The Themes Of Cultural Identity In Scar By Amy Tan

901 Words2 Pages

We often see connections from the story to our own lives. Personally I feel like “Scar” by Amy Tan does this. Like Ralston Bowles once said “ Don’t let your struggles become your identity.” This story touches on the topics of cultural identity, forgiveness and relationship. An-me struggles are forgiveness and relationship while she’s also trying to find herself. In the story, we see Popo (the grandmother) has taken care of An-mei and her younger sibling. They seem to be a really close family, sadly An-mei father passed away and her mother fled to the north. Years go on by and we see the mother have came back to take An-mei with her, but the grandmother rejected. As the narrator says “this dark boiling soup spilled forward and spilled”. …show more content…

In order for Popo to survive, the mother has done a physical sacrifice. “My mother took her flesh and put it in the soup. She cooked magic in the ancient tradition to try to cure her mother this one last time.” (Tan 295) We see two different cultures colliding here in the western civilization, eating your own skin is seen as taboo, It’s also known to be form of torture. In the eastern civilization is a way to cure the illness that Popo has. Also, We see how the mother “had married a man with a wife, two concubines, and other bad children.” We see polygamy which is seen as a taboo, we see reports on how it can be so evil. For example, we hear how the Mormons polygamy is all based on family and children end up being confused once everything is brought out to the light. As many other children in the world now, they are confused on who they are and what’s the new norm, with these two examples we see how anyone even a child can be cultural confusion because we all do. We can see a connection to this with the world in the fact of having religion being a big part on identity. I remember meeting a girl, she would go to church five days a week, had long hair and wore long skirts everyday until she arrived to seventh grade. I remember students asking her why do you wear that, why do you pray before every meal. She would always respond to well my father told me to do it, she didn’t have no real idea why. Then she started to ask herself well …show more content…

An-mei seems to have a problem to forgive her mother after all since she left her children because they were disobedient children. Popo has a problem forgetting her daughter (An-mei’s mother) because she left her family to marry somebody else. A way we see that An-mei’s mother tries to ask for forgiveness is to do a ritual. An-mei’s mother had to cut a piece off her skin and eat it to cure her Popo. An-mei didn’t have to forgive her because she saw her mother in her and “put herself in her footsteps.” I can relate to this section because I have started to see the text to my world. I took my father nine years to realize that he was doing wrong, just like An-mei I saw fear in his eyes of being alone and not having his only daughter there with him. I feel like forgiveness and having petty towards somebody

Open Document