Too Many People? by Vanessa Baird
analytical Essay
1435 words
The worldwide population is approaching 7 billion and is expected to reach 9 billion by 2050 (Baird). This projected population number is down from a once predicted 16 billion (Baird) and while some are not concerned, others are worried about any increase in population. Population growth is discussed in the articles “Too Many People?” by Vanessa Baird; “Population Control: How Can There Possibly Be Too Many of Us?” by Frank Furedi; and “The Population Bomb Revisited,” by Paul R. Ehrlich and Anne H. Ehrlich. Baird and Furedi concur that a concern for population growth has been around since mathematician Thomas Malthus, in 1798, warned that overpopulation could lead to “the collapse of society” (Furedi). Furedi claims that too much human life is being used as an excuse, by population control supporters, for the world’s current and future problems. Baird tries to discover if “the current panic over population growth is reasonable.” For Ehrlich and Ehrlich the concern over population growth is very real, and they reinforce and support their book “calling attention to the demographic element in the human predicament” (Ehrlich and Ehrlich 63). While taking different approaches to their articles, the authors offer their perspectives on population growth, population control and the environmental impacts of a growing population.
The authors have differing perspectives on population growth. Ehrlich and Ehrlich believe
“ignored population growth,” since writing their book in 1968, is one reason “collapse now seem[s] ever more likely” (63). They suggest we can avoid collapse if we reduce our population to an “optimal number” and they reinforce the message of their book, earth has a finite capacity and a growing ...
... middle of paper ...
... provides us with information to put the “panic” over population into perspective. She addresses both the benefits and side effects of family planning and that population growth can have environmental concerns. Whether offering an opinion or presenting an academic writing or investigation, each author has left the reader with a great deal to consider in regards to the relationship between population control and a growing population.
Works Cited
Baird, Vanessa. “Too Many People?” New Internationalist 01 Jan. 2010:
Web. 30 Sept. 2011.
Ehrlich, Paul R., and Anne H. “The Population Bomb Revisited.” The Electronic Journal 1.3
(2009): 63-71. Web. 30 Sept. 2011.
Furedi, Frank. “Population Control: How Can There Possibly Be Too Many of Us?” Spiked
18 Jun. 2007. Web. 30 Sept. 2011.
Internet World Stats. 19 Jul. 2011. Web. 17 Oct. 2011.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the world's population is approaching 7 billion and is expected to reach 9 billion by 2050.
- Analyzes how furedi believes too much human life around killing the planet is an increasingly popular idea encouraged by population control groups.
- Compares ehrlich and furedi's views on population growth and terrorism.
- Argues that while baird and ehrlich see benefits to family planning, furedi disagrees with the concerns of an ageing population.
Related
- opinion
- analytical
- comparative
- explanatory
- Essay On Population Overpopulationopinion essayIn 1950, the world had 2.5 billion people; and in 2005, the world had 6.5 billion people. By 2050, this number could rise to more than 9 billion.” The fact that the population of humans on Earth could be over 10 billion people in a hundred years is shocking to me. Many projections say our global population could become unsustainable due to lack of energy sources. “Given the unequivocal relation between energy use and fertility, stabilizing the global population by mid-century will require vastly more energy than is currently projected to be available.”(DeLong 6) If those projections are even close to accurate, it can only mean problems for us and our planet. We need to start reducing the population growth rate now. That statement, at first, should make anyone a little uncomfortable. Slowing down the rate at which people reproduce is something that seems impossible to do without severely violating our natural human
In this essay, the author
- Opines that if we don't find legitimate answers to these questions now, it will be too late. the selfish mentality that could be the difference between humanity's survival and extinction.
- Argues that the population of humans on earth could be over 10 billion people in a hundred years due to lack of energy sources. slowing down the rate at which people reproduce is something that seems impossible without violating our natural human rights.
- Opines that any person, no matter their race, gender, or culture, should be able to have children. there are many circumstances where people aren't capable of properly supporting and raising a child.
- Opines that the government should not deny an innocent couple the right to have children, regardless of their disabilities or genetic imperfections.
- Opines that a permit could help ensure good homes for every child and increase the ratio of children being raised by their biological parents.
- Explains that a parenting license is meant to ensure probable quality of character in the generations of the future and keep us from overfilling our planet.
1209 wordsRead More - Garrett Hardinanalytical essayIn “The Tragedy of the Common,” Garrett Hardin discusses the problem of overpopulation. He argues that unlike other dilemmas in the world, the current crisis of overpopulation is a complex problem without a technical solution. The exponential growth of the human race will, as Hardin asserts is to be, the downfall of humanity. Unfortunately, this tragedy is unavoidable as there are too many variables in the mix to effectively solve the problem of overpopulation and avoid the destruction and extinction of the human race. In society, individuals think within their own bubble. They act on their beliefs, on their wants, and on their needs; not the needs of the rest of the world. Most people fail to recognize the serious consequences of “adding one
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how garrett hardin's "the tragedy of the common" argues that overpopulation is a complex problem with no technical solution.
317 wordsRead More - Overpopulation Issuesopinion essayAs a society, we are currently sitting in a position of increasing pressure to act on the issue of overpopulation. To develop a plan of action on long term sustainability solutions for our planet, the fundamental problems that arise from overpopulation must be explained and understood. Overpopulation brings a multitude of consequences for society as well as the environment. Individuals of rapidly growing countries experience lower education levels, inability for economic success, and an increased chance of contracting diseases. Similarly, the environment is affected by overpopulation through loss of habitat and freshwater, climate change, and intensive agricultural practices. The answers to these issues will have to be centered around two main
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the focus on reducing the possible problems of overpopulation must be directed toward high growth, "stage two" countries such as india and sub-saharan africa.
- Opines that overpopulation is causing environmental problems, such as loss of freshwater, habitat loss, increased global warming, and intensive farming practices.
- Analyzes how the people paradox introduced two solutions to combat overpopulation: economic and social gains and the education and liberation of women, which will lift the countries of rapid growth to a position of stabilization.
- Opines that if progress is to be made on overpopulation, the lives of women must improve. a strong economy allows women to move away from the focus of large families and focus on individual careers.
- Opines that we are at a crucial position for population stabilization or explosion. if fertility drops to an average just below two children, population could double, reaching over 11 billion by mid-century.
- Explains the social and environmental consequences that arise from overpopulation and high growth states have been shown to be monumentally destructive. the movie "the people paradox" and text "environment in anthropology" introduced two possible solutions.
- Explains that the movie "the people paradox" and the book "environment in anthropology" set the foundational outlines for these overpopulation consequences and their solutions.
1502 wordsRead More - Overpopulation is Not Really a Problemanalytical essayToday, as we near the 21st century, overpopulation, as some may call it, still seems to be a concern. There have been reports that, if the current rate of population growth were maintained, the world will be home to some 694 trillion people by the year 2150, almost 125 times that of today's population (Bender, p. 65). On October 12th, 1999, the world was presented with the associated press headline that the world population counter at the UN topped 6 billion. It is evident that our society is still concerned about the increasing population. The intent of this paper is to prove that there is not, and will never be, according to long-term trends, a situation in which it is impossible to provide everyone on earth a living standard at the subsistence level.
In this essay, the author
- Argues that overpopulation is a concern as we approach the 21st century. the paper aims to prove that there is not, and will never be, an impossible situation.
- Explains that the world's food supply increased so much that it provided a larger population with even more food supplies per person, contrary to malthus' theory.
- Explains that the world today possesses enough food to feed the entire human population of the earth.
- States the law of conservation of matter states that material is neither created nor destroyed in any chemical or physical reaction.
- Explains bender, david, bruno leone, charles f. hohm, lori justine jones, population: opposing viewpoints.
- Analyzes how rev. thomas malthus predicted that the growing european population would quickly outstrip its available resources. paul ehrlich's the population bomb predicted tens of millions of people would starve to death in the 1970s.
- Explains that paul ehrlich predicted that the world would outgrow its food supply in 1969. he failed to take into account the increase in labor power and advancements in technology associated with population increase.
- Explains that women are choosing to have fewer children. the total fertility rate, a hypothetical measure, is the expected number of lifetime births that 1,000 women would have.
- Explains that the predictions failed due to the large increase in food supply, which is measured by calories per capita per day.
- Explains that the "fortune tellers" believed the world would outgrow its food supply, and that certain resources may be limited, but the amount of material in this world will never decrease.
- Opines that starvation does not occur due to an overall lack of food supply, but occurs because it is "economically unfavorable" to export their food to a country that can not afford it.
1265 wordsRead More - Cause And Effect Essay On Overpopulationcomparative essayOf all of the environmental issues we perceive on the planet today, overpopulation is one that can be easily overlooked. Challenges such as pollution, climate change and global warming all seem to take priority in coverage, education and discovering solutions, but the majority of key environmental issues flow from the very fact that humans are over populating the globe. Overpopulation is the rapid increase of the human population, which is gradually exceeding the capacity of the globe.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that overpopulation is a global issue, affecting all of humanity. it is caused by an increase in births, reduced mortality rates, immigration and improved medical understanding.
- Explains the effects of overpopulation on the environment, including water pollution, depletion of natural resources, and deforestation.
- Explains that the world's population will increase to approximately 9 billion in 25 years. this will have drastic effects on our environment such as soil contamination, worsening climate change, and mass species becoming extinct.
- Predicts that the world's overpopulated population will increase to approximately 11.5 billion by 2025, leading to an increase in air pollution, human waste, and inadequate fresh water supply.
1048 wordsRead More - Malthusian Principle Of Populationanalytical essayIn Thomas Malthus’ Essay on the Principle of Population, the scholar describes what he believes to be the constant pressures on the growth of human populations. Though he postulates that populations are checked by the “means of subsistence,” or amount of food that must be produced for everyone in a population to survive, he is unable to correctly predict the technological advances that allow for more production to occur in smaller areas of land. His linear versus exponential growth models for food production and population, respectively, were also largely approximated and did not take into account the continued progress of civilization and the ability of humanity to innovate and solve problems. Furthermore, while his assumption that the attraction between the sexes will never be removed from society still holds true today, he is unable to foresee scientific advancements such as contraception that decrease the number of children per
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how malthus' essay on the principle of population is valuable and should be considered as a model for analytical observations of societies.
- Analyzes how malthus argues that food is a limiting factor of any population, though his predictions are arbitrary and based on his current views of english society.
- Analyzes how malthus' essay demonstrates that he is taking a purely analytical stance on the topic of describing the effects of population growth.
- Analyzes how malthus understands that industrialization leads to large increases in production, but that population dynamics are more complex than a simple correlation with industry.
- Analyzes how malthus criticizes the poor laws for their illogical nature. he removes himself from the situation and takes an objective point of view.
- Analyzes how malthus logically describes the situation of the rapidly developing english society and ignores the implications of technological and societal advances that would result from the industrial revolution.
1814 wordsRead More - The Plague of Overpopulationanalytical essayCritics are warning that at almost six and a half billion people currently inhabiting the world, we are coming dangerously close to the sustainable capacity of planet Earth. Overpopulation and attempts to control the whirlwind of reproduction that is plaguing both developing and developed nations has been dog-eared as one of the major concerns for the United Nations at the recent summit in Johannesburg. Both Edwin Dolan and Charles Southwick have cited the population explosion that started post-industrialization in their respective excerpts; "TANSTAAFL: The Economic Strategy for Economic Crisis" and Global Ecology and Human Perspective - as a problem deserving serious attention both in academia and the international front. However, both men's arguments contain some rather significant holes for several reasons. The first is perhaps often overlooked when discussing the Earth's ultimate capacity in terms of human population. What is a sustainable number of persons on the Earth? How is it to be measured? What basic human rights should be ensured to every man, woman, and child, and how can these rights be ensured without a redistribution of wealth? In essence, can overpopulation and economic disparity be separated? Southwick discusses this, but gives no decisive verdict on how the two are actually related, while Dolan claims that the issue is of less urgency than commonly perceived.
In this essay, the author
- Argues that overpopulation and attempts to control the whirlwind of reproduction that is plaguing both developing and developed nations have been dog-eared as a major concern for the united nations at the recent summit in johannesburg.
- Analyzes how dolan and southwick fail to include important viewpoints into their arguments, which ultimately results in the weakening of their chosen position.
- Analyzes how southwick doesn't define overpopulation, but he points to the environmental consequences of too many people in any confined area and depleting their resources beyond repletion.
- Analyzes how dolan skirts the issue of overpopulation, focusing instead on how the rate of growth will eventually curb itself.
- Analyzes southwick's claim that the optimal carrying capacity of the world is only 2 billion persons. the real global problem is the ever-increasing poverty gap that is correlated to this overpopulation.
- Analyzes dolan's argument regarding the eradication of the human population explosion in the u.s. and other well-developed countries.
- Opines that a simple educational plan funded by the wealthier, more developed countries and global organizations, namely the united nations, teaching methods of birth control, can curb the population explosion in some places.
- Argues that overpopulation is another way of implying environmental degradation. southwick's "reasonable standard of living" aligns itself with the definition of an american lifestyle.
- Cites southwick, charles h., ch. 15 from "global ecology in human perspective" oxford univ. press, 1996, pp. 159-182.
1925 wordsRead More - Population Developmentexplanatory essayAmong the first main publications considering at the ability of the earth to withstand its population was ‘An essay on the principle of population’ written in 1798 by Thomas Malthus. In this article, Mathus suggested that the future population growth was unsustainable As population grew more than resources , the population out grew the resources accessible to them leading to famine, diseases and war.This was unpredicted due to advances in technology, sanitation, population growth slowing down and food distribution, however the general theory is still relevant in the 21st century.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that poor households and children in low and middle income countries were hardest hit by economic fallout. the world bank indicated that 130 million people were considered into extreme poverty.
- Explains that the world bank report on assessing aid -- what works, what doesn't, and why states that if donors provided their assistance to the right countries, poverty reduction would be more successful.
- Explains that the concept of people's participation was formulated in the 1970s, in response to the growing awareness of the many approaches and in addition of employed for rural development.
- Explains that unicef is the latest international organization to withdraw funding from uganda.
934 wordsRead More - We Can Stop Overpopulationexplanatory essayOverpopulation is when the demand of humans is too high for the supply of the earth. Many people do not consider this a threat or have even considered it. Many scientists believe that the world can hold up to 10 billion people which will be in the next 100 years. (Wolchover, 4) Will you or even your children be alive? To many of you the answer is yes. If the world’s fertility rate is above 2.1 children per woman then it is something we need to be conscious about. We can look at the history, present, and future of overpopulation to decide what the next step will be.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that china's one child policy is to ensure the number of people in the country starts to fall.
- Explains that overpopulation is when the demand of humans is too high for the supply of the earth.
- Explains that india has made an effort to lower their population count of 1.25 billion people by using a lottery type system that allows you to win cars, tvs, motorcycles and more.
- Explains the end of the one-child policy in china. the lancet 377.9770 (2011).
- Explains cooper, mary h., and katz, joelle. "the problem of overpopulation and how we can work to solve it."
1238 wordsRead More - Population Control: Preventing Unwanted Pregnanciesopinion essayThe world’s population is rising rapidly from seven billion to the estimated nine billion in 2050 (Ellis, Overpopulation is Not the Problem). Every human being adds stress to the Earth’s resources. Numerous places like Africa and China maintain a copious amount starvation and poverty. There are days when people go without food, water, or shelter. There is even such happening in the United States. In such places, it is difficult to find contraception, or birth control, which leads to unplanned pregnancies. These situations are rooted down to overpopulation, which is when there are too many humans. However, there is a multitude of ways to reverse such negative effects. Population control is a necessary act that will benefit the world through sparing natural resources, decreasing famine, and controlling unplanned pregnancies. A worldwide effort would have to take effect in order for a successful future.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that population control is a necessary act that will benefit the world through sparing natural resources, decreasing famine, and controlling unplanned pregnancies.
- Explains that china has a list of problems while maintaining one fifth of the world’s population.
- Explains that in the 1940s, china viewed promoting a larger population as positive improvement for political strength and to improve economic development.
- Explains that since the 1980s, china created law that differs from normal life in the united states. the law restricts a couple to only conceiving one child.
- Explains that the chinese government has made contraception, public health care, and additional types of birth control more tangible to those who could not afford it.
- Analyzes how poverty and famine overwhelm the country. deforestation takes away precious land from wildlife, and food from humans.
- Explains that pollution, desertification, population growth, and food consumption will affect the future. populations in africa are skyrocketing past the lands limit.
- Opines that population control is necessary in order to eliminate hunger and poverty, not because of abhorring a huge population.
- Explains that industrialization has caused excess air pollution and has led to health problems in china as well as other countries.
- Opines that countries should reduce car travel and make homes more efficient in order to solve countless problems throughout the world. the earth will soon be pushed to its maximum capacity.
- Opines that population control is the key to a future containing less starvation and jocular lives.
- Opines that overpopulation is not the problem, and navarro, mireya, pflanz, mike.
1033 wordsRead More