The Wisdom Of Whores Analysis

1483 Words3 Pages

“The Wisdom of Whores” Critical Review
The control and eradication of HIV/AIDS should be of the upmost importance for the whole of the global community. Though many modern countries have effectively treated and controlled the disease in the last few decades in their own societies, it is vital for third-world countries and poorer nations to control the disease in order to advance as a population. Currently, the methods in place to control HIV/AIDS do not work in poor countries due to stigmas attached to the disease and to a general lack in understanding of it. In “The Wisdom of Whores,” Elizabeth Pasini presents a new method of studying the disease from a scientific perspective that is both viable and promising as a solution to AIDS/HIV problem. Her proposal is very strong and well documented. She uses her own experience working in UNAIDS, the CDC, and the WHO to help support her claims from a first hand account and cities a lot of her own, as well as other, scientific research to explain why the focus should be on the tracking patterns and spread of HIV/AIDS, instead of simply on the control of it. Her general argument is very persuasive and provides information from a viewpoint not normally assessed. Proponents of NGOs and religious groups who go in to help prevent the spread of the disease would be the only real dissent against her argument. They would argue against her suggestion that NGOs and religious groups have hurt HIV/AIDS prevention in the past or are currently affecting the control of the disease in a negative way.
According to WHO in 2007, “more than 95% of HIV cases are in developing countries, with two-thirds of them in sub-Saharan Africa. “ In addition, there were 2.1 million deaths related to HIV and 2.5 million...

... middle of paper ...

...not take into great account, they really fail to persuade their readers that NGOs can be successful if enough effort is put into the collective action by the aided government and the organizations as a whole.
Pasini’s overall thesis is simply that the way HIV/AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa should be approached should be changed. Her background, based solely in science and not medicine, leads her to suggest that following the patterns and spread of HIV/AIDS rather than focusing on the control and treatment of it will allow us to successfully stop it in the future. She is both compelling and persuasive in her argument, really making the reader believe what she says. Not only does she use the best possible evidence, firsthand experience, but she also explains what the major issues facing the HIV/AIDS community are in stigmas, marginalization, and organizational problems.

Open Document