The Defeat of The Confederacy

1817 Words8 Pages
There were several reasons for the defeat of the Confederacy which included no industrial base, (Donald 1996, p. 99) inadequate transportation net (Donald, 1996, p. 99), and bickering among the generals (McPherson & Hogue, 2009, p. 365) etc., but the overriding factor was that the Confederacy never became a nation (Donald, 1996, p. 100). That is, they seceded because the Southern states believed they had the right as independent States to do so (Donald, 1996, p. 7). The South lost because they never stopped believing this. No state could depend on any other for full support of the war. The Governor of Georgia specifically prohibited his troops from fighting outside the state for many months. Many governors set limits on how many troops they would spare and where they could be used. The States kept home guards far beyond the actual need for internal security. The Confederacy was more of a coalition than a Confederacy. General Lee spoke of his "country" when he talked of Virginia (Bowman, 2006, p.49).

This is a simplistic answer to a very complicated question that needs a great deal more discussion and investigation. But of course the factors that enter into the South's ultimate defeat are those things that are consistently emphasized with a great amount of validity: the North's industrial base; the North's manpower resources and the fact that foreign recognition was denied the Confederacy. Why did the South lose? When the question is asked that way, it presupposes that the South lost the war all by itself and that it really never could have won it. The South lost because the North outmanned and outclassed it at almost every point, even militarily (Donald, 1996, pp. 99-100). The North was able to bring its industry a...

... middle of paper ...

...cago, IL, The University of Chicago Press.

McPherson J. & Hogue J. (2009) Ordeal by Fire: The Civil War and Reconstruction

(4th ed.), New York, NY, The Mcgraw-Hill Company.

Bowman J. (2006) The Civil War: The definitive reference including a chronology of

events, An encyclopedia, and the memoirs of Grant and Lee. East Bridgewater MA,

World Publication Group East and JG Press.

Donald, D. (1996), Why the North won the Civil War. Simon and Schuster Adult

Publishing Group.

McPherson J. & Hogue J. (2009) Ordeal by Fire: The Civil War and Reconstruction

(4th ed.), New York, NY, The Mcgraw-Hill Company.

McPherson J. (1996) Drawn with the sword: Reflections on the American Civil War

Oxford New York, Oxford University Press.

The Columbian Exchange, (2011). Retrieved from

Open Document