The Portable Phonograph Analysis

813 Words2 Pages

In only a matter of time, the surrounding environment is destroyed, natural sources become contaminated and useless, the temperature drops, and suddenly winter is paying a lingering visit. A nuclear winter. It is a definite possibility in today’s society, a thought that casts shivers down spines. It is the topic that is being addressed by Walter Van Tilburg Clark in his short story, “The Portable Phonograph”, and it is the possible occurrence that is being assessed by James Roberts in the article “How to Survive Nuclear Winter”. In the short story, a group of four men is forced to survive during a nuclear winter, and they have been for a certain period of time. So far, the men have found sources that they can live off of, however, the primary …show more content…

It has been said that in harsh environments, such as one forged from a nuclear war, the nuclear winter, you may only last three hours without a proper shelter. To add to the previous statement, it is a known fact that one can not survive longer than approximately three days without water, therefore making the resource a top priority. Luckily for the men in “The Portable Phonograph”, they had a “creek...already silent under ice. In the bank above it was dug a sort of cell” (Clark, 1941, p. 178). They used the cell as shelter from the extreme temperatures of the outdoors, and the creek a nearby source of water. However, even though they have shelter and water, the percentage of survival remains meager. The article suggests to “have emergency heating supplies on hand…[along with] appropriate clothing” (Roberts, 2007, p. 2). In an attempt to preserve “the precious remnants of wood, old fence posts and timbers from the long-deserted dugouts,” (Clark, 1941, p. 178), the men settled with petty warmth provided by blocks of peat. Not to mention, there would also be an extensive dilemma to find food, as the diversity of the environment would be so dominant that it could be close to impossible to grow a single seed in the earth. Considering what was previously addressed, the short story “The Portable Phonograph” has no true reference to what the men were feeding off of. The reason being, the short story is focused on a more concrete topic, creating entertainment in order to preserve a clear grasp on

Open Document