Summary Of The Lamplighter By Maria Susanna Cummins And Ruth Hall

2145 Words5 Pages

Females are powerful creatures that are often overlooked and underestimated. Females are a force to be reckoned with. In literature, the inspiration that drives the creation of strong female characters often comes from the writer’s own experience and life. This essay will compare the female characters of The Lamplighter by Maria Susanna Cummins and Ruth Hall: A Domestic Tale of the Present Time by Fanny Fern and the characters’ journey toward independence by referencing how the genres of literature and background of the authors feed the main ideas of the respective novels. Fanny Fern was born Sarah Payson Willis in July of 1811 in Maine and died in 1872 at the age of sixty-one. Her father was “Nathaniel Willis, a printer and founder of the …show more content…

Cummins life experiences lack in grief and struggle compared to Fern’s as well. An interesting issue in Cummin’s life however, is the fact that historians are not sure who Maria’s mother was. Her father was a well off man who began her education on his own and later enrolled her in “Mrs. Charles Sedgwick’s Young Ladies School…where she continued her adolescent studies” (“Cummins, Maria Susanna” 857). After her education at the young ladies school, Cummins wrote short fiction anonymously in periodicals throughout the New England area (857) before publishing The Lamplighter, her most successful work, in 1854. Unlike Ruth Hall: A Domestic Tale of the Present Time and its existence as an autobiography of Fanny Fern, The Lamplighter, is a work of fiction. However, The Lamplighter does draw on some similar details of Cummins’ life. For example, the uncertain identity of Cummins’ mother is paralleled in the uncertain identity of Gertrude’s father for a majority of the novel. There is also the similarity of Cummins’ education at Mrs. Charles Sedgewick’s Young Ladies School with that of Gertrude’s position of employment at Mr. W’s school as a teacher …show more content…

The Lamplighter is full of emotion, rather than reason, that attacks the senses and the hearts of the readers. The connections that exist for a wide variety of readers aided to its popularity. “Domestic sales at the end of twenty days reached 20,000 copies; by year’s end the total had swelled to 73,000, and translations in French, German, Danish, and Italian followed suit, along with pirated editions in England (“Cummins, Maria Susanna” 857). Her writing style makes her work appealing to readers of different backgrounds and classes. While both The Lamplighter and Ruth Hall: A Domestic Tale of the Present Time exhibit sentimental tropes, as June Howard concludes in her article entitled, “What is Sentimentality?”, it is impossible to “end discussion and produce a consensus for a single definition of sentimentality” (Howard 76). So both novels are sentimental because of the authors’ writing styles, but they can both be considered unsentimental as well, depending on the background of the reader, where the reader searches for examples of sentimentalism, and how the reader react to the novels themselves.
To examine these ideas more specifically, the reader should examine Emily Graham, of The Lamplighter, who is a rather interesting character. While she is reliant on the aid of others due to her blindness, she is strong willed and focused. She has an independent mind and a dependent body.

Open Document