We Must Provide Subsidized Healthcare for Illegal Immigrants
analytical Essay
2571 words
The topic of undocumented immigrants is heavily debated across the United States. Furthermore, the concept of these undocumented immigrants receiving subsidized healthcare is an even more highly controversial matter. The conflicting sides are significantly divided even though the United States of America was founded upon the notion of freedom and the melting pot ideology. This paper will examine the dilemma of undocumented immigrants and access to subsidized healthcare; yield a few attainable solutions in addition to some recommendations for the future on how this issue may be solved. Immigration has been around in the United States of America since the colonial times. Along with those immigrants come many other issues, including healthcare. Many of the millions of immigrants presently in the United States are without insurance. This paper will discuss how important it is for us as Americans to provide those who are uninsured and here illegally with some form of subsidized care. Additionally, this article will inform readers on reasons why this should derive from an ethical stand point and due to the associated health risk that can come about for those who are here legally. The multiplying constituency base includes healthcare providers, consumers, and buyers. There is a great importance to these individuals regarding the assurance of a more equitable and accountable system of healthcare (Kaiser Family Foundation). The terms “illegal immigration” and “undocumented immigration” are often used in an interchangeable manner. “Illegal immigration is the movement of a person from his native country to foreign country, with an intent to find a lively hood and settle down without the permission of the government. Il... ... middle of paper ... ...2690> ProCon.org. Is Illegal Immigration an Economic Burden to America?, August 11, 2009. Web. 20 March 2015. Smith, J. “Screen, Stabilize, and Ship: EMTALA, U.S. Hospitals, and Undocumented Immigrants.” Houston Journal of Health and Law Policy 10, 2010: 309-358. Web. 20 March 2015. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. Race, Ethnicity, and Health Care Issue Brief: Policy Challenges and Opportunities in Closing the Racial/Ethnic Divide in Health Care, March 2005. Web. 11 March 2015. Theadvocatesforhumanrights.org The Facts: Undocumented Immigrants. The Advocates for Human Rights, 2006. Web. 11 March 2015. < http://www.energyofanation.org/ sites/25elf498-741c-478a-8a08aa486d8533a5/uploads/ undocumented_immigrants_3.pdf>
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the political climate of the united states increasingly holds a negative stigmatization upon the population of undocumented immigrants.
- Analyzes the issue of undocumented immigrants receiving subsidized healthcare in the united states of america.
- Explains that immigration in the united states dates back to colonial times circa 1607 and still occurs today.
- Argues that the refusal to provide undocumented immigrants with subsidized healthcare is unethical and will only ensure the american citizens will have a more significant problem in the future.
- Explains that the emergency medical treatment and active labor act is a constant struggle for medical facilities that receive federal funding.
- Argues that eliminating ethnic and racial disparities in health care is politically sensitive and challenging in part because their causes are intertwined with a contentious history of race relations in america.
- Explains that the united states of america is in a state of controversy as the citizens and interest groups debate whether undocumented immigrants should receive subsidized healthcare.
- Explains achkar, macklin, and achcar, j. m. ethical considerations about reporting research results with potential for further stigmatization of undocumented immigrants.
- States that goldman, smith, and sood, n. legal status and health insurance among immigrants. health affairs, 24, no. 6 (2005): 1640 – 1653.
- Explains that illegal immigration is an economic burden to america. the henry j. kaiser family foundation. race, ethnicity, and health care issue brief.
Related
- opinionated
- analytical
- explanatory
- Illegal Aliens and American Medicineopinionated essayAbout half of immigration into the United States is illegal, thus approximately half of the impact of immigration on our health care system is due to illegal immigration. The influx of illegal aliens has serious hidden medical consequences. We judge reality primarily by what we have seen. But what we do not see can be more dangerous, more expensive, and more deadly than what is seen. What is unseen is their free medical care that has degraded and closed some of America’s finest emergency medical facilities, and caused hospital bankruptcies.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that half of the impact of immigration into the united states is due to illegal immigration. the influx of illegal aliens has serious hidden medical consequences.
- States that the general accounting office traveled to southern arizona to study the impact of illegal immigrants on arizona and other border state hospitals.
- States that the emergency medical treatment and active labor act (emtala) requires every emergency department to treat anyone who enters with an emergency.
- Explains that mexican ambulances come to american emergency departments with indigents because the drivers know that emtala requires accepting patients. government imposes viciously stiff fines and penalties on any physician and hospital refusing to treat any patient that a zealous prosecutor deems an emergency patient.
- Explains that american hospitals welcome ‘anchor babies.’ illegal alien women come to the hospital in labor and drop their little anchors, each of whom pulls its illegal alien mother, father, and siblings into permanent residency by being born here.
- States that the articles support a theory that explains the illegal alien problem as part of the general environment in which it is found.
- Explains that the fourteenth amendment was ratified to assure rights of freedom and citizenship to newly emancipated negro citizens.
- Suggests that we close america's borders to prevent illegal entry. deport illegal aliens. rescind the citizenship of anchor babies.
- Explains that doctors are obligated to promote or restore the health of their patients, but there can be no obligation to do something morally wrong. illegal aliens come to another country and reap the benefits of health care without going through the proper channels.
- Opines that the issue is not about denying needy services to individuals and families, but about what is right. obligations of citizenship in a democracy require concern for the conduct of government and responsible participation in the electoral process.
- Opines that the burden of health care to illegal aliens has taken an overwhelming toll on the american healthcare dollars. surrender is surrender to collectivist america.
- Cites cosman, m.p., ruggiero, v. and weissinger, g.
1033 wordsRead More - Annotated Bibliographyanalytical essayThe US government is struggling to implement the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), also known as Obamacare. The ACA has four challenges, first, inequality, reducing health discrepancies among racial and ethnic minorities is a major focus of the law. Second, and perhaps the greatest challenge in the US health care system is inefficiency. The tremendous costs of the US system have worsened gaps for racial and ethnic minorities by making it difficult to afford health insurance. Even the ones who were able to afford it were only able to afford lowered end treatment. Persistent expansion of health insurance for minorities will require significant improvements in the efficiency of healthcare. Third, the US system is heavily relied on reliance on expensive, high tech care. For example, minorities without health insurance have commonly not had access to preventive services because of the expensive equipment that is used. Fourth, continuing public puzzlement is a problem for the implementation and political upkeep for the law. The only thing most people know about the act is the individual mandate that everyone has to have “minimum essential” health coverage. There was a poll released by Kaiser Health Tracking that affirmed this how uneducated people are on the ACA. The poll was released in April 2013, which revealed that 4 in 10 Americans are still unaware that the ACA is the law and is being implemented. Those who are aware of the law only half of them understand how the law will affect their family. For the people who are uninsured there is even a greater lack of understanding, 58% among diverse minorit...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the us government is struggling to implement the patient protection and affordable care act (aca), also known as obamacare.
- Explains that racial and ethnic minorities have poorer health than whites, such as chronic diseases, life expectancy, and infant mortality.
- States kimbroughmelton, robin j. "health for all: the promise of the affordable health care act for racially and ethnically diverse populations." american journal of orthopsychiatry.
- Explains why most americans will continue to depend on their employer for health insurance even after obamacare is implanted in 2014. employers with low-wage workers would be less likely to provide health coverage.
- Explains that employers will be penalized for not giving their employees health insurance, but they can raise salaries to pay for better health care and results with a win-win situation.
- Concludes that massachusetts had health care reform similar to that of the aca and concluded that the employer-coverage would remain intact.
- Analyzes blumberg, buettgens, feder, and holahan's "why employers will continue to provide health insurance: the impact of the affordable care act."
- Argues that the affordable care act shows how the us needs to change its perspectives and approach towards minority populations and the issue of health care that comes with it.
- Opines that the greatest effect of the aca on ethnic health gaps will come from the broad provisions intended at reducing economic hurdles to care.
- Explains that the affordable care act requires that all insurance plans make sure one be covered for preventive care. the expansion of medicaid eligibility to all households below 133% of the federal poverty level is an unsolved issue.
- Opines that the affordable care act is the first step to eliminate health disparities and represents the greatest advancement in us health care since medicare and medicaid were initiated in 1965.
- Analyzes errickson, sadye paez, "what will health-care reform mean for minority health disparities?" public health reports.
- Explains that americans are part of an experiment where they have to choose the best health care plan for them and the one that will hopefully drive down the price among competitors.
- Explains that most people who make the decision on which plan to choose have never had health insurance and are uneducated.
- Compares the results of the first experiment, where participants were asked to pick a plan for their family of three. economists think that people overweight deductibles and out of pocket costs and underweight premiums.
- Opines that consumers need help choosing a plan; if they don't choose the most cost-efficient plan, there would be no pressure on competitors to lower prices.
- Explains johnson, eric j., ran hassin, tom baker, allison t. bajger, and galen treuer, "can consumers make affordable care affordable? the value of choice architecture."
- Explains the effects of the affordable care act on consumer health care spending and risk of catastrophic health costs.
1529 wordsRead More - The Pros and Cons of Illegal Immigration into the United Statesexplanatory essay?Over 6 million illegal immigrants live in the US- some estimate even more.? (Illegal Immigration) This is astonishing. Six million people could make up a whole suburb such as Mesa or Chandler. Immigrants arrive in America in different ways. One is crossing the border illegally by land. Another way get into the US are by false identities or by stolen, or falsified passports. Another way is by illegal smuggling boats. ?Others enter with legal documentation and then violate the terms on which they have been admitted by taking jobs that are not authorized or overstaying the authorized period of stay in the country? (Illegal Immigration)
In this essay, the author
- Explains the pros and cons of illegal immigration into the united states. illegal immigration has three main purposes: to find a better life in the 'promise land', free healthcare, and third: for criminal activity.
- Explains that over 6 million illegal immigrants live in the us- some estimate even more. immigrants arrive in america by land, false identities, stolen, or falsified passports, and illegal smuggling boats.
- Opines that illegal immigration is a major cause of overcrowding of our schools and prisons.
- Explains that illegal immigration is not always looked down upon, as some say they help our economy, while others say hurt the economy. many business owners are strongly pro-immigration.
- Opines that the u.s. will keep illegal immigration to a minimum by reforming policies that crack down on criminal illegals.
- Cites bender, david, bruno leone, charles p. cozic, huffington, michael, and izumi.
784 wordsRead More - Essay On Social Justiceanalytical essayUsing two dominant theories, Rawlsian Liberalism, and Sen and Nussbaum’s capabilities approach, we identify a weakness when the theories are applied with the assumption that a human right is by virtue of being human (Powers & Faden, 2006). Both theories have some means of acknowledging health care as a right. Rawl’s suggests that health care may be a “primary good”, or a benefit that is part of a just society, on which Daniels outlines “six health needs” including social determinants (Almgren, 2013, pp. 35-36). Nussbaum (2000) specifically outlines 10 capabilities that expand upon categories of health and well-being. The divergence of our universal right is in both theories assumed that a person should be a citizen or have some capacity to contribute to society. Rawlsian liberalism goes as far as to outline that a “free and equal individual”, or one who has a right to primary goods, requires that the person can engage in social and political citizenship, which includes voting (Almgren, 2013, p. 17). Undocumented immigrants possess no such rights, so they would have no claim to health care as Rawl’s primary good, despite their contribution to labor and economic stability in the United
In this essay, the author
- Compares rawlsian liberalism and sen and nussbaum's capabilities approach to identify a weakness when the theories are applied with the assumption that health care is by virtue of being human.
- Analyzes how medicaid is a chess piece in the hands of partisan politics. the aca sought to expand medicaid to cover more low-income americans by creating national eligibility standards.
- Argues that medicaid provides a valuable resource for the poor, children, pregnant women, the disabled and the elderly based on nominal application of social justice theories.
- Argues that the right to health care is a non-relational right that every human needs irrespective of differences in individual goals.
1081 wordsRead More - The Pros And Cons Of Health Careanalytical essayWithout a doubt, universal healthcare is one of the most numerous issues that were discussed intensely in the 2012 elections that will continue to be debated into the further future. While President Obama passed his compelling piece of legislation in 2010, the Affordable Care Act, there was an undeniable polarization within all the American people which ensued. Regardless, even with all of the potential economic things that may arise from new health care policies, it is formidable legislation the United States should continue to uphold and support. This essay will comprise of several parts. I will initially discuss what opponents of universal healthcare are concerned about. Subsequently, I will then go over the reasons we should support a universal healthcare policy, explaining that universal healthcare Provides multiple benefits ranging between protecting the poverty-stricken and insured to being a more efficient financial plan for the government.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the brand new health care policy provides more coverage to a larger percentage of all americans, is more effective for the united states’ budget during these dire economic conditions, and is moral cause and sign of community.
- Argues that universal healthcare is one of the most numerous issues that were discussed intensely in the 2012 elections that will continue to be debated into the future.
- Concludes that universal healthcare is a sound policy that will improve the united states government in multiple ways.
- Analyzes how politicians use tennessee's predicament to illustrate how universal health care is potentially a disaster, and employers make sacrifices when purchasing care for their employees.
- Argues that a universal plan would ensure care while eliminating the capitalistic idea of profit that arises when private insurance companies enter the picture.
- Explains that since roosevelt, and every single democratic president elected into office has attempted to pass a version of universal health care, but none have achieved that at that time.
- Explains that obama promised to make health insurance affordable for all, but needed to cut a deal with the health-care companies, which had long opposed such reform. republicans, opposing such an expansion of government, resisted the bill.
- Explains that opponents of the aca present two primary claims in the court. the first is that they argued that the individual mandate exceeded the bounds of commerce clause, which was the power given to congress by the constitution.
- Explains that obama care's effects on the cost of premiums will differ across insurance markets. low-income people can enroll in medicaid or qualify for a subsidized insurance plan through their state’s healthcare exchange.
1077 wordsRead More - The Affordable Care Actopinionated essayThe United States of America is a very socially diverse nation with inhabitants ranging from the wealthiest in the world to near third world-like living conditions. In an essay titled, America’s Shameful Poverty Stats, Sasha Abramsky sheds light on some statistics like, “15 percent of people in America live at or below the poverty line” (Abramsky, Sasha 1). In America many citizens are poverty stricken and left uncovered from a healthcare standpoint, which is why a universal healthcare plan like The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) would greatly benefit America. Universal healthcare, for the most part, refers to a healthcare system in which the government provides medical care and financial solutions for all of that particular nation’s citizens. For most people in the upper and middle class universal healthcare is not something they would like to see in America because they already have healthcare, or they don’t want to pay higher taxes because of it. A nation as advanced and developed as America should have installed a universal healthcare plan years ago because it only makes sense to strengthen our nation as a whole. All of America’s citizens should accept The Affordable Care Act to start becoming more socially responsible and help provide healthcare to millions of uninsured Americans in an attempt to help lower the poverty level and provide financial support as well.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the united states of america is a socially diverse nation with inhabitants ranging from the wealthiest in the world to near third world-like living conditions.
- Explains that america's middle class is shrinking and the lower class growing. why not help our hurting citizens who simply cannot afford healthcare without a universal healthcare plan?
- Explains that social classes in america collide with differing stances and views on almost everything that is debatable regarding social class in some way.
- Explains that the upper and middle classes group members of the lower class with stereotype depictions, which makes the middle and upper classes not want laws like the affordable care act.
- Explains that the affordable care act makes it easier for small businesses to become more socially responsible. small businesses can invest in their employee's wellbeing by providing healthcare plans.
- Explains that obamacare's main purpose was to "make healthcare affordable, or even free, for low-income americans." the supreme court ruled that states could opt out of the expansion of medicaid coverage.
- Opines that the affordable care act will either succeed or fail — it's a socialist agenda that doesn't receive support from die-hard capitalist citizens.
- Opines that the affordable care act will bring more social equality to the poor if america as a whole accepts it and states choose not to opt out of medicaid expansion.
- Explains that the persistent poverty counties are represented by 139 democrats and 331 republicans, and 18 are split between the two parties.
- Analyzes how abramsky, sasha, and young, jeffrey, "by the numbers: health insurance." the huffington post.
1625 wordsRead More - The Patient Protection Affordable Care Actopinionated essayThis new bill includes an individual mandate requiring all uninsured individuals to purchase a health care plan from over 200 policy options or be fined. According to government officials, the options available under the Affordable Care Act is affordable and protects people from other health policies that neglect to cover pre-existing conditions, mental health illnesses and/or substance abuse issues. However, many taxpayers, newspapers journalists, and other political organizations are claiming that this new bill is causing a crisis across America. There are many different perspectives a person can take when scrutinizing Obamacare, but it would be wrong to judge the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act until thoroughly researching and critically analyzing the bill’s purpose, content, and the affects it can have on the individual, a community, and the nation as a whole.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the supreme court passed the patient protection and affordable care act (obamacare) in june 2010.
- Opines that health reform and its historic investment in prevention will help us achieve the promise we made to give our children a higher quality of life than we have.
- Explains that the affordable care act is affordable and protects people from other health policies that neglect to cover pre-existing conditions, mental health illnesses and/or substance abuse issues.
- Explains that the patient protection and affordable care act is designed to offer affordable health coverage to those who are not offered health benefits through their employer or have been denied in the past.
- Opines that the patient protection and affordable care act is beneficial for america. there are many positives that provide a strong argument supporting the bill.
- Believes that health care reform should be guided by a simple principle: fix what's broken and build what works.
- Describes the pros and cons of the patient protection and affordable care act.
- Analyzes the arguments for and against the patient protection and affordable care act.
- Argues that the patient protection and affordable care act is a crisis due to the questionability of president obama's credibility and competence.
- Opines that the press and anti-obamacare organizations are not providing the public with any reason to believe the new bill was a good idea or that it will help them more than the old form of health care
- Opines that repealing the patient protection and affordable care act is a means of hope for those who are harmed most by the new bill.
- Opines that the patient protection and affordable care act is becoming a national crisis as the government forces americans to sign up or pay fees.
- Explains that four years after obamacare's passage, the health care system remains in crisis.
1661 wordsRead More - Pros And Cons Of Obamacareanalytical essayObamacare has been a widely debated topic over the course of President Obama’s terms in office. Although Obama’s term is coming to an end, the policies of Obamacare will remain a hot topic of discussion due to its pros and cons for many different Americans. Due to the different viewpoints of many Americans, it is not an issue for a mere few individuals, rather a social problem that impacts every American’s life. Many Americans agree that not all of the policies implemented are fair to them, including the employer mandate, the minimum essential coverage, and the individual mandate. These policies may favor one group, yet have detrimental effects to another.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that obamacare has been a widely debated topic over the course of president obama's terms in office.
- Argues that the employer mandate is beneficial for the working class of large corporations, but it does not do any good for employers in small businesses.
- Explains that the individual mandate states that all individuals must have healthcare, or are required to pay a fine through taxes.
- Analyzes the economic and religious impacts of obamacare's birth control mandate on women.
- Explains that obamacare was originally planned to solve the social problem of the lacking in healthcare security of a large portion of americans.
1057 wordsRead More - Affordable Care Act: Is This Helping Americans?opinionated essayAs our great country grows we fix and find new problems every day. One of the biggest debates in the country is regarding whether or not the new “Affordable Care Act” is posing a problem to American society and lifestyle. Many actors, sports men, and friendly faces would tell you how wonderful it will be for American medicine once the populace is insured. However “Affordable care is more of a pipe dream in America until we are a more fiscally stable country, as well as a better approach to socialized medicine. For now the only thing we should be doing regarding health care is stapling a limit to make it more affordable for middle and lower class people instead of penalizing people for something they cannot afford.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that affordable care is a pipe dream in america until we are more fiscally stable and better approach to socialized medicine.
- Opines that requiring people to buy and consume broccoli is socialism in the government, and dangerous to our republic democracy.
- Opines that obama won the presidency with a 66 percent of the vote among adults aged 18 to 29. his health care overhaul could impose its greatest burdens on young adults.
- Explains that many companies, businesses, and other places where people work, have cut their employees hours back to thirty or less in order to avoid the new health care laws.
- Opines that the affordable health care act is an unnecessary and unconstitutional act that no one who isn't paid to say otherwise really wants.
633 wordsRead More - The Battle Over Healthcareanalytical essayHealthcare has always been a priority in American culture, although a new wave of reform has caused uproar in discontent and opposition. Since the Great Depression, many Americans have relied on private sector insurance companies to protect families across the nation and provide fast, reliable services when a medical situation arises. The Affordable Care Act, passed in 2010, has caused uproar in Washington and continues to provide a headache as the stalemate over healthcare continues on into 2014. While healthcare is an important aspect of the American society, the Affordable Care Act and its provisions are detrimental to our economy because it furthers the nation’s debt and does not allow the American people to make their own decisions.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the affordable care act, passed in 2010, has caused uproar in washington and continues to provide a headache as the stalemate over healthcare continues into 2014.
- Argues that government mandates have been placed upon the american people throughout history, especially with the recent requirements for purchasing health care.
- Opines that the government should be an educator, not an enforcer, to reduce the opposition and better serve the economy.
- Opines that the extreme members of congress are not willing to compromise, further leading to reform and modifications.
- Opines that the affordable care act is detrimental to american economy becuase it places harsh mandates on citizens, expands the nation’s debt through welfare, and places more regulation on insurance companies.
- Argues that the affordable care act's provisions will lead to higher healthcare costs for those who had plans and then had to switch plans.
1342 wordsRead More