremely beneficial for any parent, it does have a con for me: it is too verbose. Namely, it could state what it attempts to convey in fewer words. After

    Read More

  • My Two Blankets By Irena Kobald And Freya Blackwood

    1223 Words  | 3 Pages

    Books offer children a variety of learnings sometimes with hidden messages that are not explicit in nature. The book ‘My Two Blankets’ by Irena Kobald and Freya Blackwood (2014) is a good example of a story that touches on many modern day issues (societal issues). Such as displaced persons due to war, emotions that children are sometimes exposed to, acceptance of diversity and friendship. This multimodal text is a great medium for being able to open up conversations in the classroom around any or all of these important topics. The lesson is motivated by the Australian Curriculum learning area, English with the content descriptor, “discuss literary experiences with others, sharing responses and expressing a point of view (ACELT1604)” (ACARA, 2014).

    Read More

  • A Comparison Of The Joy Of Reading And Writing: Superman And Me?

    1446 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although the greater picture is that reading is fundamental, the two authors have a few different messages that they seek to communicate to their audiences. “The Joy of Reading and Writing” depicts how reading serves as a mechanism to escape the preconceived notions that constrain several groups of people from establishing themselves and achieving success in their lifetimes. “Reading to Write,” on the other hand, offers a valuable advice to aspiring writers. The author suggests that one has to read, read, and read before he or she can become a writer. Moreover, he holds an interesting opinion concerning mediocre writing. He says, “Every book you pick has its own lesson or lessons, and quite often the bad books have more to teach than the good ones” (p.221). Although these two essays differ in their contents and messages, the authors use the same rhetorical mode to write their essays. Both are process analyses, meaning that they develop their main argument and provide justification for it step by step. By employing this technique, the two authors create essays that are thoughtful, well supported, and easy to understand. In addition, Alexie and King both add a little personal touch to their writings as they include personal anecdotes. This has the effect of providing support for their arguments. Although the two essays have fairly different messages, the authors make use of anecdotes and structure their writing in a somewhat similar

    Read More

  • Annotated Bibliography For Lion Hudson

    934 Words  | 2 Pages

    This is a heartwarming picture book about a young boy and his sister, Clemmie, and all of the incredible things that they do together. They go on adventures, discover things, and play for hours on end. He talks about how much his sister means to him and how wonderful she is, but it isn’t until later in the book that you realize that she has an intellectual disability. We learn that she shows many adaptive behaviors and that even though she is older than her brother, she can’t do many of the things that he can. This book shows the importance and the benefits for children with disabilities and their siblings to interact together and learn

    Read More

  • Greek Mythology - Aphrodite

    1736 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ingri and Edgar Parin D’alaure’s. Book of Greek Myths. New York: Bantam Dowbleday Dell Publishing Group, 1962.

    Read More

  • A Modest Proposal

    738 Words  | 2 Pages

    I found the problem with the argument of the article was there was no set argument that was clearly stated. If there was an argument in the article it was not clearly stated and I personally did not catch onto it. Altogether this was a well written article without a clear argument.

    Read More

  • The Tale of Peter Rabbit and Voices in the Park

    1298 Words  | 3 Pages

    It is very easy to agree with Moebius statement that ‘good’ picture books contain some form of invisible and intangible concepts that keeps the reader returning. In Voices in the Park it is very easy to see Moebius idea due to the ability of technology to create detailed and complex books. In contrast, Potter has produced a book that more subtle in showing this relying not on technology like Voices in the Park but working within severe limitations. Blending page turns, text, colour to create understandable concepts. Goodman comments that some would argue that these elements in pictures interfere with and detract from the text, and thus undermine the confidence of the reader. An extrapolation of this idea is that preconceived ideas and pictures of another spoil the reader’s entrance to literacy.

    Read More

  • Aphrodite. Then and Now

    580 Words  | 2 Pages

    5. Buxton, R. G. A. The complete world of Greek mythology. London: Thames & Hudson, 2004.

    Read More

  • A Love Affair With Books

    520 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ever since I was a child, I've never liked reading. Every time I was told to read, I would just sleep or do something else instead. In "A Love Affair with Books" by Bernadete Piassa tells a story about her passion for reading books. Piassa demonstrates how reading books has influenced her life. Reading her story has given me a different perspective on books. It has showed me that not only are they words written on paper, they are also feelings and expressions.

    Read More

  • Written Critique on Corduroy and Winn-Dixie

    1542 Words  | 4 Pages

    Norton, D. E., & Norton. S. (2011). Through The Eyes Of a Child. An Introduction To Children’s Literature. Boston, MA, 02116: Eight-Edition Pearson Education

    Read More

  • Racism in Children's Literature

    2373 Words  | 5 Pages

    Writing has been an important part of every culture from the beginning of time. The illustrations of cavemen have evolved immensely. Today, there are millions of published books. In fact, there are over four hundred books published every month. What happens when these books turn into something more? Is there racism in our children's literature? Ironically, the renowned great works of our past is full of racism. The question that remains, how do we teach our children the great lesson that these brave authors intended?

    Read More

  • The Wielding Women of The Great Gatsby

    650 Words  | 2 Pages

    Fiction Studies 49.3 (Fall 2003): 443-468. Rpt. in Children's Literature Review. Ed. Jelena Krstovic. Vol. 176. Detroit: Gale, 2013. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Mar. 2014.

    Read More

  • The Harry Potter Series by J.K Rowling

    2082 Words  | 5 Pages

    Jones, Marnie. "The Threat to Imagination in Children's Literature." International Journal of the Book 3.2 (2005/2006): 71-76. Print.

    Read More

  • A Timeline of Children's Literature

    1209 Words  | 3 Pages

    The construction of children’s literature was a gradual process. For a long period of time children’s books were frowned upon. The stories were said to be vulgar and frightening. Adults censored children’s ears to stories of daily life, tales with improbable endings were not to be heard. It was not until the mid 1800s that stories of fairies and princesses began to be recognized. Although children’s literature was accepted, the books were not available for all children. With limited access to education, few public libraries, and the books’ costs, these texts were only available to the middle and high- class. As public education and libraries grew so did the accessibility of books and their popularity. They no longer were considered offensive, but rather cherished and loved by many children. Children’s literature became orthodox and a revolution began, changing literature as it was known.

    Read More

More about What Great Books Do for Children by Arthur Schlesinger Junior

Open Document