The Natural Movie

748 Words2 Pages

Changes
In the novel “The Natural” written by Bernard Malamud Roy Hobbs is a man that is terrible with making good decisions for himself as well as learning from his mistakes. In the film version of the movie directed by Barry Levinson, the viewer is exposed to a Roy Hobbs that is the exact opposite. Movie Roy shows the viewer how a mature professional baseball player is supposed to handle himself and how to go about life. Overall the two differences in character are very profound and speak volume to the differences that movies and books have. Roy Hobbs is a different character in the book and in the movie and it shows by his decision making, rational responses and how he handles certain situations.
Movie Roy makes some great decisions, …show more content…

Movie Roy handles himself in a manner that people are proud off and want to hang around. He thinks with his head and is smart in his decision making. An example of this is when he is asked where he is from. The reason that this is a good decision not to tell others exactly where he is from is simply because then the past will be broughten up. The last thing that Roy wants is for his past experiences and life to be brought to the main stream. Book Roy makes a terrible decision with a lady who attends one of his games. Roy finally opens up about the train and why it took him so long to get to baseball. Shortly after he seduces the lady into having sed with him. “Roy, are you-”(Malamud 157), Roy was not using protection. This is a great example of how book Roy never used his head and was always thinking of pleasure and never the consequence of his actions might be.
Movie Roy and book Roy have profound differences. They have unique characteristics that help and hurt them in the long run. Most off all they contrast one another on many levels and cause a friction amongst the two that a reader or viewer is keen to pick up on. The differences they share include their decision making, rational responses and their ability to handle situations they are faced with. Movie Roy does a much better job of handling these situations on a moment to moment basis unlike book Roy. Overall, they both make mistakes but only movie Roy is truly able to learn from the mistakes he has

Open Document