The Mental State in Scottish Supernatural Fiction

2265 Words5 Pages

Ghost stories and supernatural fiction have entertained readers for centuries. Margaret Oliphant wrote a short story, “The Library Window” about a young woman who sees a man working in a room through his window, but the room does not exist. J. M. Barrie’s story Farewell Miss Julie Logan is about a young minister who sees a young woman and falls in love with her, but no one else can see her. In “The Watcher by the Threshold”, John Buchan writes the story of a man who has an illness, believes he is being haunted by the Devil, and forms a connection with Justinian as a form of relief. Some supernatural fiction, however, can do more than simply entertain. It can also be used to reveal truths about humanity and the conditions of the mind. Buchan, Oliphant, and Barrie use a supernatural plot to explore the mental state of characters who are isolated from human interactions and the consequences of isolation.
In the short story “The Library Window”, Margaret Oliphant writes about a young woman who is isolated from the people around her. One reason for this isolation is that she is the only young person in a house with an elderly aunt and her friends (1, 3). Almost every time her aunt or her aunt’s friends are mentioned, they are referred to as being “old” (1,3, 6). She feels “unconsciously the contrast of [her] youngness to their oldness” (3). She passes the majority of her time sitting in “the deep recess of the drawing-room window” (1). From this situation she is able to watch the street below her, the windows across from her, listen in on the conversations in the room, or read her books. (1, 5). As a result she is merely a spectator of the world around her, and the elderly friends of her aunt recognize that there is something odd abo...

... middle of paper ...

...rrie, J. M.. “Farewell Miss Julie Logan” Farewell Miss Julie Logan: A J. M. Barrie Omnibus. Ed. Andrew Nash. Edinburgh, Hewer Text Ltd, 2000. 248-330. Print.
Buchan, John. “The Watcher by the Threshold.” The University of Adelaide. 1900. Web. 27 Oct, 2013.
Calder, Jenni. “Through Mrs Oliphant’s Library Window.” Women’s Writing 10.3 (2003): 485-502. Print.
Hynd, Hzel. “Celtic Rivals: John Davidson and W. B. Yeats.” Irish Studies Review. 10.3 (2013). 277-288. Print.
“J. M. Barrie Biography” BBC Two: Writing Scotland. British Broadcasting Corporation, 2013. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
“John Buchan Biography” BBC Two: Writing Scotland. British Broadcasting Corporation, 2013. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
“Margaret Oliphant Biography” BBC Two: Writing Scotland. British Broadcasting Corporation, 2013. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
Oliphant, Margaret. “The Library Window.” Gaslight, 1896. Web. 13 Oct. 2013.

Open Document