Views on Different Cultures Presented in Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan and Search For My Tongue

1177 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Comparing presents from my aunts in Pakistan with searching for my tongue

Views on Different Cultures Presented in Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan and Search For My Tongue

For my essay I am going to compare 'Search For My Tongue' by Sujata

Bhatt and 'Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan' by Moniza Alvi.

'Presents from my Aunts in Pakistan' is autobiographical. It is set in

England where the author talks about and describes the presents that

she receives from her Aunts who live in Pakistan.

'Search for my Tongue' is written while living in Germany but during

her life Sujata Bhatt has had to speak three different languages.

These are: Gujarati, English and German. She writes how she feels at

the way that she has to lose or forget her original language which is

Gujarati and only speak the language of the country that she is living

in which is currently Germany and then she realises that although she

has to speak German on the streets she doesn't have to speak it at

home and she doesn't have to write or think in German. She realises

that not speaking a language does not mean that you have lost your

cultural identity.

In 'Search for my Tongue' I think that Sujata Bhatt does not like

having to belong to two cultures. The line ' if you lived in a place

you had to speak a foreign tongue' reinforces this point. The words

'had to' suggest the fact that she is being forced to speak German

when she really wants to speak Gujarati. This implies the fact that

she does not want to have to speak German but feels she has no other

choice and would much rather be speaking Gujarati. In saying she would

rather speak Gujarati also implies that she is not forgetting her

language deliberately, she does not want to forget it ...

... middle of paper ...

...t that she doesn't want to be part

of the culture that she is currently in and she misses her original

culture. The lines; 'Your mother tongue would rot, rot and die in your

mouth', shows how she misses her old culture and feels she is almost

being forced to forget it.

In 'Presents…' the line 'I could never be as lovely as those clothes,'

makes you realise that she thinks that the clothes and the culture are

both lovely and wonderful but she feels she would never fit in with

them.

Both of these poems are wonderful. They both portray a search for

cultural identity, and while one seems to find hers the other appears

to end her poem at a point where she is still at the beginning of her

quest. Overall my favourite poem is Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan

but I also really enjoyed reading 'Search for my tongue'.

Show More
Related

  • With close reference to Before you were mine Mother..any distance and

    869 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the last stanza it is explained how, even when she was a child, she

    Read More

  • Comparing Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan 'And Half-Caste'

    319 Words  | 1 Pages

    In ‘Presents From My Aunts in Pakistan' and 'Half Caste', the poets Moniza Alvi and John Agard uses first person narrative to protest and express their feeling of not belonging to a place. It describes their feelings of being recognized as having no fixed nationality by demanding answers. Present for my aunts in Pakistan talks about receiving gifts from her Pakistani aunt and asking questions on whether she belongs in Pakistan or England. She thinks she does not fit in the Pakistan clothes her aunt sent her, but neither does she with denim. Half-Caste is about the speaker asking someone to explain what they mean for calling him Half-Caste. It describes some events that are utilized to question us. The speaker speaks in a demanding tone with

    Read More

  • Search For My Tongue and Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan

    578 Words  | 2 Pages

    form the reader and wants the reader to know how it feels to have two

    Read More

  • Psy 270 Week 2 Community Interview Questions

    781 Words  | 2 Pages

    Her primary language is English. She said that although she learned some Spanish in high school, she isn’t comfortable speaking it because she thinks that she will say something incorrectly and that it would be embarrassing.

    Read More

  • Free College Admissions Essays: Multifaceted Background

    465 Words  | 1 Pages

    I do not consider myself Paki-American. I am too "Americanized" to be Pakistani. (although by birthright, I am American), and I am not quite up to par with the American way of life. So what does all this have to do with my culture, what does a label really matter to cultural identity? It matters much. I believe that this seemingly trivial confusion over labels reveals the even greater confusion that surrounds my cultural identity: Am I a bridge between these two multifaceted cultures, or have I become a mosaic displaying colors from here and there, and elsewhere too? Perhaps both, and I could be a colorful bridge, or perhaps neither. Whatever the case, I cannot seem to separate these absolutely disparate realities within me. Their forces are still clashing, coming together within me, creating a wonderful confusion out of me. I believe that to truly analyze my culture, the roots of this confusion must be explored. In the span of this essay, I must try to encompass the widths of two worlds, their unique interactions within me... which I hope constitute what is called culture.

    Read More

  • Poe/Dickinson Central Idea Paper

    789 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...n seems to be the only thing that kept her together, and once is breaks, she does too. The end of the poem results in a finale of her knowledge, “And Finished knowing – then-“. At the end of both writings, the narrators’ self-awareness and realization explained their final actions.

    Read More

  • Of Gogol's Assimilation, Misidentification, And Cultural Restoration

    1316 Words  | 3 Pages

    I am not a child of immigrants, but maintaining one’s culture is a universal struggle in a land far from one’s ethnic origins. Lahiri suggests that without cultural connections such as family and friends, one’s culture can simply vanish if they are not in the land of ethnic origin. I have found this to be true within my own

    Read More

  • Trapped by Two Cultures in Beets, Made You Mine, America, and Sangre 24

    712 Words  | 2 Pages

    Something that has always fascinated me is the confrontation with a completely different culture. We do not have to travel far to realize that people really lead different lives in other countries and that the saying "Home sweet home" often applies to most of us. What if we suddenly had to leave our homes and settle somewhere else, somewhere where other values and beliefs where common and where people spoke a different language? Would we still try to hang on to the 'old home' by speaking our mother tongue, practising our own religion and culture or would we give in to the new and exciting country and forget our past? And what would it be like for our children, and their children? In Identity Lessons - Contemporary Writing About Learning to Be American I found many different stories telling us what it is like to be "trapped" between two cultures. In this short essay I aim to show that belonging to two cultures can be very confusing.

    Read More

  • The Blue Estuaries Personification

    718 Words  | 2 Pages

    As the poem begins, the narrator recounts her seemingly revolutionary experience; beginning with the narrator in the college

    Read More

  • The Meaning Of Liberalism: The Definition Of Liberalism

    1094 Words  | 3 Pages

    being of an individual depends on the well-being of their cultural group or whose cultural

    Read More

  • Arts of the Contact Zone

    1183 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...inferior cultures are always able to adapt and learn things from larger groups, in contact zone environments the larger groups are finally able to draw things from the smaller cultures as well, and thus transculturation becomes a two-way street. Only when people are made aware of the marginal diversity that surrounds them in everyday life are they able to gain a wider understanding and deeper knowledge of the world around them. They are then able to apply that knowledge to shape and benefit the way they interact with others and operate as a part of a society that is more open, leaving behind the mistake of imagined communities and applying inaccurate definitions to groups of people.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between The Joy Luck Club And For A Daughter Who Leaves

    1322 Words  | 3 Pages

    The beginning of the poem starts

    Read More

  • Blessing by Imtiaz Dharker

    806 Words  | 2 Pages

    of the poem into a crescendo at the bursting of the pipe. She uses an

    Read More

  • Cultural Relativism: Vice And Virtue In Everyday Life

    1546 Words  | 4 Pages

    This means that many times the definition of a culture becomes very blurry and that following the standards in each culture is quite difficult. An example of this in our world today can be seen in China’s underground Christian church movement. These are citizens of China who because of the government forbidding the act of preaching to other citizens are supposed to abide by the laws of the land, but are also obligated as Christians to preach the Gospel to those around them. They are wholly Chinese and wholly Christian, so forcing them to choose between the two is a difficult decision that many times leads to great persecution from the government. No person should be forced to conform to one culture, and it is close-minded and unrealistic to expect someone to obtain all of their morals from their geographical

    Read More

  • Adapting to a New Cultural Environment

    1289 Words  | 3 Pages

    At some point in our lives we experience a culture as an outsider by moving from one culture to another.In the world today there are so many different cultures and not one of them is found to be the same.Instead they all have something that makes them unique, whether its language or even the clothes they wear and their behavior as well.The differences they have is what separates them from one another and who ever joins that particular culture must get accustomed to their way of life.In the society today we have many people immigrating to the United States to start a new and better life but what they soon begin to realize is that it’s a whole new world out there and in order to survive they have to get accustomed to the new way of life which is much different from their lives before.

    Read More

More about Views on Different Cultures Presented in Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan and Search For My Tongue

Open Document