The Constitutional Congress set out to develop a way to select the president. One idea proposed was to have Congress elect the president. Some felt that this procedure would invite political bargaining and corruption. They felt the president might feel obligated to aid Congress in passing legislation by not vetoing. Others felt this system would upset the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches of government.
This phenomenon may very well happen again this year. This system needs to be changed. The highest office in our great nation needs to be elected by the people he/she is representing. The electoral college was developed by our founding fathers as a compromise between a president elected by Congress and one elected by the popular vote of the people. They feared that if the president was elected by Congress, he/she may feel some obligation to it.
As the Constitution of the United States was drafted, three options were presented as a means to elect the Executive branch of the government. The first idea was to have Congress chose the President, but it was ultimately rejected because it would “upset the balance of power between the legislative and executive branches of government” (Kimberling, 1992). The second was to have state legislatures choose the President. This idea was also rejected due to fear that the President would feel obligated to the states that put him in office, which would “undermine the whole idea of a federation” (Kimberling, 1992). The third idea was to elect the president by popular vote; however, the framers of the constitution had limited trust in the capability of the public to make intelligent and informed decisions.
The Electoral College system is a body of electors who formally elect the United States president and vice president. It was one of the most difficult agenda items in the 1787 Convention, where delegates were trying to create a fair and equitable way of selecting our President. As we would expect, there were numerous suggestions. For example, some delegates urged that the President should be selected by the Legislature while opposing delegates, in favor of direct election, believed that the Presidents loyalty would be to the Legislature instead of being independent in... ... middle of paper ... ...ring Constitutional Conflicts. Web.
The founders originally came up with several different ideas to accomplish this. After deciding against a popular national vote, they considered just having the congress or the state legislature select the president. They finally decided on the system that we have today, the Electoral College. The Electoral College works by representing each state separately in the election. In doing this, the states share power with the federal government.
The members of the convention felt that the direct election of the president by the people would give them too much power. Before choosing the Electoral College, the Constitutional Convention came up with several methods of selecting a president with those reasons under consider... ... middle of paper ... ...hey too found themselves to be deadlocked. This led to the creation of the Electoral Commission of 1877, which chose Hayes on a party vote. Later, Congress passed a law that gave states exclusive powers to resolve all controversies involving the selection of electors. The last change that has been made to the Electoral College came by way of the 23rd Amendment.
The candidate with the majority of the votes, Geor... ... middle of paper ... ...e is entitled electors whose duty is to elect the President. Giving the power to the electors is unfair to the public who are the ones who should be choosing. The Electoral College ignores a large percentage of votes, discourages voter participation, and the way electors vote can all influence the election making it unfair. Through this process, the voting public is not reflected appropriately by the electors. The electors have all the power when it comes to electing the President.
They felt that political parties were dishonest and evil due to the British Election 3 political parties. This led them to have to find a way to accommodate everyone without the use of political parties and a national campaign. The Founding Fathers came up with several different ways that they could elect the president. The first idea was to have Congress select the president but this idea was rejected because many felt this would lead to corruption within the government because members of Congress. It could have also led to a bad balance of power between the legislative and executive branches of government.
The debate over democracy began at the time of our nation’s founding and still strongly exists among today’s society. With the rapid development of technology and social media, American politics have become a complete mess as it is being displayed in our current presidential election. Almost everyone in America believes in democracy, however, Americans possess many different beliefs regarding how far democracy should extend into political, social, and economical life. One of the fundamental arguments that exist among political scientists is the idea of popular democracy versus elite democracy. Elite democrats hold the belief that democracy is a valuable method for selecting our government officials, yet they are cynical about the political
Some wanted to elect them like they do in Great Brittan with the parliament electing the prime minister. Others disagreed. The compromise was the creation of what we now call the Electoral College. One might think that when they cast their vote in the presidential election, that they are voting directly for the president. This is not so!