The Problem of Non-Belief

1875 Words8 Pages
The Problem of Non-Belief Drange vs. McHugh- Scoring the Debate Drange’s Argument from Non-Belief The argument being put forth by Drange specifically attacks the God of Evangelical biblical Christianity, an important distinction for the argument itself. The Encyclopedia Britannica illuminates evangelicalism as a Christian protestant movement which emphasizes conversion and the foundational nature of the Bible as the only basis for faith, declaring the Bible as “inerrant.” (Brittanica, par.1) According to Drange’s argument, presuming that if God exists, there are numerous ways through which he could have brought change in some circumstances to ensure belief in his existence (Drange 418). For instance, one way would have been immediate implantation of the given values, outlined in set P, into individuals’ thoughts (Drange 418). More so, another suitable thing God could have done is to ensure the development of "belief genes" which are approved on from one creation to the next. In this sense, babies could possibly be born with the propensity to instantly ground their beliefs in the perception of set P as their thoughts grow. Drange illuminates another way for God to have gotten the concept across would have been by the efficiency of amazing wonders. For example, He could verbally communicated to individuals with thunderous speech from the sky, or used skywriting to announce set P to all the world to ensure belief (Drange 418) . Moreover, as in the time of Jesus, history could have unfolded in a different fashion. Instead of making his presence known only to his supporters, when resurrected from the dead, Jesus could have showed up to many and other individuals. Perhaps most distinctively Pontius Pilate, Emperor Ti... ... middle of paper ... ..., both that God cannot have inconsistent wants and that for God nothing is difficult, which seems to be a contradiction. But the more primary problem in the discussion is that it translates nothing is impossible for God in an unlimited way. However, how can we possibly ever know if or how the rules of rational logic apply to a ruler of the universe? Works Cited Drange, Theodore, “McHugh’s Expectations Dashed” from Philo, Vol.5(2):242-248 Drange, Theodore, “The Argument from Non-Belief” from Religious Studies, Vol.29(1993): 417-432 The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica. "Evangelicalism (religion)." Encyclopedia Britannica Online. Encyclopedia Britannica, Web. McHugh, Christopher, “A Refutation of Drange's Arguments From Evil and Nonbelief.” From Philo, Vol.5(1): 94-102.

More about The Problem of Non-Belief

Open Document