The Negative Impact of the CSI Franchise

1812 Words4 Pages
With a record of an average 119 television channels available to each household, television dominates American life (MediaBuyerPlanner). This wide assortment of television gives viewers many different realities to imitate, like a small child following and obeying its parent. One of the leading television shows in our society is the CSI franchise, with three different extensions. CSI, and shows similar to it, portray the criminal justice system in a negative light, which causes confusion between reality and fiction. Television is a means of entertainment, yet its influence on today’s generation is powerful and enchanting. Television shows centered on criminal justice are implausible portrayals of reality that create unrealistic expectations of evidence in the courtroom, as well as creating superfluous fear of murder for the viewers.

The procedures depicted of the criminal justice system on television are complex, inaccurate, and implausible portrayals of what actually occurs. These shows do not show the planning, timing, and effort that is put into the maintenance of a crime scene. Investigators show up, take some photographs, and continue to the lab for results in a matter of minutes (Forensic Science Degree). Television leaves out the uneventful procedures that are essential in a real crime scene. They also neglect to show how much time is spent on each case, which can take months or even years to finish. There are many techniques and procedures which seem to be forgotten or simplified in the shows. Crime scenes require a variety of people, including the skills of photographers, sketch artists, evidence recorders, and other team members. Intricate notes and sketches of the crime scene give all of the details requ...

... middle of paper ...

...12. Web. January 2014.

Roane, Kit R. “The CSI Effect.” U.S. News & World Report. 25 April 2005. Web. 15 January 2014.

Shelton, Hon. Donald E., Gregg Barak, and Kim S. Young. “A Study of Juror Expectations and

Demands Concerning Scientific Evidence: Does the ‘CSI Effect’ Exist?” Vanderbilt Journal of

Entertainment & Technology Law. 9.2 (2007): 331-368. pdf. 15 January 2014.

“The ‘CSI Effect’; Forensic Science.” The Economist. 24 April 2010: 77 (US). Student Resources In

Context. Web. 14 January 2014.

Thomas, Andrew P. “The CSI Effect: Fact or Fiction.” The Yale Law Journal Pocket Part. 70. 2006.

Web. January 14 2014.

Townsend, Lucy. “How Unrealistic Is Murder On Television.” BBC News Magazine. 16 January

2013. Web. 9 January 2014.

“U.S. Homes Receive a Record 118.6 TV Channels on Average.” MediaBuyerPlanner. 16 June 2008.

Web. 2 February 2014.
Open Document