Pros And Cons Of The New Deal

2035 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Economic effects on America during the great depression

Was the New Deal a Good Deal?
Previous to the New Deal was a decade that contained disaster and hardships called the Great Depression. Once Roosevelt took office in 1933 he implemented the New Deal. This deal was to return America expediently back to its economically, socially, and politically prosperous days. A good deal offers flexible but reasonable opportunities and solutions to direct the attention towards the nation’s struggles. The distinguishment between a successful deal and a non successful deal is the ability for the outcome to truly impact and fulfill the goal that it was set to do. Roosevelt’s New Deal appeared to be a good deal but the disadvantages outweighed the progression or improvement that it promised to provide. Collectively, …show more content…

Congress, at times, was said to have spoonfed Roosevelt power and support his decisions wholeheartedly. As shown by the image “Oliver Twist” below, the word “power,” in the picture represents that Roosevelt was not a good representation for the nation due to his persuading charisma towards the goal of unjust greediness. The New Deal basically manipulated the American people and the government in desperate desirement for control. Citizens that first elected Roosevelt for presidency have now changed their decision not to support the New Deal assertions. According to Dr. M. Santos in “The New Deal Was a Failure,” states “I do not believe that Roosevelt will solve this crisis, for if he had wanted to, as he promised to the American people, he would have solved it, as the Legislature and the Senate have given Roosevelt more power than any other president of the United States….” As Roosevelt continued the New Deal, he used his power in a negative effect regarding the nation’s hardships. Programs in the New Deal opposed the foundation of the Constitution and constantly need improvements thus not assisting the problems. The Agricultural Adjustment Administration represents one program that was ruled unconstitutional. US History.org from The Farming Problem states, “The Supreme Court put an end to the AAA in 1936 by declaring it unconstitutional… After years and years of plowing and planting, much of the soil of the Great Plains and become depleted and weak.” The lack of government intervention within the New Deal’s programs, such as the AAA, allowed Roosevelt to continue the destruction of soil. Broken sod and power farming put the nation into a time of anguish leading up to the Dust Bowl. This displays one example of the absence of guidance from the government; the mindset by

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast The Great Depression And The New Deal

    1257 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Great Depression of 1929 to 1940 began and centered in the United States, but spread quickly throughout the industrial world. The economic catastrophe and its impact defied the description of the grim words that described the Great Depression. This was a severe blow to the United States economy. President Roosevelt’s New Deal is what helped reshape the economy and even the structure of the United States. The programs that the New Deal had helped employ and gave financial security to several Americans. The New Deals programs would prove to be effective and beneficial to the American society.

    Read More

  • Presidents of the 1930s

    738 Words  | 2 Pages

    "America's Great Depression and Roosevelt's New Deal."DPLA. Digital Public Library of America. Web. 20 Nov 2013. .

    Read More

  • Interpretations of Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal

    1643 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the midst of the greatest depression in the history of the United States, Franklin D. Roosevelt and his committees drafted The New Deal, consisting of policies which they hoped would help all declining facets of the nation at the time. The American people needed to heed a promising leader that would set plans to end the depression, a change from president Hoover who seemed to have no set plan for foe dealing with such economic crisis. The New Deal aimed to stimulate the economy, create jobs, and lift America out of the economic strife. The controversy amongst historians that surrounds the New Deal is whether or not it prospered in helping America out of a depression. David M. Kennedy argues that the New Deal did indeed serve its purpose, by implementing policies, which improved the economy as well as American lifestyle on a general level, in his piece What the New Deal Did. In New Deal Agricultural Policy: An Evaluation, Theodore Saloutos comes to the same conclusion as Kennedy, except focused on agricultural aspects of the New Deal that helped revive the economy. On the other hand, Harold L. Cole and Lee E. Ohanian use statistics to argue that the New Deal policies were the reason why the economy was unable to recover following the Great Depression in their piece, New Deal Policies and the Persistence of the Great Depression: A General Equilibrium Analysis. After examining all three articles, Cole and Ohanian’s findings seem to overpower the opinions of Kennedy and Saloutos, resulting in the conclusion that the New Deal policies did more harm than good for America.

    Read More

  • Assessment of the Success of the New Deal

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Assessment of the Success of the New Deal FDR introduced the New Deal to help the people most affected by the depression of October 1929. The Wall Street Crash of October 24th 1929 in America signalled the start of the depression in which America would fall into serious economic depression. The depression started because some people lost confidence in the fact that their share prices would continue to rise forever, they sold their shares which started a mass panic in which many shares were sold. The rate at which people were selling their shares was so quick that the teleprinters could not keep up, therefore share prices continued to fall making them worthless. Also causing many people to lose their jobs as the owners of factories could not afford to pay the workers wages.

    Read More

  • The New Deal Dbq

    766 Words  | 2 Pages

    The New Deal was a set of acts that effectively gave Americans a new sense of hope after the Great Depression. The New Deal advocated for women’s rights, worked towards ending discrimination in the workplace, offered various jobs to African Americans, and employed millions through new relief programs. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR), made it his duty to ensure that something was being done. This helped restore the public's confidence and showed that relief was possible. The New Deal helped serve American’s interest, specifically helping women, african american, and the unemployed and proved to them that something was being done to help them.

    Read More

  • The Partial Success of The New Deal

    1237 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although Roosevelt is highly praised as an amazing leader during the great depression, one can argue it was the circumstances that put him in his position that made him famous. The New Deal was only partially successful, not entirely. There were parts of it that just didn’t work as much as they should have. For the most part, in more ways than one, historians argue that Roosevelt was not aggressive enough to help the economy. But what it did bring to the table was an end to purely laissez-faire policies – the US was beginning to shed traditional values in favor of European economic aspects. Sure, conservatives whined that every baby step away from capitalism was a monstrous leap toward socialism and even communism. But a little government intervention, especially in a time of crisis, goes a long way.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq

    1227 Words  | 3 Pages

    The New Deal was Franklin D. Roosevelt’s plan to stop The Great Depression in the 1930’s. He passed more legislation in eight days than any other president did in a whole term as the president of the United States. His plan included financial reforms, public works projects, federal programs, and regulations. FDR passed relief measures in order to provide immediate relief, recovery measures to rebuild the economy, and reform measures to keep America from having another depression. The New Deal did not successfully end the Great Depression; however, it did stabilize the economy and keep it from getting any worse.

    Read More

  • New Deal Dbq

    1545 Words  | 4 Pages

    Coming into the 1930’s, the United States underwent a severe economic recession, referred to as the Great Depression. Resulting in high unemployment and poverty rates, deflation, and an unstable economy, the Great Depression considerably hindered American society. In 1932, Franklin Roosevelt was nominated to succeed the spot of presidency, making his main priority to revamp and rebuild the United States, telling American citizens “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people," (“New” 2). The purpose of the New Deal was to expand the Federal Government, implementing authority over big businesses, the banking system, the stock market, and agricultural production. Through the New Deal, acts were passed to stimulate the economy, aid banks, alleviate environmental problems, eliminate poverty, and create a stronger central government (“New”1).

    Read More

  • Was the New Deal a Good Deal for America?

    609 Words  | 2 Pages

    In his presidential acceptance speech in 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt addressed to the citizens of the United States, “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.” The New Deal, beginning in 1933, was a series of federal programs designed to provide relief, recovery, and reform to the fragile nation. The U.S. had been both economically and psychologically buffeted by the Great Depression. Many citizens looked up to FDR and his New Deal for help. However, there is much skepticism and controversy on whether these work projects significantly abated the dangerously high employment rates and pulled the U.S. out of the Great Depression. The New Deal was a bad deal for America because it only provided opportunities for a few and required too much government spending.

    Read More

  • New Deal

    788 Words  | 2 Pages

    Franklin Roosevelt’s “optimism and activism that helped restore the badly shaken confidence of the nation” (pg. 467 Out of Many), was addressed in the New Deal, developed to bring about reform to the American standard of living and its low economy. It did not only make an impact during the Great Depression. Although, many of the problems addressed in the New Deal might have been solved, those with the long lasting effect provide enough evidence to illustrate how great a success the role of the New Deal played out in America’s history to make it what it is today.

    Read More

  • How Did The New Deal Affect The Economy

    254 Words  | 1 Pages

    The era of Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s presidency was a time of hardship in the United States but also the mission of recovery. The economy was at a complete downfall with millions in poverty and unemployed. With the help of congress, President Franklin D. Roosevelt created several government role changes and implemented several reforms and welfare programs. Many of his advisors had different opinions and ideas in recovering the United States; however, it was FDR’s decisions that was final creating the “New Deal”.

    Read More

  • Roosevelt's New Deal: Triumph Amidst Trials

    740 Words  | 2 Pages

    The time period of the deal was very rough, many people suffered to take care of their family's and could barely make it by, unfortunately Roosevelt had to deal with this. The new deal was something nobody had ever dealt with before, Roosevelt did what he could to help our nation and sadly not everything ended the way he would have liked. Our national debt was higher than it had ever been, this was the start to World War Two and many other things occurred that we regrettably could not fix, but the good outweighed the bad many new laws were passed and are still around today. Although the new deal put the nation in a difficult situation, Roosevelt was able to create equal opportunities for youth and civil liberties for all, and also opened up

    Read More

  • The Pros and Cons of Roosevelt's New Deal

    1214 Words  | 3 Pages

    The era of the Great Depression was by far the worst shape the United States had ever been in, both economically and physically. Franklin Roosevelt was elected in 1932 and began to bring relief with his New Deal. In his first 100 days as President, sixteen pieces of legislation were passed by Congress, the most to be passed in a short amount of time. Roosevelt was re-elected twice, and quickly gained the trust of the American people. Many of the New Deal policies helped the United States economy greatly, but some did not. One particularly contradictory act was the Agricultural Adjustment Act, which was later declared unconstitutional by Congress. Many things also stayed very consistent in the New Deal. For example, the Civilian Conservation Corps, and Social Security, since Americans were looking for any help they could get, these acts weren't seen as a detrimental at first. Overall, Roosevelt's New Deal was a success, but it also hit its stumbling points.

    Read More

  • The New Deal

    1629 Words  | 4 Pages

    The New Deal period has generally - but not unanimously - been seen as a turning point in American politics, with the states relinquishing much of their autonomy, the President acquiring new authority and importance, and the role of government in citizens' lives increasing. The extent to which this was planned by the architect of the New Deal, Franklin D. Roosevelt, has been greatly contested, however. Yet, while it is instructive to note the limitations of Roosevelt's leadership, there is not much sense in the claims that the New Deal was haphazard, a jumble of expedient and populist schemes, or as W. Williams has put it, "undirected". FDR had a clear overarching vision of what he wanted to do to America, and was prepared to drive through the structural changes required to achieve this vision.

    Read More

  • The New Deal Reforms

    1052 Words  | 3 Pages

    The United States faced the worst economic downfall in history during the Great Depression. A domino effect devastated every aspect of the economy, unemployment rate was at an all time high, banks were declaring bankruptcy and the frustration of the general public led to the highest suicide rates America has ever encountered. In the 1930’s Franklin D Roosevelt introduced the New Deal reforms, which aimed to “reconcile democracy, individual liberty and economic planning” (Liberty 863). The New Deal reforms were effective in the short term but faced criticism as it transformed the role of government and shaped the lives of American citizens.

    Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of The New Deal

Open Document