South Vietnam Case Analysis
analytical Essay
1040 words
2. To what extent could McNarmara’s assessment be said to reflect the success of the North Vietnamese “strategy of attriting our national will”?
The goal of north Vietnam was to weaken both the US and South Vietnam so that they could rule over the South making it a whole coutry. We were keeping the south from becoming communist. Eventually we ended up leaving Vietnam because of the casualties suffered. This assessment reflects the success of the North because now there is not North and South Vietnam it is only the one Vietnam. This shows that the North ened up being victorious.
4. What assumptions did McNamara make about the support of war among the South Vietnamese, American military personell, and Americans at home?
The South Vietnamese were for the Americans helping in the fight against communism. The American military personell were
…show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how vietnam changed their view on america because of the horrendous acts that occurred over there. the act of killing another person was turned into a game.
- Analyzes how mcnamara's assessment reflects the success of the north vietnamese "strategy of attriting our national will".
- Explains woodley committed crimes against humanity because he had joined the game of killing others. he was a burden to society because no one could control him.
- Explains that the criminal abortion laws were created in the victorian time era to limit on illicit sexual conduct.
- Opines that mccorvey was exploited because she was not properly explained the process of abortion and what an abortion is.
- Analyzes how the man is happy in america because he has more freedom and oppurtunities for jobs, and his children are above average in their courses.
Wade and Abortion Rights
2. According to the court, why were criminal abortion laws enacted?
The criminal abortion laws were created in the Victorian time era. They were created to limit on illicit sexual conduct.the first point was the fact that the texas courts did not advance this justification. The second reason is that abortion is looked as a medical procedure but when abortions were first used they were harmful for the female. The third reason is the states intrest in the need for protecting the prenatal life.
4. With respect to the state’s important and legitimate intrest in potential life, the “compelling” point is at viability.
This statement is talking about regulations that are enforced by the state. There is a certian point in the pregnancy that the baby is considered viable. This regulation also helps with the mothers health. The mother is benifited both physically and mentally with these regulations.
30.3 Norma McCorvey explains how she became “Roe” of Roe Vs Wade
2. Why, according to McCorvey, was she “Exploited by two self interested attorneys”? Do you agree with her? Why or why
Related
- analytical
- opinion
- explanatory
- comparative
- Abortion, Public Policy, & Texasanalytical essayIn 1973, in what has become a landmark ruling for women’s rights, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of a woman’s right to an abortion. Ever since, individual states have adopted, altered, and/or mutilated the edict to fit their agendas – Texas included. However, the decision made by the justices in Roe v. Wade didn’t set clear cut, inarguable demarcation lines, which has allowed the fiery debate to consume the nation. Rather than establishing a legal ruling of what life is, or is not, the Supreme Court has remained silent on the issue.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that texas' parties shifted from predominantly democrat to being dominated by republicans, creating a conservative think tank amongst state legislators.
- Argues that abortion in the western hemisphere has become a largely controversial topic that affects every human being. there is no agreement on when life begins and at which one crosses the line from unalienable rights to murder.
- Argues that the social contract prohibits abortions because a fetus can be the same as minors, the mentally retarded, or the insane.
- Explains that with new laws in texas, self-induced abortion could rise. dave, p. (2014, april 16). judge rules north dakota's abortion ban after 6 weeks unconstitutional.
1028 wordsRead More - January, 1968: Keh Sanh, The Tet Offensive, and the Unraveling of an American Presidencyanalytical essayWhen President Johnson delivered his State of the Union Address to Congress on January 17, 1968 he spoke of the war in Vietnam with optimism. He listed the many military accomplishments to date, mentioned the word “progress” five times, discussed a “fruitful” visit with the pope, and spoke with a tone and tenor that suggested an imminent, peaceful resolution (“Johnson’s Annual Message”). Not three months later – in a similarly important speech to the American people – Johnson stoically announced that he would not be seeking reelection (“Johnson’s Address to the Nation”). What had seemed like an impending certainty dissolved into a distant dream. Public support for the war, and of Johnson, had deteriorated so swiftly in the winter of 1968 that he had no choice but to disband his efforts to seek a second term. What happened in the months between Johnson’s confident State of the Union and his more sullen speech in March of 1968 is no mystery. The Battle of Khe Sanh, combined with the more lastingly impactful Tet Offensive in late January, were devastating blows to American efforts in Vietnam. In hindsight, these events may have been militarily ineffective, yet the cultural ricochets they created throughout America can be seen as nothing short of a major victory for the North Vietnamese. These events were instrumental in turning the tides of the war.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the battle of khe sanh and tet offensive were devastating blows to american efforts in vietnam.
- Analyzes how the 76-day battle at khe sanh ended with both sides claiming victory.
- Analyzes the dramatic shift in american public opinion of the war, and of johnson's handling of it.
- Describes william thomas allison's the tet offensive: a brief history, with documents.
- Analyzes how the tet offensive had a devastating effect on american perception of the war — it showed unforeseen weakness in american forces and unexpected strength in the north vietnamese.
- Analyzes how president lyndon b. johnson's address to the nation announcing steps to limit the war in vietnam and reporting his decision not to seek reelection: march 31, 1968.
1741 wordsRead More - Jane Roe's Argument Against Abortionanalytical essayTexas statutes created it a criminal offense to acquire or try associate abortion except once medically suggested for the aim of saving the lifetime of the mother. Appellant Jane Roe sought-after a declarative judgment that the statutes were unconstitutional on their face associated an injunction to forestall litigant city County public prosecutor from implementing the statutes. Appellant purported that she was single and pregnant, which she was unable to receive a legal abortion by a commissioned medico as a result of her life wasn't vulnerable by the continuation of her physiological condition which she was unable to afford to visit another jurisdiction to get a legal abortion. Appellant sued on behalf of herself and every one different girls equally settled, claiming that the statutes were unconstitutionally imprecise and cut her right of private privacy, protected by the primary, Fourth, Fifth, Ninth, and Fourteenth
In this essay, the author
- Explains that texas statutes created it a criminal offense to acquire or try to associate abortion except once medically suggested for the aim of saving the lifetime of the mother.
- Explains that texas statutes unsuitably invade the rights influenced by the appellant to cease her physiological condition symbolized within the fourteenth amendment’s group action clause, within personal married, familial, and sexual discrepancy
- Argues that the court finds that associate degree abortion statute that bans all abortions except within the case of a life saving procedure on behalf of the mother is unconstitutional based upon the veracious to privacy.
310 wordsRead More - Wade's Case: The 1973 Roe V. Wadeanalytical essayA Texas law that made abortion a crime except when in the case of saving the mothers life was overruled by the United States Supreme Court in 1973. (Greenberg 435) In 1970, abortion was illegal for women who live in many of the states of the U.S, until a woman by the name of Norma McCorvey also known as Jane Roe, decided it was time to make a change. McCorvey was a resident of the States of Texas, and strongly believed
In this essay, the author
- Explains that 1973 roe v. wade is one of the most controversial cases in the united states in not only the abortion issue, but also in american government.
- Explains that texas law made abortion a crime except when in the case of saving the mothers life was overruled by the united states supreme court in 1973.
- Explains that justice blackmun's 1973 supreme court decision would have struck down the texas law on the grounds of vagueness, and the majority of abortion statutes in the united states would be unconstitutionally vague.
- Explains that after the rehearing, the court, with blackmun again writing for the majority, found the texas abortion law to be unconstitutional.
- Argues that abortion should not be considered in cases where the pregnancy might not have been planned or the child wouldn't be safe in living conditions of its parents.
- Analyzes how the supreme court's decision on roe v. wade has polarized the american people with the legal, moral, and political issues.
- Explains that due process of law ensures the government respects all of a person's legal rights instead of just some or most of them. it is also interpreted as placing limitations on laws and legal proceedings in order to guarantee fundamental fairness, justice and liberty.
- Explains the issue of whether a pregnant woman has the constitutional right to terminate the pregnancy of her baby by means of abortion, and whether it is in the state of texas interests to preserve the life of the child and/or mother.
- Explains that the ninth amendment protected a woman's right to privacy, and the court did not accept arguments based on the due process clause of the fourth amendment.
- Explains that justine blackmun has been explained the three reasons delivering the opinion of the court, which explain abortion laws and justify their continued existence today.
- Opines that the government is threatening to restrict women's freedom by limiting their options.
- Explains that abortion was morally wrong and was constituted as a crime that could lead to prison. the roe v. wade decision has impacted the lives of men and women.
- Explains that after abortion legalization, the number of sexually transmitted diseases increased. one of the major costs associated with sexual involvement is the risk of unwanted pregnancy.
- Opines that abortion was legalized by the roe v. wade case, which affected all aspects of society, from the supreme court to the human status of an unborn fetus.
1423 wordsRead More - The Tet Offensive of the Vietnam Waropinion essayadvance for the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong, but also gave the United States a
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the book tells where the tet offensive stands in terms of length of the war.
- Analyzes how tet carries the topic for the two weeks that followed.
- Explains that the first major problem was that there was little help available for the few arvns.
- Explains that there were only two ways to get from one side to the other: a rail-bridge and an elevator.
- Narrates how they retake the macv building and retreat on the perfume river.
- Explains that arvn 1st division was the only company to retake the city.
- Opines that americans didn't think they had any right to be there, and it wasn’t our war.
- Describes the consequences of shooting at any american they saw, even though they were not american citizens.
- Opines that most of the wounded had already died and managed to make their way to the hospital.
- Opines that u.s. raids on towns and villages earned them just as much contempt as the north.
- Opines that the u.s. made a major mistake in removing support functions.
- Opines that the slogan “hey l.b.j., how many kids did you kill today?” put a dent in the killing of children.
- Opines that it was a psychological advance for the north vietnamese and the viet cong, but also gave the united states the notion that the war wasn't going to be an easy win.
- Explains that vietnam was in a civil war divided by political ideologies. the domino effect is the idea that when one nation falls to communism, other nations around it will fall.
- Explains that the cease-fire was a peaceful and hospitable agreement between the u.s. and the nva to stop all assaults during tet, the annual vietnamese festival for celebrating the lunar new year.
- Explains that people from all over the nation flew to vietnam to document the sights and stories, so that viewers at home would have a feel for the war they were paying for.
- Analyzes how the tet offensive proved wrong the claims of general westermoreland of the u.s. army that the war would be a swift victory for democracy
- Explains that the live coverage of the vc attack on the u.s. embassy in saigon gave the american public a different view on war.
- Describes how a vc suspect was sentenced to death and shot in the head by an arvn regular from point-blank range in saigon.
- Analyzes how the media's coverage of vietnam was a severe blow to the war effort. walter cronkite gave his personal opinion of the vietnam war in 1968.
- Analyzes how cronkite felt he was certain to lose the election. he turned to his press secretary and said, “if i’ve lost walter, i have lost mr. average citizen.”
- Opines that the attack had torn a psychological hole in the u.s. forces and the arvn. there was an incredible amount of fear and paranoia felt throughout the ranks.
- Analyzes how the tet offensive was short, and the cities taken by the nva and vc were retaken quickly, but one dragged on.
- Explains that the city was divided by the perfume river on the north side of the citadel, surrounded by twenty foot walls.
- Opines that the nva and vc suffered about ten times the casualties as the marines and arvn. the long period of fighting had broken the u.s.
- Explains that before tet, the vc had never planned a major assault, and many u.s. troops were scared to death of every new town or village.
- Explains that in 1968, company c of the 1st division marine infantry swept through the town before diverting off to binh tay. the village was burned to the ground.
- Describes how he spent his time giving aid to the vietnamese farmers who were forced to leave the countryside and seek refuge in towns and cities. he was stationed in quang ngai, one of the major attack points
- Explains that the vc had taken over the local high-school in quang ngai, and the blockade they set up prevented access to the hospital from the residential areas.
- Explains that civilians had a new sense of trust in the americans and much more contempt for the vc and nva.
- Explains that commanders felt it was too dangerous for them to be in the vicinity of the fighting. the women, who were mostly volunteers, felt that they were being labeled as weak.
- Narrates how they gathered a group of statesmen and soldiers whom they trusted, and whose opinions he valued. they were known as the "wise men."
- Describes how the group met with the president for lunch and gave johnson counsel to move towards peace, and cut back on military attacks.
- Explains that lack of support was the main key in the u.s. failure to win the war.
- Analyzes how his opinion toward the war changed after the tet offensive, and how that changed the feelings of the readers.
- Narrates martin's account of the change in moral of volunteers and civilians under pressure after the tet.
2385 wordsRead More - Dovesopinion essayThe Vietnam War was a war with many unnecessary casualties and injuries. The United States entered the Vietnam War and increased the stakes. Now South Vietna...
In this essay, the author
- Opines that killing under the cloak of war is nothing but an act of murder. the vietnam war was a war that america did not need.
- Explains that the french were forced out of vietnam and vietnam was divided between communist and anti-communist regimes. the united states believed in the domino theory.
- Explains that the vietnam war was a war with unnecessary casualties and injuries. the united states entered the war and increased the stakes.
- Explains that agent orange was a conglomerate mix of different herbicides used to remove enemy cover and destroy crop fields for enemy soldiers in vietnam, laos, and cambodia.
- Describes how a team of american soldiers were sent to the village of my lai on march 16th, 1968. they were told that everyone there was part of the vietcong or supporters.
- Argues that america needs to be careful where they are involved because there is always a large impact. america's involvement in the war caused other communist countries to become involved.
- Opines that america's ideas of saving are always based on war. they believe that they must fight to save others.
- Cites the works citedagent orange from http://www.history.com/topics/vietnam-war/agent-orange.
826 wordsRead More - The Peace Treaty between the United States and Hanoiexplanatory essayHanoi quickly moved into the south to appoint officials and re-organize society. Northern and southern Vietnam had been separated for thirty years. The period of 1973-1975 was “their war”, not America’s war in Vietnam. This war was fought between Vietnamese. The United States was involved monetarily, but for the most part, this war was fought between North Vietnam vs. South Vietnam. North Vietnam won and the war was over. Vietnam had finally been reunited after many bloody years of war.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the peace treaty signed by the united states and hanoi did not mean an end to conflict in vietnam. the republic of vietnam was the sole legitimate government in south vietnam, as nixon saw it.
- Describes how thieu defied the paris peace agreement by bombing the joint military commissions teams mapping respective zones, and launching economic blockades against prg (provisional revolutionary government) zones.
- Explains that the united states gave a considerable amount of aid to the republic of vietnam before and after the signing of the paris peace agreements.
- Describes how the drv began to construct a highway network from the demilitarized zone to north of saigon.
- Explains that the prg was willing to negotiate a peace with thieu and his government, but he declined. the war was on its last leg but efforts to continue the carnage by generals of the south continued
- Explains that hanoi quickly moved into the south to appoint officials and re-organize society. the period of 1973-1975 was "their war", not america's war in vietnam.
820 wordsRead More - Abortion Essaycomparative essay“Laws against abortion have been around for approximately two hundred years though they have varied by state,” (Laws Against Abortion par. 1). In 1973, however, abortion was legalized as a result of the U.S. Supreme Court rule in Roe v. Wade. In this court case, the Supreme Court held that “the word ‘person,’ as used in the Fourteenth Amendment, does not include the unborn,” (McCuen 106). The ruling created a fundamental right for a woman to choose to have an abortion, no matter t...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that abortion has been practiced since ancient times as an effective form of birth control. pregnancies were terminated through a number of methods.
- Explains that abortion laws have been around for approximately two hundred years though they have varied by state. in 1973, abortion was legalized as a result of the u.s. supreme court rule in roe v. wade.
- Explains that many women encounter health risks that prevent them from safely continuing a pregnancy, such as severe infections, heart failure, and severe cases of preeclampsia.
- Explains that the religious issue over abortion is complex because of the varied nature of religion in the united states.
- Explains that pro-lifers claim that abortion should be illegal because it is a form of murder. the best alternative to abortion is giving the baby up for adoption.
- Concludes that abortion should remain legal and allow women to have a second chance when the life of the expected mother is in danger. anti-abortion laws are unconstitutional.
596 wordsRead More - What Was The Battle Of Saigon: The Success Of The Vietnam War?explanatory essayThere are many opinions and theories to why the Vietnam War is unsuccessful for the United States. Most of the views on success are directly attached to the perceived victories and losses of battles. The battle discussed in this paper is the Battle of Saigon. This battle is said to be one of the successful battles in Vietnam. Research on this battle comes from four online sources: Battle for Saigon, Tet Offensive (1968), Tet Offensive – Vietnam War, and Vietnam War: General William Westmoreland. There are similar facts in these sources; but, there are also subtle information additions that allow more insight into the battle as a whole. First, the battle is reviewed in its original occurrence. Then alternate outcomes are provided. The notion
In this essay, the author
- Explains that there are many opinions and theories to why the vietnam war is unsuccessful for the united states. the battle of saigon is one of the successful battles in vietnam.
- Explains that there are many views on the success of the battle of saigon. the united states military has declared this battle as a victory, while the north vietnamese have also claimed this victory.
- Describes how general william westmoreland became commander of the military assistance command, vietnam (macv) and began building up troops in south vietnam.
- Describes giap's "general offensive," a two-part strategy designed to prevent the south vietnamese army from responding and weaken the americans' will to stop the fight.
- Explains that the battle of saigon took place in this south vietnamese capital on january 31, 1968. the principle adversaries are the military assistance command, vietnam (macv) and the north vietnamese (nva/vc).
1079 wordsRead More - My Lai Research Paperopinion essaythe American approach in Vietnam and particularly their inability to ‘win the hearts and minds
In this essay, the author
- Explains that vietnam and my lai offer a warning about the nature of warfare.
- Analyzes how my lai emphasizes to the historian the dangers of using certain sources as evidence.
- Opines that historians need to question the validity of all facts.
- Describes the use of the word “assault formation.”
- Explains that events at war are defined by the purpose that they serve the reasons for american war.
- Analyzes how insulting the past suggests that we can never trust any source and therefore anyone.
- Opines that all sources hold value as they represent the view of a person.
- Opines that it is important to know what took place in vietnam.
- Describes the factors that determine who you are, where you were, and why.
- Opines that the american approach in vietnam and especially their inability to ‘win the hearts and minds of the people’ is a major factor in the conclusion and subsequent loss.
- Analyzes how vietnam highlighted the power of the media as a tool for public persuasion.
- Analyzes how the structure of war led to a greater emphasis on dead bodies.
- Opines that we need to bear in mind the validity of first-hand accounts, without knowing.
- Opines that the scale of events at my lai was exceptional only in its scale, while sanders describes it as the most famous but by no means only example of american hatred of the vietnamese.
- Argues that if events of similar nature existed, they would not have been able to remove themselves from public view.
- Opines that the reasons for a country entering war may not reflect experience as much as the individual reasons of those soldiers who chose to fight.
- Opines that sanders, v. the usa and vietnam 1945-75, hodder and stoughton, 2004, p89, kendrik, o.
- Opines that knowledge is controlled and in the hands of the people who are going to shape it to reflect their views.
- Explains that postmodernism advocates that history is history if it is believed to be true, individual truths take priority over ‘universals’.
- Analyzes how my lai has left a significant and controversial place in history because it is the most horrific example. it offers lessons about history rather than defines it as overall.
1118 wordsRead More