Tybalt's Misinterpretation in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

856 Words2 Pages

Tybalt's Misinterpretation in Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and Juliet is the story of two "star-crossed lovers who take

their life" (prologue). Their families were ancient enemies based on an

ancient grudge no longer known, but still strong. Romeo and Juliet fall

passionately in love ignoring the fact they are, by household, enemies.

Friar Lawrence joins them in marriage in hope "to turn their households'

rancour to pure love"(p. 43). They married without their families'

permission or knowledge and against their society's conventions. Neither

Romeo nor Juliet could live without the other by their side and were

willing to do anything to be with each other. Shakespeare believes that

acting in response to knowledge without evidence or thought can lead to

disaster in the end.

Misfortunes occurred due to Tybalt and Mercutio's misinterpretation

of Romeo's reluctance to fight. Tybalt came to pick a fight with Romeo and

instead of getting what he wanted, Romeo continued to hold back because of

his marriage to Juliet. Tybalt continued to push for conflict not

understanding Romeo's unwillingness. Mercutio also misunderstands Romeo's

reluctance to fight and decides to stand up for him by challenging Tybalt

to a dual. Tybalt and Mercutio end up fighting. When Romeo stepped in

between the fighting Mercutio believed that the dual had ended. And as

Mercutio was taken off guard Tybalt attacked and Mercutio was killed.

Romeo wanted to get Tybalt back for what he had done and make Mercutio's

death of some worth. Romeo used his rage and grief to slay Tybalt. All of

this had happened because of Tybalt's and Mercutio's little

misinterpretation of Romeo. Both acted without thinking or waiting for a

little sense of the matter or any kind of explanation. Two lives were

taken as

a result and one banished from his true love.

Romeo's banishment from Verona resulted in Friar Lawrence's failure

to form a back up plan of any kind in case Romeo would not receive the

letter or learn of the plan with Juliet. Right after Friar Lawrence

received news that Juliet was to be married to Paris he created a plan

right on the spot. The plot involved taking a substance that would make

her appear to be dead. He said that he would send a letter to Romeo

Open Document