The Case of Anne Gunter

The case of Anne Gunter fits the modern stereotype of witchcraft accusations and the trials that resulted from them; a young girl falsely claims that an older woman or women are causing her harm using supernatural abilities they have gained through nefarious means, sending the community into an uproar. Hysteria runs rampant through the community and the poor women are harshly punished – the formulaic story plays out similarly throughout popular media, must notably in Arthur Millers’ ‘The Crucible’. Yet in the case of young Anne Gunter from North Moreton, there is a deviation from the “standard plot” of a witchcraft trial – the women are acquitted and Miss Gunter’s subterfuge is revealed. The fact that the allegations are not only proven to be false, but a confession of such is given by Anne Gunter allows the focus to shift from the actual Gunter case to what factors played into why people were accused of witchcraft. What we can infer from the Gunter case is that people in England were accused of witchcraft because of three major things: lack of power, prestige, and plenty within society.

Generally, there is a socioeconomic disparity between the accuser and those who are accused of practicing witchcraft. The accuser is usually from a higher social class than the people that they are bringing allegations against. The power dynamic between the two parties is often weighted in favor of the person throwing out accusations. Anne Gunter came from a family that was relatively new to North Moreton, but her father, Brian Gunter, was the only gentleman in the village. Yet one of the women Anne accused of witchcraft was a member of one of the leading families of North Moreton, the Gregory’s. Elizabeth Gregory was the wife of a yeoman farmer...

... middle of paper ...

... well liked. Reputations are also shaped by interacts with others, which can lead to civility or animosity between citizens.

One could argue that there are a many reasons why someone would be accused of witchcraft during the early modern period. Using Anne Gunter as a case study, three important factors can be parsed out: power, reputation, and wealth. Those with the power, a good reputation, and wealth, can easily throw out accusations at people lacking in all three areas who are in a lower station than them. Social status matters when it comes to accusations of witchcraft. A woman who is poor and thought to be a witch or has a bad reputation among her neighbors, is more likely to be labelled a witch than the daughter of a gentleman. That is why reputation is the most important factor in considering why people were accused of witchcraft in early modern England.