The Rich Diversity of Meanings of the Pardoner's Tale
Chaucer’s innovation in the Pardoner’s performance tests our concept of dramatic irony by suggesting information regarding the Pardoner’s sexuality, gender identity, and spirituality, major categories in the politics of identity, without confirming that information. Our presumed understanding of the Pardoner as a character lacks substantiation. As we learn about the Pardoner through the narrator’s eyes and ears, we look to fit the "noble ecclesiaste" (l. 708) into the figure shaped by our own prejudices and perceptions, as any active reader must do. But the Pardoner, ever aware of his audience, does not offer clear clues to his personality. This break between what the other characters say about the Pardoner and what the Pardoner says about himself has been a major source of tension for all readers of the Tales and especially critics who search for substantiation of their views beyond the Chaucer’s own language. The general tone of the Canterbury Tales is comic. After all, the pilgrims are traveling to the shrine St. Thomas Beckett in a public act of holy reverence, but the Tales take a darker turn when the Pardoner is brought to the foreground. The whole Canterbury Tales is a collected set of performances, stories told about telling stories. As Joseph Ganim has written, theatricality, by which he means "a governing sense of performance, an interplay among the author’s voice, his fictional characters, and his immediate audience," is "a paradigm for the Chaucerian poetic" (5). This paper shall endeavor to show that the major effect of the Pardoner’s presence in the Tales is to focus the reader’s attention to questions of performance and performativity, literary perception, ...
... middle of paper ...
...University of California Press, 1988.
Lochrie, Karma; McCracken, Peggy; Schultz, James A. Editors. Constructing Medieval Sexuality. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press, 1997.
McAlpine, Monica E. “The Pardoner’s Homosexuality and How It Matters.” Geoffrey Chaucer’s The General Prologue to the Canterbury Tales. Ed. by Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea House Publishers, 1988. pp. 103-124.
Nevo, Ruth. “Chaucer: Motive and Mask in the General Prologue.” Geoffrey Chaucer’s The General Prologue to the Canterbury Tales. Ed. by Harold Bloom. New York: Chelsea House Publishers, 1988. pp. 9-20.
Ross, Thomas W. Chaucer’s Bawdy. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., 1972.
Sedgewick, G. G. “The Progress of Chaucer’s Pardoner, 1880-1940.” Chaucer: Modern Essays in Criticism. Ed. by Edward Wagnknecht. New York: Oxford University Press, 1959. pp. 126-158.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how chaucer's innovation in the pardoner’s performance tests our concept of dramatic irony by suggesting information regarding his sexuality, gender identity, and spirituality.
Analyzes how the general prologue offers a first impression of the pardoner, which has affected his interpreted characterization to this day.
Analyzes the narrator's use of animal imagery in his portrait of the pardoner.
Argues that critics have accepted their comments as indicative of the pardoner's sexual deviance, either physical or social. the phrase "beel amy" of line 318 is regularly regarded as a homophobic jibe.
Argues that the text conveys some sense of sexual abnormality about the pardoner.
Argues that effeminacy connotes rambunctious heterosexuality in men, an excessive interest in and desire for women in medieval times.
Analyzes how chaucer's pardoner joins a list of fictional persons throughout western literature, whose vivacity and power lie in the tense relation of sexuality and morality that forms their characters.
Analyzes carolyn dinshaw's interpretation of the pardoner’s fashion consciousness as a critical trope for his deceptive appearance.
Analyzes how chaucer makes clear the nature of the pardoner's tale as a performance, not only as one of fifty-eight tales the pilgrims will tell on their journey to and from canterbury.
Analyzes how critics like harold bloom locate chaucer's strength as a poet in his vivid creation of character who create themselves through language.
Analyzes the dispute between linguistically-oriented interpretations of the characters as rhetorical effects of chaucer’s conscious manipulation of language and psychologically-oriened studies that treat the pilgrims as dramatic characters.
Argues that the pardoner's prologue and tale are melodramatic lamentations that icing the simple, yet effective story of the three rioters.
Analyzes how the pardoner's presentation lacks the substance necessary to achieve his desired results, so he turns to the delivery of the presentation itself.
Analyzes how the pardoner concludes the tale with the much-cited claim "i wol yow nat deceyve" (918), a deliberately ambiguous statement that perfectly fits his character and performance.
Analyzes how the pardoner's sermon and exemplum is manipulating the sermon tradition to cheat the "lewed" audience out of their money.
Analyzes how the tale is a vehicle for the pardoner's self-revelation and the evasion of identity through performance.
Analyzes how the pardoner makes his living by his ability to perform. he is a professional magician of words who suffers muted outrage when the truth of his conjuring is discovered.
Analyzes how the pardoner concludes the tale with the much-cited claim "i wol yow nat deceyve" (918), a deliberately ambiguous statement that perfectly fits his character and performance.
Analyzes how chaucer blesses the pardoner with a distinct performative style and technique. his abject, spectacular life offer the raw material for the emotional force of his tale.
Analyzes how the pardoner is a practical rhetorician, mastering diverse ways of persuading an audience to act as he wishes.
Analyzes how the pardoner adapts his presentation with each re-reading to the benefit of his audience.
Analyzes how the pardoner, his prologue, and his tale are evocative emotionally, spiritually, morally and aesthetically. chaucer's fictive power is his powerful hold over our imaginations as readers.
Explains benson, c. david, chaucer's drama of style: poetic variety and contrast in the canterbury tales.
Introduces harold bloom to geoffrey chaucer's the general prologue to the canterbury tales.
Describes bronson, bertrand h., "the pardoner's confession." twentieth century interpretations of the pargiver’s tale.
Introduces dewey r. faulkner in twentieth century interpretations of the pardoner’s tale: a collection of critical essays.
Explains that ginsberg, warren, and harold bloom have written geoffrey chaucer's the general prologue to the canterbury tales.
Explains green, richard firth, and lisa j. kiser's "the pardoner’s pants (and why they matter)."
Describes harrington, david v., "narrative speed in the pardoner's tale." twentieth century interpretations.
Explains that huppé, bernard f. a reading of the canterbury tales. albany: state university of new york, 1967.
Explains jordan, chaucer's poetics and the modern reader, berkeley: university of california press, 1987.
Explains koff, leonard michael. chaucer and the art of storytelling. berkeley: university of california press, 1988.
Describes lochrie, mccracken, and schultz, in constructing medieval sexuality.
Explains mcalpine, monica e., and bloom's the general prologue to the canterbury tales.
Describes geoffrey chaucer's the general prologue to the canterbury tales.
Explains sedgewick, g. g, and wagnknecht's chaucer: modern essays in criticism.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales: Riverside Chaucer Third Edition. Ed. Larry D. Benson. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company,1987. 3-328 Secondary
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how chaucer sets the mood by providing an overall idea of the type of character who is telling the tale, then allows that character to introduce themselves through a personal prologue and finally, the pilgrim tells their tale.
Analyzes how the miller's physical descriptions were believed to denote a shameless, talkative, lecherous, and quarrelsome character. his personality is also depicted as being very loud and disturbing.
Analyzes how the narrator urges the reader to find another tale to read before they are offended and waste their time listening to the miller.
Analyzes how the color of her stockings, in particular, is significant, since, like the miller, her face is also described as "reed of hewe"
Analyzes how the wife of bath loses control of her fifth husband, jankyn, and uses it to manipulate him into giving her back her property.
Analyzes how the altercation ends the difficulties that the wife of bath was having getting along with her husband.
Analyzes how the merchant, like the miller, is described as a devilish man with "forked berd" in "the general prologue." he is distinguished by his views on marriage, which compliment his business sense.
Compares "the merchants tale" to "wife of bath" because the main character, januarie, is blind to many aspects of what the merchant feels are problems with women.
Analyzes how chaucer describes the miller as having a "thombe of gold" in "the general prologue." the miller's appearance after the more solemn knight creates contrast in mood.
Analyzes how the color red in the miller's face and hair can be interpreted in two different ways. it creates a comical mood around him that is carried by the reader into his tale.
Analyzes how chaucer's advice to turn away from the story is enticing the reader and piquing their curiosity about the tale that the miller is eager to share.
Analyzes how beidler asserts that the word large can be interpreted as an adverb rather than an adjective.
Analyzes how the wife of bath has adapted herself to the role of a wife and uses her feminine powers to gain an advantage over him. the knight shows little respect for women in the beginning of the story.
Analyzes how the merchant, like the wife of bath, uses his tale and prologue to offer his opinion of love and marriage.
Analyzes how chaucer uses the pilgrims as instruments to illustrate a network of interlocking stories within the larger work.
Describes chaucer's canterbury tales, including his 'foot-mantel', and irma taavitsainen.
Mandell, Jerome. Geoffrey Chaucer : building the fragments of the Canterbury tales. N.J. : Fairleigh Dickinson University Press, 1992.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how the language of this passage is strikingly similar to the hag’s confirmation of her knight's concession and their resultant bliss
Analyzes how eisner discounts motifs (c, d, and e), discards (f) and acknowledges only a cursory resemblance in motif (h).
Analyzes how eisner's "new" motifs can be attributed to the theme of the hunt, which he prematurely dismisses.
Analyzes the specific nature of the choice, addressing eisner's motif (g), is unique in alice’s story as well.
Analyzes how the choice of pride vs. passion presupposes the dominion of the lover/husband. the choice the hag poses is a much more powerful, complex dilemma.
Analyzes how the inexorable relationship between the hag and the knight is central to the tale.
Analyzes how magic is "intrinsic" to the hag's role. alice regrets the loss of magic in the world and casts aspersion on the church’s inauthentic, arbitrary dogma and ritual.
Opines that the wife doesn't respect the church, as we are told in the narrator's profile.
Analyzes how the wife of bath concludes her tale with a powerful prayer, reiterating her ethical lessons.
Analyzes how alice illustrates the theme of overpowering, or failing to yield to women, in her prologue recounting her history with her fifth husband, and in a strongly didactic tale that parallels her own.
Describes chaucer, geoffrey, "the wife of bath's prologue and tale." from the riverside, third edition, ed. larry d. benson.
Analyzes how chaucer's canterbury tales assembles pilgrims who engage in a story-telling contest along their route. the pitting of tales one against another reveals the interpersonal dynamics of the societal microcosm.
Analyzes how the hag corrects the knight's errant perception that gentility is his birthright in the telling of the wife of bath.
Analyzes the use of the term ‘maistrie’, or ‘dominion’ in both accounts, and the concession to ‘chese and governe as me lest’.
Analyzes how sovereignty, or dominion, is central to the wife of bath's tale as it explores the question of "maistree."
Analyzes how alice and chaucer value religious truth only to the point that it is justified through practical, rational analysis. alice's tale is carefully carved from the source material to serve her didactic purpose.
Explains eisner, sigmund, and mandell, jerome. geoffrey chaucer : building the fragments of the canterbury tales.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. “The Canterbury Tales.” The Norton Anthology of English Literature: 6th edition New York: Norton. 1996
In this essay, the author
Argues that people have been fascinated by ideals of heroism, chivalry, and what we now refer to as romance for a very long time.
Opines that modern police officers, soldiers, paramedics, fbi/cia agents, and any who take on with their livelihood the motto "to protect and to serve."
Analyzes how the idea of glory and honor is summed up in "beowulf" by the line "heaven swallowed the smoke" (l. 3155).
Compares "beowulf" to a book by david laven called napoleon's legacy: problems of government in restoration europe.
Analyzes how grendel's mother remains unnamed in the text of beowulf.
Concludes that women's conquest for their rights can relate to one of their favorite things in the world known to us as literature.
Analyzes the symbolism of the pentangle versus the green girdle. the shield represents chivalry in its impossible idiom.
Analyzes how the green girdle, the kings and gawain's conversation, shows that even though we are not perfect, we can always learn from our mistakes and improve upon our weaknesses once realized and admitted.
Explains the norton anthology of english literature: 7th edition.
Explains chaucer's "the canterbury tales." the norton anthology of english literature: 6th edition.
In “The Pardoner’s Tale,” Geoffrey Chaucer masterfully frames an informal homily. Through the use of verbal and situational irony, Chaucer is able to accentuate the moral characteristics of the Pardoner. The essence of the story is exemplified by the blatant discrepancy between the character of the storyteller and the message of his story. By analyzing this contrast, the reader can place himself in the mind of the Pardoner in order to account for his psychology.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes chaucer's use of verbal and situational irony to accentuate the moral characteristics of the pardoner.
Analyzes how the pardoner's sermons revolve around the biblical idea that the love of money is the root of all evil.
Analyzes how chaucer clouds the genuine nature of the pardoner's psychology in ambiguity.
Analyzes how the pardoner's psychology is directed by immoral habits. he envelops his sermon on avarice around a subliminal message urging his audience to purchase his indulgences.
Analyzes how the pardoner's psychology is defined by his unyielding love of money. his impurity isn't a result of his sins, but his reluctance to change his ways.
Analyzes how the pardoner's mind is replete with subtle, contradictory nuances. he is highly effective in what he does.
Chaucer first begins his sly jab at the Church’s motives through the description of the Pardoner’s physical appearance and attitude in his “Canterbury Tales.” Chaucer uses the Pardoner as a representation of the Church as a whole, and by describing the Pardoner and his defects, is able to show what he thinks of the Roman Catholic Church. All people present in the “Canterbury Tales” must tell a tale as a part of story-telling contest, and the pilgrim Chaucer, the character in the story Chaucer uses to portray himself, writes down the tales as they are told, as well as the story teller. The description of the Pardoner hints at the relationship and similarity between the Pardoner and the Church as a whole, as well as marks the beginning of the irony to be observed throughout the “Pardoner’s Prologue and Tale.” The narrator describes the Pardoner as an extremely over confident, arrogant, and unattractive man, noting that his hair is “as yellow as wex,” lying thin and fl...
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how chaucer explores the idea of hypocrisy in his "pardoner's prologue and tale" and the introduction to the tale.
Analyzes how chaucer uses the pardoner as a representation of the roman catholic church in his "canterbury tales."
Analyzes how the pardoner's appearance and attitude introduce the idea that he and his overall character are full of ironic discrepancies.
Analyzes how chaucer points out that pardoner is not a strange case, or someone who is fraud at his job, as he has all the appropriate paperwork and is clearly supported by the church.
Analyzes how chaucer criticizes the church through the irony between what the pardoner says is right and how he actually acts and speaks.
Analyzes chaucer's belief that the pardoner represents the church as a whole by being one of their spokesmen.
Analyzes chaucer's portrayal of the pardoner as a self-absorbed, greedy man that mirrors what thinks about the church.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. "The Canterbury Tales Study Guide : Summary and Analysis of The Pardoner's Tale | GradeSaver." Study Guides & Essay Editing | GradeSaver. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 May 2011. .
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how the pardoner in the pardoners tale is hypocritical, his scare tactics prove this. he says that greed over things like money is evil, and his audience should give him large amounts of money.
Analyzes how the pardoner tries to use his story to get the audience to give him money for their greedy sins.
Analyzes how the pardoner is acutely greedy. he wants people with not much money to pay him with silver.
Narrates chaucer's canterbury tales study guide : summary and analysis of the pardoner’s tale.
Skeat, Walter W., ed. Complete Works of Geoffrey Chaucer. 2nd ed. 6 vols. Oxford: Clarendon, 1899; rpt. 1972.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how chaucer had audience awareness as a reporter of the human condition. he could expect married men, and bukton, to share the great joke of matrimony, gender-based and misogynistic.
Describes chaucer, geoffrey, and larry d. benson's the riverside chauce.
Explains that skeat, walter w., ed. complete works of geoffrey chaucer. oxford: clarendon, 1899.
Analyzes how the wife of bath's personality, philosophy of sexuality, and attitude toward sovereignty in marriage are offered as comedy.
Explains that chaucer's persona is not silent on the subject in this vein. he quotes, with an innuendo most scholars since skeat have taken as domestic, "awak,' to me he sayde,/ ryght in the same vois and stevene" (ii.56062).
Opines that chaucer's envoy is merely advising the shrews to fight back, not just against their persecutors, as did the wife of bath, but against clerks who write bad stories about women.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. "The Pardoner's Tale." Chaucer's Works. Ed. Walter W. Skeat. Vol. 4. London: U of Oxford, 2007. N. pag. Web. 24 Apr. 2014
In this essay, the author
Explains that in literature, evil can take many different forms, including physical, inner, and a combination of the two.
Analyzes how the anglo-saxon heroic story, beowulf, is influenced by physical evil, which takes the form of many things from the grim reaper to monsters.
Analyzes the inner evil within the characters in chaucer's pardoner’s tale from the canterbury tales.
Analyzes how macbeth's internal and physical evils are equally important and directly lead to death.
Opines that no matter what type of evil these stories contain, it is still influential in the plot of the story.
Opines that chaucer, geoffrey, "the pardoner's tale" is a work of walter w. skeat.
Describes the shmoop editorial team's macbeth themes.
Chaucer used controversies to create character. He wanted his characters to teach the readers something new about life. The Wife of Bath and the Pardoner demonstrate Chaucer’s way of creating characters based on the sexuality of the medieval period.
In this essay, the author
Analyzes how the nominalistic pilgrim sees these lines as representing a new birth, baptism and cleansing, and the breath of zephyrus as an allusion to the biblical story of adam and eve.
Analyzes how chaucer uses the wife of bath and the meek pardoner to examine sexuality in the medieval period.
Analyzes how the wife of bath is a confident, experienced woman who is liberal about education and sexual matters.
Explains that life in the middle ages: appearance vs. reality is available at st. john’s college high school.