The Triple Helix written by Richard Lewontin and The Beak of the Finch written by Jonathan Weiner transport the reader to the world of evolutionary theories. Although both authors discuss the evolution of species, they take distinctive and different approaches as they describe to the reader their specific scope of evolution itself. These differences are seen throughout both novels and the conclusions made on evolution from both authors challenge each reader’s individual belief on natural selection, genes, and the environment itself.
Lewontin acknowledges that the The Triple Helix has a “distinctly negative flavor” (pg. 109) to explaining how a reductionist approach may lead us to formulating an incomplete picture of biological processes of living organisms. Although the author may have wrote the book with this mindset, The Triple Helix reiterates that genes are not the only factor for living organisms development, but it is a extraordinary relationship of genes, organism, and environment that influence the biological processes for an organism to succeed.
The first chapter of Lewontin’s argument, “Gene and Organism”, focuses on the problem of relying on genetics for all the answers to organism development. For example, the Drosophila (or fruit fly) shows a mutation on the development of its head. A normal fly has antennas, while the Drosophila replaces the antennas with “leg-like appendages” (Figure 1.2, pg. 15). Lewontin explains that these dramatic gene mutations convince established biologists that variation within organisms must have occurred because of genetic differences (pg. 15). However, the environment plays a tremendous role in organism development, “a unique interaction between genes and [an organism], and random ...
... middle of paper ...
...researcher indicate value to Lewontin’s theory on evolution. The dynamic processes of Grants findings, however, would not fit ideally into Triple Helix.
To conclude Richard Lewontin’s The Triple Helix and The Beak of the Finch written by Jonathan Weiner engaged the reader to view evolutionary theory in juxtaposing lenses. While Lewontin has strong opinions towards modern evolutionary biologists, Weiner praises Peter and Rosemary Grant for their work following Darwin’s Origin of Species. Finally, the conclusions constructed by both authors transport the reader to the enthralling world of evolutionary biology and all of its differences.
Work Cited
Lewontin, Richard C.. The Triple Helix: Gene, Organism, and Environment. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP, 2000. Print.
Weiner, Jonathan. The Beak of the Finch: A Story of Evolution in Our Time. New York: Knopf, 1994. Print.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how richard lewontin and jonathan weiner's the triple helix and the beak of the finch transport the reader to the world of evolutionary theories.
Analyzes how lewontin acknowledges that the triple helix has a "distinctly negative flavor" to explain how reductionist approach may lead us to formulating an incomplete picture of biological processes of living organisms.
Analyzes how lewontin's argument, "gene and organism", focuses on the problem of relying on genetics for all the answers to organism development.
Analyzes how richard lewontin and jonathan weiner's the triple helix and the beak of the finch transport the reader to the world of evolutionary theories.
Analyzes how lewontin acknowledges that the triple helix has a "distinctly negative flavor" to explain how reductionist approach may lead us to formulating an incomplete picture of biological processes of living organisms.
Analyzes how lewontin's argument, "gene and organism", focuses on the problem of relying on genetics for all the answers to organism development.
Analyzes how lewontin uses an "empty bucket" analogy to explain an organism's capacity and how it might or might not be reached depending on its environment.
Explains that lewontin's idea of an organism and the environment comes from ideas of the central relationship of these two factors.
Explains that the triple helix envisions evolution as an interlocking system of genetics, organism, and the environment. genetic determinism is not the key to understanding evolution of living organisms.
Compares jonathan weiner's beak of the finch with lewontin, who focuses on the galápagos research of peter and rosemary grant on daphne major and darwin’s finches.
Analyzes how the beak of the finch is a complete 180 in terms of attitude of biologists and evolutionary theory.
Explains that darwin's finches needed to be isolated to fully explain the changes and variations within each finch. daphne major was the ideal area for any researcher to detect natural selection working in all of its glory.
Explains that darwin wrote that even the slightest variations are the foundation of natural selection and the important beginning stage of evolution. the grants studied the beaks of the thirteen species of finches on the island.
Explains how peter and rosemary grant found that the variability of the finches helped or hindered their ability to survival.
Argues that lewontin's the triple helix elucidates that the environment plays a tremendous role in organism development. the differences of organisms and their ability to reconstruct their environment, must be incorporated into weiner’s writings.
Explains that dna is becoming the answer for evolutionists and learning about the "history of life." the mutations in darwin's finches increased the variation in their genes and increased their evolution.
Analyzes how lewontin disagrees with weiner's idea that dna is the fundamental force in the variability of the finches at daphne major.
Analyzes how the use of darwin's model in the origin of species impacted the grants' conclusions about the finches because it relied heavily on the theory of natural selection.
Analyzes how lewontin describes how the grants skimmed over the possibility that organisms reconstruct their environment and can pick certain parts of the environment to use in survival.
Opines that lewontin's criticism of the finches would not be justified, since they have been isolated on daphne major for a tremendous amount of time, and their characteristics do not fit the mold of normal organisms.
Concludes richard lewontin's the triple helix and the beak of the finch written by jonathan weiner engage the reader to view evolutionary theory in juxtaposed lenses.
Click here to unlock this and over one million essays
Darwin, Charles, and David Quammen. On the Origin of Species. New York: Sterling, 2008. 349. Print.
In this essay, the author
Compares the views of charles darwin and john locke on slavery. both exemplify their views on equality.
Argues that darwin's views on evolution may have portrayed his writings of evolution. his observation of galapagos finches impacted his opposition on slavery, but it had no comparison to the beagle voyage.
Analyzes charles darwin's theory of instinct, which further establishes his opposition on slavery.
Compares the views of charles darwin and john locke on slavery. both exemplify their views on equality.
Argues that darwin's views on evolution may have portrayed his writings of evolution. his observation of galapagos finches impacted his opposition on slavery, but it had no comparison to the beagle voyage.
Analyzes charles darwin's theory of instinct, which further establishes his opposition on slavery.
Compares locke's views on the topic of slavery to charles darwin. he believes slavery should be a form of punishment for those who committed crimes deserving the death penalty.
Compares the views of charles darwin and john locke on equality, stating that slavery is a belittling act of indecency and maltreatment.
Analyzes how charles darwin's ideals demonstrate the true rights of the people, with his simple view that all people were created equally. locke believes in equality, but only when it is involved directly with the punishment of an individual.
Explains darwin, charles, and david quammen. on the origin of species.
Dawkins, Richard. The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution. New York: Free, 2009. Print.
In this essay, the author
Explains that fossils support creationism more than evolution. evolutionists believe that transitional species are a cross between two animals.
Explains shier, david, jackie butler, and ricki lewis' hole's essentials of human anatomy and physiology.
Explains richard dawkins' the greatest show on earth: the evidence for evolution.
Explains that fossils support creationism more than evolution. evolutionists believe that transitional species are a cross between two animals.
Explains shier, david, jackie butler, and ricki lewis' hole's essentials of human anatomy and physiology.
Explains richard dawkins' the greatest show on earth: the evidence for evolution.
Argues that evolution and creation have different perspectives on the origin of life. biblical creation is the belief that god created and designed the earth, while evolutionists believe in darwinian evolution.
Explains that the fossil record supports the theory of a worldwide flood.
Anyone with even a moderate background in science has heard of Charles Darwin and his theory of evolution. Since the publishing of his book On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection in 1859, Darwin’s ideas have been debated by everyone from scientists to theologians to ordinary lay-people. Today, though there is still severe opposition, evolution is regarded as fact by most of the scientific community and Darwin’s book remains one of the most influential ever written.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how the kallikak family tree is ambiguous when dealing with evidence contrary to its theory. it does not seem logical to try to eliminate people from the gene pool who simply weren't given an opportunity to succeed.
Explains that darwin's theory of evolution has been debated by scientists, theologians, and lay-people since his book on the origin of species by means of natural selection.
Argues that social darwinism is wrong about the survival of the fittest socially.
Analyzes how the kallikak family tree is ambiguous when dealing with evidence contrary to its theory. it does not seem logical to try to eliminate people from the gene pool who simply weren't given an opportunity to succeed.
Explains that darwin's theory of evolution has been debated by scientists, theologians, and lay-people since his book on the origin of species by means of natural selection.
Argues that social darwinism is wrong about the survival of the fittest socially.
Explains arthur, john, and hofstadter, mark h. eugenics: hereditarian attitudes in american thought.
Darwin’s theories, which have become the basis for Evolutionist thought, came from observations made while on an expedition in South America. After observing environmentally related variations in traits among 13 types of the same species of bird, Darwin developed the con...
In this essay, the author
Explains that darwin's ideas can't be used to prove a theory because it is based on observation rather than fact. evolutionist theories are fickle and each flaw is covered up.
Explains that the theory of evolution says life originated, and that life proceeds, by random.
Cites darwin, charles, the origin of species & the descent of man.
Explains that darwin's ideas can't be used to prove a theory because it is based on observation rather than fact. evolutionist theories are fickle and each flaw is covered up.
Explains that the theory of evolution says life originated, and that life proceeds, by random.
Cites darwin, charles, the origin of species & the descent of man.
Argues that darwin's theory of evolution is based on the concept of microevolution, while the evolutionists believe in the "big bang" theory.
Explains that scientists who set out to prove the theory of evolution end up finding evidence that supports the creationist view.
...(1995). The Beak of the Finch: A Story of Evolution in Our Time. Vintage Books: New York.
In this essay, the author
Argues that humanism answers questions about origins by naturalistic means and science has been redefined in the process.
Explains that theistic evolution rejects the christian tradition of interpreting the creation days as being normal 24-hour days. they believe that humans evolved from a bacterial precursor in the distant past.
Explains that theistic evolution meshes two worldviews, naturalism and christianity, laying a foundation for ethics and morality.
Argues that humanism answers questions about origins by naturalistic means and science has been redefined in the process.
Explains that theistic evolution rejects the christian tradition of interpreting the creation days as being normal 24-hour days. they believe that humans evolved from a bacterial precursor in the distant past.
Explains that theistic evolution meshes two worldviews, naturalism and christianity, laying a foundation for ethics and morality.
Explains that non-evolutionists object to the theory of evolution because no evidence has been found for mutations leading to new genes that are beneficial.
Explains that evolutionists often reconstruct supposed transitional forms with a few fossil fragments and imagination. the fossil record does not show the myriad missing links that the evolutionary theory anticipates.
Argues that theistic evolutionists should consider an alternative worldview, since faith and logic may be antonyms, but one's faith should have as few contradictions as possible.
Explains that foundational to recent creation is a proper view of god. no limits bound god’s power, wisdom, or love. he created and rules over the universe.
Explains that recent creationists read the chronological account in genesis 1 in a straightforward manner. they believe that the universe and all life forms were created in six 24-hour days.
Explains that god planted a special garden of beautiful trees with delicious fruit. after adam and eve were created, god commanded them to care for it.
Analyzes how accepting the evolutionary theory and death before adam dilutes god’s holiness and justice and destroys the heart of the gospel. if death did not come through adam, there is no hope of restoration to god through jesus christ.
Argues that theistic evolution pieces together two opposing worldviews: naturalism and christianity, and applies historical science duplicitously. evolutionists have found no new beneficial genes introduced by mutation and only a few disputable transitional forms
Explains ham, k. (2002). why won't they listen? a radical new approach to evangelism.
Explains weiner, j., the beak of the finch: a story of evolution in our time.
Analyzes how theistic evolutionists attempt to mix and match the two worldviews into one.
Argues that theistic evolutionists are inconsistent in their application of naturalistic science. the basic gospel message is dependent on miracles.
Explains that origins scientists have redefined science to meet their purposes. they recognize that the relegation of their field to the field of speculation would greatly damage their credibility.
Explains that stephen jay gould and other evolutionists postulated the punctuated equilibrium theory of evolution, which does not predict fossils.
The term evolution has been frequently linked to Darwin, however, the development of this theory also involves the influence of other forerunner such as Lamarck, where he and Darwin both support the idea of ‘natural selection’ (Than, 2015). Darwin’s Theory of Evolution consists the following four arguments:
In this essay, the author
Explains that evolution refers to the changes in genetic traits or mutation between several generations. it occurs during the breeding process, where the genes are copied passed on to offspring.
Explains that the term evolution has been frequently linked to darwin, however, the development of this theory involves the influence of other forerunners such as lamarck, where he and darwin both support the idea of ‘natural selection’.
Explains that natural selection acts only by taking advantage of slight successive variations; she can never take a great and sudden leap, but must advance by short and sure steps.
Explains that evolution refers to the changes in genetic traits or mutation between several generations. it occurs during the breeding process, where the genes are copied passed on to offspring.
Explains that the term evolution has been frequently linked to darwin, however, the development of this theory involves the influence of other forerunners such as lamarck, where he and darwin both support the idea of ‘natural selection’.
Explains that natural selection acts only by taking advantage of slight successive variations; she can never take a great and sudden leap, but must advance by short and sure steps.
Explains that darwin's theory of evolution has been agreed to be the most convenient theory for evolution. there are two theories that propose the origin of homo sapiens, the ‘multiregional’ and ‘out of africa’ hypothesizes.
Explains that the trend of hominid evolution can be easily identified via four characteristics: the cranial capacity, tooth size, shape of forehead and size of brow ridges.
Explains that modern chimpanzees are usually noted for their resemblance on behavior and dna to human, however, based on the two species were evolved differently, the changes in the shape and function of body structure are significant.
Explains that the presence of craft stone tools suggests the increase in intelligence of the hominid specie where the population are able to create tools for different needs.
Explains that the theory of premise is the starting point of all theories. the theory in crisis suggests that organisms will change genetically under the various pressures.
Explains that fossils are crucial evidence that support the theory of evolution, as they are the natural preserved remains or traces of organisms that once lived on earth.
Explains that the fossils of australopithecus and early hominid species remain in east africa due to the critical environment of northern africa and middle east.
Darwin’s investigation into evolution began when he trekked to the Galapagos Islands, where he would gather evidence that he would eventually put into his book. While in the Galapagos Islands, he discovered finches with beaks built to break into the specific type of nut that was on their island, with the birds on other islands also having corresponding beaks. He also found the tortoises that were previously mentioned, another key example of the adaptation of animals to their environments. This shows the ability, over ...
In this essay, the author
Explains that evolution is a hot topic, causing lots of controversy for almost 200 years. evolution is the belief that creatures have changed and adapted to their environments over time.
Analyzes how darwin's "origin of species" explains evolution in layers, but it wasn't truly put together until he observed differences among species to adapt to their environments.
Explains that darwin's investigation into evolution began when he trekked to the galapagos islands, where finches with beaks built to break into the specific type of nut that was on their island, and the tortoises that were previously mentioned.
Explains that evolution is a hot topic, causing lots of controversy for almost 200 years. evolution is the belief that creatures have changed and adapted to their environments over time.
Analyzes how darwin's "origin of species" explains evolution in layers, but it wasn't truly put together until he observed differences among species to adapt to their environments.
Explains that darwin's investigation into evolution began when he trekked to the galapagos islands, where finches with beaks built to break into the specific type of nut that was on their island, and the tortoises that were previously mentioned.
Explains that darwin's first book is dedicated to charles lyell, a predecessor of darwin in the world of evolutionary theory.
Explains darwin's theory that humans evolved from primates of some sort. homonids are part of the primate family, which is a direct statement of where we came from.
Explains that darwin's theory of natural selection is a big part of evolution, showing the gradual adaptation of characteristics in species.
Explains that better traits can be given out more plentifully using overproduction, where the bad traits will die out, and the strong ones will live.
Explains adaptive radiation, which is the rapid evolution of many diverse species from ancestral species. punctuated equilibrium causes this, followed by long periods of speciation.
Opines that evolution is a broad subject that is controversial and causes many problems in the scientific community.
In 1986, Richard Dawkins, an eminent ethologist and evolutionary biologist, published a three-hundred-plus page refutation of William Paley’s watchmaker analogy. The writing itself is thorough, elegant, and forceful. Dawkins possesses what is possibly the most blunt yet poetic scientific writing style that exists, sometimes even quoting pieces of poetry and literature in his writings. While previous works such as The Selfish Gene and The Ancestor’s Tale were scientific masterpieces unto themselves, the insights contained in The Blind Watchmaker are among some of the most important and impressive ever offered by a human being.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how richard dawkins, an ethologist and evolutionary biologist, published a three-hundred-plus page refutation of william paley’s watchmaker analogy. the writing itself is thorough, elegant, and forceful.
Analyzes paley's watchmaker analogy, stating that life is more complex than a watch. the crux of his argument was the eye, which he compares to the man-made telescope.
Analyzes how dawkins' refutation of paley's watchmaker begins proper in chapter 2, "good design," by elucidating what constitutes good design.
Analyzes how richard dawkins, an ethologist and evolutionary biologist, published a three-hundred-plus page refutation of william paley’s watchmaker analogy. the writing itself is thorough, elegant, and forceful.
Analyzes paley's watchmaker analogy, stating that life is more complex than a watch. the crux of his argument was the eye, which he compares to the man-made telescope.
Analyzes how dawkins' refutation of paley's watchmaker begins proper in chapter 2, "good design," by elucidating what constitutes good design.
Analyzes how dawkins describes the evolution of the eye, which isn't an example of "good design" — it's the result of a natural process, utilizing what materials it had available.
Analyzes how cumulative selection can potentially, over very few generations, make seemingly complex changes to an organism.
Analyzes how dawkins' second program, called biomorphs, uses a similar methodology to the first. the computer draws small, stick-figure creatures on the screen and breeds them.
Analyzes how dawkins demonstrates that there is an edge and looking 6% like one is even better. in chapter 6, he tackles the origin of life.
Analyzes how dawkins' "doomed rivals" debunks the creationist claim that evolution can only destroy information in genes, not create it.
Opines that the book's inclusion of chapter 9, "puncting punctuationism", was an interesting read, but felt out of place in this book.
Opines that dawkins has demonstrated that nature needs a process of cumulative selection working on randomly mutating, self-replicating creatures in order to create the variety and abundance of life on our planet.
Since the publication of Charles Darwin’s Origin of Species, in which the theory of evolution has risen, people have debated the merits of the theories of creationism and evolution. The theory of is reinforced through scientific studies using DNA, genetics and its mutation, the fossil record and the change in earlier species that has been encountered, and the distribution of related species of animals over a broad geographical range.
In this essay, the author
Explains dna gene mutations & evolution: genetic mistakes, natural selection and biological change.
Explains that king, robert c., pamela k. mulligan, and william d. stansfield. a dictionary of genetics.
Explains that fossils are mineralized remnants or impressions of once-living organisms that have been encased in rocks.
Explains dna gene mutations & evolution: genetic mistakes, natural selection and biological change.
Explains that king, robert c., pamela k. mulligan, and william d. stansfield. a dictionary of genetics.
Explains that fossils are mineralized remnants or impressions of once-living organisms that have been encased in rocks.
Explains actionbioscience's "evolution: fact and theory" promoting bioscience literacy. john pojeta and dale a. springer.
Gould and Lewontin present an argument criticizing the way evolutionary science solely relies on adaptations in the current environment. Their argument, known as pluralism, asserts that evolutionary biology continues on the path adaptationism without ever exploring other methods. Gould and Lewontin propose several alternative approaches, the fourth of which states that an identical trade into different organisms of the same species can be led to in different ways that have the same result. They assert that organisms that do this are a product of selection even though they used one method instead of another does not enhance the fitness of the organism. To demonstrate this, suppose there are two foxes. The first is able to dig the burrow using its front paws and snout while the second uses its hind legs followed by the front paws. In this scenario both of these foxes dig equally sufficient burrows at the same speed and both are able to remain and live comfortably inside of them. The foxes come to the same result by utilizing different meth...
In this essay, the author
Analyzes gould and lewontin's argument that evolutionary biology continues on the path adaptationism without ever exploring other methods. they assert that organisms that do this are a product of selection even though they used one method instead of another.
Explains that natural selection is a catalyst in the development of many different traits.
Argues that a pluralist perspective would respond by acknowledging the potential for an organism to develop two separate ways of doing the same things through selection; however, once the population becomes equally dominated by both of the traits, all further selection would be random.
Analyzes gould and lewontin's argument that evolutionary biology continues on the path adaptationism without ever exploring other methods. they assert that organisms that do this are a product of selection even though they used one method instead of another.
Explains that natural selection is a catalyst in the development of many different traits.
Argues that a pluralist perspective would respond by acknowledging the potential for an organism to develop two separate ways of doing the same things through selection; however, once the population becomes equally dominated by both of the traits, all further selection would be random.
Werner, Dr. Carl. Evolution: The Grand Experiment Vol. 1. Green Forest: New Leaf Publishing. Print
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how evolution argues that life on earth began more than 3.5 billion years ago as a single species, and the early organisms tolerated quick genetic alterations.
Argues that darwin's theory of evolution has been disproved due to an implausible claim of spontaneous generation, gaps in the fossil record, and contradicting scientific discoveries.
Argues that mounting scientific evidence undermines evolution's defenses. evolution claims that embryos and vestigial organs are similar among all organisms, but vertebrate embryo patterns are very different.
Analyzes how evolution argues that life on earth began more than 3.5 billion years ago as a single species, and the early organisms tolerated quick genetic alterations.
Argues that darwin's theory of evolution has been disproved due to an implausible claim of spontaneous generation, gaps in the fossil record, and contradicting scientific discoveries.
Argues that mounting scientific evidence undermines evolution's defenses. evolution claims that embryos and vestigial organs are similar among all organisms, but vertebrate embryo patterns are very different.
Cites driscoll, mark, and brashears' "chapter 3: god makes" doctrine: what christians should believe wheaton: crossway, 2010.
"The discovery of the structure by Crick and Watson, with all its biological implications, has been one of the major scientific events of this century." (Bragg, The Double Helix, p1) In the story of The Double Helix, James Watson tells of the road that led to the discovery of life's basic building block-DNA. This autobiography gives insight into science and the workings within a professional research laboratory that few members of society will ever be able to experience. It also gives the reader an idea of the reality of life for one scientist and how he struggled with the problem of DNA. However, the author's style is marked by his lack of objectivity and inclusion of many biased opinions and personal prejudices.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how james watson's autobiography gives insight into science and the workings within a professional research laboratory that few members of society will ever experience.
Analyzes how watson's choice of words, such as feminine qualities, mild interest, strong features, and imagination of english blue-stocking adolescents demonstrates how the passage is not objective.
Analyzes how watson's subjective style shows that he has failed to show more objective information and thought, and therefore his creditability is brought down.
Analyzes how james watson's autobiography gives insight into science and the workings within a professional research laboratory that few members of society will ever experience.
Analyzes how watson's choice of words, such as feminine qualities, mild interest, strong features, and imagination of english blue-stocking adolescents demonstrates how the passage is not objective.
Analyzes how watson's subjective style shows that he has failed to show more objective information and thought, and therefore his creditability is brought down.
Analyzes how watson's subjective style is visible through his word choice. he portrays rosy as a misguided feminist.