The Pros And Cons Of NAFTA

652 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Relation between The United States and Mexico

In 1992, Ross Perot declared during the 1992 presidential campaign that if implemented, NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) would create a “giant sucking sound” of jobs going south to cheaper labor markets of Mexico. Granted, Perot heard the sound, however, he missed the market. In June 2007, Candidate Obama conceded the failings in NAFTA subsequently as President; he endeavors using the invisible hand of geopolitics by drawing Japan closer through the Transpacific Partnership Agreement (TPP). In the process, he isolates the true “sound” of China’ comparative advantage by upgrading existing standards (NAFTA) and setting new high standards (TPP) that includes forty percent of the global economy. However, Thomas Sowell in Applied Economics: …show more content…

Schott, experts at the Peterson Institute for International Economics and the authors of NAFTA Revisited disclosed, “NAFTA was designed to promote economic growth by spurring competition in domestic markets and promoting investment from both domestic and foreign sources." Consequently, with foreign investors growing progressively agitated with the freedom of competition inside China, regardless, the invisible hand effect of NAFTA has US workers’ wages at a pace below labor productivity. Mohammed Aly Sergie writing for the CFR in NAFTA's Economic Impact discloses Alden alternately proclaiming, “Income inequality in the United States has risen in recent years, in part due to pressures on the U.S. manufacturing base.” Will the TPP level the playing field for American workers and American businesses towards a comparative advantage? History indicates to listen for the sucking sound for marginal benefit

Show More
Related

  • Understanding International Trade: Costs, Benefits, and Agreements

    715 Words  | 2 Pages

    Trade is the most common form of transferring ownership of a product. The concepts are very simple, I give you something (a good or service) and you give me something (a good or service) in return, everyone is happy. However, trade is not limited to two individuals. There are trades that happen outside national borders and we refer to that as international trading. Before a country does international trading, they do research to understand the opportunity costs and marginal costs of their production versus another countries production. Doing this we can increase profit, decrease costs and improve overall trade efficiency. Currently, there are negotiations going on between 11 countries about making a trade agreement called the Trans-Pacific

    Read More

  • U.S-Mexico Borderlands

    1084 Words  | 3 Pages

    After three years of debate NAFTA was established in 1994. Fears concerning NAFTA included job creation, loss and transfer, wages and infrastructure. (Ganster/Lorey 188-189) However, with the implementation of NAFTA the economy grew. Ganster and Lorey reveal that bilateral trade increased by $211.4 per year from 1989 to 2004. Commerce grew by 20 percent in the first six months of 1994. There were advantages and disadvantages of NAFTA, nevertheless, NAFTA “intensified the integration of the two economies rather than distancing them.” (Ganster/Lorey 190)

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of NAFTA

    1027 Words  | 3 Pages

    On January 1st, 1994, a treaty that created the largest free trade area were signed into place by the trilateral of United States, Canada, and Mexico. NAFTA is a promise made by world’s most significant corporations claiming to create many high paying jobs and raise the standard of living in the US, Canada and Mexico. As we approach its 21st birthday, NAFTA now links 450 million people producing trillion dollars’ worth of goods and services each year. However, behind this seemingly good deal, it also created many underlying issues. Beginning with NAFTA giving corporation opportunities to move factories aboard to the lower-cost Mexico. Manufacturing aboard did not only outsourced American jobs, it also caused manufacturers that remained to lower

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of The New Deal

    636 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the early 1920s, Florida was flourishing economically. Land sales were reaching planetary heights, tourism was booming, and new residents were coming in every day. By September 1926, the population of Dade County and the new City of Miami had blossomed to more than 100,000 and construction was all over. Although Florida was prosperous that was only on the surface, behind the scenes there existed a widespread of poverty. And things got even worst when the 1926 hurricane hit Florida. The hurricane was described by the U.S. Weather Bureau in Miami as "probably the most destructive hurricane ever to strike the United States." Severe flooding and wind damage weakened communities. Lake Okeechobee flooded and drown over 2,000 people in nearby communities. Many buildings that were a work in progress were damaged and discontinued, tourism was at an all-time low, and also many citizens lost their homes. And The Great Depression didn’t make things any easier. Florida was in trouble and in need of help.

    Read More

  • NAFTA: The North American Free Trade Agreement

    1078 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout history, the United States has initiated policies, peace agreements, or laws which were believed to bring prosperity, and success, however those policies as a result were created in the U.S. best self-interest. One of these policies is known as NAFTA, which was a trade agreement created to open up free trade around the globe, however this policy backfired, deeply scaring and deteriorating the Latin American economy, and its people. Specifically, NAFTA known as the North American Free Trade Agreement, took effect on January 1, 1994 was a treaty which entered by the United States, Canada, and Mexico used to eliminate tariff barriers, in order to encourage economic prosperity between these three countries. A quarter century later, the

    Read More

  • The Failure of the North American Free Trade Agreement

    1348 Words  | 3 Pages

    NAFTA's promoters promised 200,000 new jobs per year for the U.S., higher wages in Mexico and a growing U.S. trade surplus with Mexico, environmental clean-up and improved health along the border. The reality of the post-NAFTA surge in imports from Mexico has resulted in an $14.7 billion trade deficit with Mexico for 1998. By adding the Mexican trade deficit to the deficit with Canada, the overall U.S. NAFTA trade deficit for the year 1998 is $33.2 billion dollars. In the last five years we have gone from a pre-NAFTA trade surplus of $4.6 billion with Mexico to a $14.7 billion deficit. Using the Department of Commerce trade data in the formula used by NAFTA proponents to predict job gains, the real accumulated NAFTA trade deficit would translate into over four hundred thousand U.S. jobs lost.

    Read More

  • United States Trade Policy: Current and Future Role in a Global Economy

    2527 Words  | 6 Pages

    The United States has for over two centuries been involved in the growing world economy. While the U.S. post revolutionary war sought to protect itself from outside influences has since the great depression and world war two looked to break trade restrictions. The United States role in the global economy has grown throughout the 20th century and as a result of several historical events has adopted positions of both benefactor and dependent. The United States trade policy has over time shifted from isolationist protectionism to a commitment to establishing world-wide free trade. Free trade enterprise has developed and grown through organizations such as the WTO and NAFTA. The U.S. in order to obtain its free trade desires has implemented a number of policies that can be examined for both their benefits and flaws. Several trade policies exist as options to the United States, among these fair trade and free trade policies dominate the world economic market. In order to achieve economic growth the United States has a duty to maintain a global trade policy that benefits both domestic workers and industry. While free trade gives opportunities to large industries and wealthy corporate investors the American worker suffers job instability and lower wages. However fair trade policies that protect America’s workers do not help foster wide economic growth. The United States must then engage in economic trade policies that both protect the United States founding principles and secure for tomorrow greater economic stability.

    Read More

  • NAFTA

    801 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1994, the most controversial alliance between nations took its affect. NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) was the agreement to have free trade between Canada, United States and Mexico. According to the Institute for International Economics one million workers in 1995 would owe their jobs to U.S. exports to Mexico. Some 175,000 of those would be new jobs in higher paying sectors (Mohn 2007). Although it was suppose to drastically increase trade and create jobs, in many ways had the reverse affect. The environment took a backseat to the corporate greed. With the increase of trade, the pollution increased and the quality of goods decreased significantly. Our country lost more jobs than it gained. We have become increasingly dependent on other countries. The United States has sat by silently as the pollution from unregulated foreign low-wage manufacturing plants infiltrates our earth's rivers, air, and ground water. Our government has turned their heads on workers in other countries as well as our own, being exploited and forced to work in conditions not fit for and animal. NAFTA may have increased trade but at what cost? It looks like even the United States can be bought. The U. S. Government no longer controls our country, big business does.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Free Trade Agreements

    766 Words  | 2 Pages

    Imagine walking into a shopping centre, and going into a store like JB-HiFi who, specialises in electronics. You’re looking for a tablet that is simple yet does the job. You find many that do the job, all from different countries. The styles are the same but, the prices are different from varying of different country. Why is there so many? As well as why are the prices different of different countries.

    Read More

  • US-Japan Relations

    1147 Words  | 3 Pages

    With Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda’s announcement at the APEC summit held in Hawaii this past weekend that Japan will enter into Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) negotiations, the economics aspects of the alliance appear to be progressing in light of the changing strategic environment. It has been no secret that the U.S. has been pushing hard for Japan to enter into TPP talks and President Barack Obama praised Prime Minister Noda’s decision in face of strong opposition within his own party and the politically strong agricultural sector as one that, “could provide an historic opportunity to deepen bilateral economic ties” (Lindsay, 2011).

    Read More

  • Globalization: The European Union, the ASEAN Group, and NAFTA

    3413 Words  | 7 Pages

    Globalization has become one of the most influential forces in the twentieth century. International integration of world views, products, trade and ideas has caused a variety of states to blur the lines of their borders and be open to an international perspective. The merger of the Europeans Union, the ASEAN group in the Pacific and NAFTA in North America is reflective of the notion of globalized trade. The North American Free Trade Agreement was the largest free trade zone in the world at its conception and set an example for the future of liberalized trade. The North American Free Trade Agreement is coming into it's twentieth anniversary on January 1st, 2014. 1 NAFTA not only sought to enhance the trade of goods and services across the borders of Canada, US and Mexico but it fostered shared interest in investment, transportation, communication, border relations, as well as environmental and labour issues. The North American Free Trade Agreement was groundbreaking because it included Mexico in the arrangement.2 Mexico was a much poorer, culturally different and protective country in comparison to the likes of Canada and the United States. Many members of the U.S Congress were against the agreement because they did not want to enter into an agreement with a country that had an authoritarian regime, human rights violations and a flawed electoral system.3 Both Canadians and Americans alike, feared that Mexico's lower wages and lax human rights laws would generate massive job losses in their respected economies. Issues of sovereignty came into play throughout discussions of the North American Free Trade Agreement in Canada. Many found issue with the fact that bureaucrats and politicians from alien countries would be making deci...

    Read More

  • Advantages And Disadvantages Of Nafta In Canada

    534 Words  | 2 Pages

    With trading through U.S and Mexico, Canada has been greatly growing the economy. Companies in Canada can import products which are cheaper and more reasonable to sell to Canadian consumers, so that they are able to make more money than they manufacture the products themselves. Moreover, NAFTA has created jobs. When people think about NAFTA has created a lot of jobs in variety industries, they always think that only people who are living in the country will get benefits of that. Nevertheless, it is not. Also, companies have a benefits of creating jobs by NAFTA because creating jobs means that a company has more opportunities to manufacture products by increased employees and

    Read More

  • Service based economy in the U.S.

    354 Words  | 1 Pages

    We say that we are heading toward a more global economy because of the fact that competition in today’s markets is global. This means that corporations in the United States can compete in foreign markets and vice versa, therefore U.S. corporations and foreign corporations become interdependent and thrive off each other. This can have a good impact on the United States because it allows U.S. corporations to seek materials and labor outside of the U.S. in countries such as China, India, and Mexico, where workers are paid a lot less money than U.S. workers, thus allowing them to sell their products for significantly cheaper than if they were produced in the U.S.; however, the tradeoff is that many American workers in the industrial sector lose jobs due to this shift of labor to overseas. In the long run this will be beneficial for the U.S. and although some percentage of workers are losing work, new jobs in the services sector, in fields such as computer technology, telecommunications, and language skills are opening up and experiencing growth because of this change.

    Read More

  • The Pros and Cons of Free Trade

    1130 Words  | 3 Pages

    Free Trade Agreements can create opportunities for Americans and help to grow the U.S. economy. According to the United States Trade Representative, “The United States is a Member of the World Trade Organization (WTO); the Marrakesh Agreement establishing the World Trade Organization (WTO Agreement) sets out rules governing trade among the WTO's 154 members.” To decrease poverty, developing economies need to grow faster, allowing the poor to benefit from this growth as well. Trade can play an important part in reducing poverty because it boosts economic growth consequently causing the poor to also benefit from that spurt in growth and development. According to Fergusson’s (2005) study, living standards in developing countries are not catching up with those in developed countries. They have made some progression yet are still lagging in comparison to developed countries and their living standards. What distinguishes developing countries versus countries that are poorer is their openness to Free Trade as stated in Ferg...

    Read More

  • China: Rising to Be the Next Superpower?

    975 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...side of any trade partner with China because of its desire for cheap labor which has cost America countless manufacturing jobs (Rendell) and thus, making China a worthy adversary to claim number one spot for the world’s best economy.

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of NAFTA

Open Document