Similarities and Differences in Ancient and Modern Slavery

957 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: history of slavery

Slavery has been a main problem in the world for centuries. Slavery goes back to Babylon over 2,500 years ago and it is still a growing problem in the modern society. Slavery is not just one dimensional; it involves gender, race and physical appearance of a slave. In this paper, I am going to compare and contrast David Brion Davis’ view of ancient slavery along with modern day slavery by Ryan J. Dalton, and discuss why they are not similar with each other. In Modern Day Slavery by Ryan J. Dalton, discuss the problem of human trafficking in Tennessee. Dalton mention that women and children were forced into prostitution by gangs and other organized crime groups to earn money. This is different from ancient slavery discussed by David Brion Davis in Inhuman Bondage, slaves were captured and they could be raped and quickly sold. The difference between modern and ancient slavery in sex are modern slave trafficking’s main goal is to earn profit by the owner while ancient slave owner rape their slave without profit.
In Modern Slavery, Dalton explained how women and children were forced into slavery by using Terrance Yarbrough’s crime as an example. Dalton wrote “Victims testified to being beaten by Yarbrough with padlocks, crowbars and dog chains, and being burned with irons and scalding hot water in order to force the woman into prostitution.” (Daltn, 13) The women who were abducted by Yarbrough include young girls as young as only fifteen years old. Human trafficking victims were not born into slavery like most natural slaves. Human trafficking victims were forced into prostitution by the abductor. Like Aristotle’s idea of free men are not suitable of slave world and should be useful from community life, human trafficking victims were...

... middle of paper ...

...intended to make the bodies of free man and of slaves different also; slaves’ bodies strong for the services they have to do, those of free men upright and not much use for the kind of work, but instead useful from community life.” (Davis, 34)
In conclusion, ancient slavery and modern slavery are similar but different in general. Slaves were usually born into slavery for ancient slavery while sex trafficking victims were captured and forced into slavery. The main purpose of ancient slavery were slave labor and treated worse than dogs, while the main purpose of human trafficking is to gain profit from what sex trafficking victims earn. Also, ancient slavery was legal while sex trafficking is not. Although there are many difference between ancient and modern day slavery, we could still agree that both are extremely dehumanizing and should eliminate slavery on earth.

Show More
Related

  • The Characteristics Of Human Slavery In 1450-1750 CE

    1237 Words  | 3 Pages

    During the era of 1450-1750 CE, the characteristics of human slavery throughout the world started as a system of assistance gained from the capturing of enemy soldiers and adopting them into the victors society, but changed to a large trafficking business reaching overseas, and then to inherited positions gained from being born into slavery. However, throughout this time period, slavery continued to center in Africa and the Middle East, and remained a prime source of human labor in every society, due to their ability to be easily obtained and cheaply managed.

    Read More

  • Slavery In Pseudolus, By Titus Maccius Plautus

    1208 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to the Marvin Perry, “ slaves was practiced in ancient times, in many lands, and among most people.”(Perry, 112) Especially in ancient Roman, when Roman armies expand to other countries and areas successfully, they captured people during the battle and send back to Rome to be sold to the wealthy Romans as their slaves. During the last centuries of Republic and the early centuries of the imperial age, the Roman war brought back to a huge amount of slaves as their spoils of the wars. Slaves was considered legally to be a piece of property without their own freedom. In ancient Roman, people called their slaves as the “Speaking Tools” . Slaves did not treat as a human beings with legal citizen rights. They sold as products to the market and valued by their demographic characteristics including age, gender, personal skills, ethnic,manner, appearance, and personality. The lives of slaves conspicuously harsh by their tough works and cruel tortures from their inconsidered masters. The more brutal oppression of masters, the more intense of slave revolt, and finally to cause the massive revolt in Roman.

    Read More

  • Slavery in American Society: Impact and Evolution

    1631 Words  | 4 Pages

    The controversies surrounding slavery have been established in many societies worldwide for centuries. In past generations, although slavery did exists and was tolerated, it was certainly very questionable,” ethically“. Today, the morality of such an act would not only be unimaginable, but would also be morally wrong. As things change over the course of history we seek to not only explain why things happen, but as well to understand why they do. For this reason, we will look further into how slavery has evolved throughout History in American society, as well as the impacts that it has had.

    Read More

  • Inhuman Treatment of Slaves in Ancient Rome

    1010 Words  | 3 Pages

    Previous Roman actions have raised the question whether they recognized their slaves as things or people. Of course, there are economic advantages in support of slavery. However, when human lives are under constant danger and torture, the economic advantages must be forgotten. Although the slaves of Ancient Rome played a pivotal role in the society, their actions were never approved. After careful consideration, it is evident that the Romans recognized slaves as things rather than people. This conception is mainly due to three factors. They include: slaves being put on the market, the physical cruelty towards the slaves, and the slaves being mistreated to the point of revolt.

    Read More

  • Slavery: The Double-Edged Sword

    1333 Words  | 3 Pages

    To be black is to be naturally inferior; this was the mindset of the American South in the beginning of the 19th century. African Americans were confined to slavery with no means to change their situation or to escape the abuse that often accompanied their position. Slaves endured all forms of physical and mental punishment whose sole purpose was to keep them inferior to their white suppressors. Slaves were maintained through ignorance; they had their self-identity stolen from them and were kept illiterate to prevent them from questioning what power kept them oppressed and to prevent them from spreading word of the brutalities they faced. To be a slave meant to live a doomed life. Negros were not the only ones who were ruined by the institution of slavery, though. Frederick Douglass, an African American social reformer, leader of the abolitionist movement, and former slave, believed that the unnatural means of slavery had harmful effects on everyone within the institution of slavery. Although slaves faced physical, mental, and psychological abuse, slave owners were also degraded and ruined by the institution of slavery, because it distressed slaveholding families, caused warped forms of Christianity with unjust morals to arise, and reduced civil people to fiends through irresponsibility. Through his Narrative and his speeches, Douglass reasoned that if everyone within the institution of slavery was tarnished by it, then it must be unnatural, and therefore a threat to society as a whole that must be removed.

    Read More

  • Has Slavery Changed since Ancient Times?

    928 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the ancient times slavery was a common and normal thing. In 70 A.D it was estimated that there were slaves in Rome. There were no troubles or controversies over it. Slavery was widespread and most families owned at least one slave. Today there is only one real way to become a slave but in Roman Times (rise of Rome) there were three. 1=Slavery due to crime committed. 2=Not being a Roman citizen. 3=Taken prisoner by Romans. An example is war.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Slavery And Slavery

    1356 Words  | 3 Pages

    Slaves and servitude in America have similarities and differences during the 1660s and the 1800s. Both forms of labor are similar, in that you have to work, but are different as servitude is for a certain amount of time, and slaves work until they die. While these two forms of labor can be brutal, servitude as it was punishment, and slaves because they were seen as property, are still different in multiple ways.

    Read More

  • Slavery And Human Trafficking

    1303 Words  | 3 Pages

    Slavery is one of the issues that was, is and has been a major concern in the world. The nature of contemporary slavery is unknown, but estimates show that there are millions of victims of slavery across the globe. Slavery covers a wide variety of human rights violations such as sexual mutilation of men, women and children, child prostitution, sale of orphans, child pornography and many others. On the other hand, human trafficking is an area of concern that involves recruiting, transporting, buying or selling a person by means of force or fraud for the purpose of commercial sexual exploitation or forced labor. Human trafficking deprives the victims of their human rights, and is one of the causes for the spread of sexually transmitted diseases

    Read More

  • Slave Acculturation

    1314 Words  | 3 Pages

    Curtin, Philip D. and Paul E. Lovejoy, ed. Africans in bondage: Studies in Slavery and the Slave Trade. Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1986.

    Read More

  • Slavery and the Anti-slavery Movement

    1030 Words  | 3 Pages

    The act of slavery was widespread around the globe, seen in places like: the Sumerian society; Greece; the central Nigerian Society, Nupe; and of the course, the United States (Ember). Although slavery was common in all of these places, what differed is how the slaves were obtained and maintained. One of the earliest documented history of slavery dates back to 3000 B.C. in the Sumerian society (Ember). Since this society was very complex, slaves were common in Sumer. The slaves were often captives brought back from war. This way of ...

    Read More

  • Slavery : Slavery And Slavery

    1224 Words  | 3 Pages

    The living conditions of Douglass and his fellow slave mates were not the first priority for the slave owners and masters. The slaves slept on what is described as the cold, damp floor every night and had no separate quarters (Douglass 23). Douglass recalls having huge cracks in his feet due to the fridged temperatures in the winter and having nowhere to escape from the elements. Not only did they have to sleep in the cold, they were made to work out in the field with clothing similar to what they wore in the summer months. Masters allotted their slaves a limited amount of food per week and to share between all of them. That small amount of food did not support the nutrition that a hard working slave needed.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Human Trafficking By Noy Thrupkaew

    861 Words  | 2 Pages

    Human trafficking is the act of coercing someone into working against his or her will. Anyone can be a victim, especially young girls who are vulnerable to the captor’s lies. Victims have been found anywhere from driving ice cream trucks to touring boys’ choir. In her talk, Noy Thrupkaew shares several examples about how people are deceived and coerced into coming to the United States and being forced to work for someone else. She focuses on how close to home human trafficking really is and how the victims don’t necessarily need saving but solidarity. In Noy Thrupkaew’s speech about human trafficking, she not only shares her own story but also the different situations regarding how the crime functions. Because the speaker

    Read More

  • Slavery in Ancient Greece and Rome

    1110 Words  | 3 Pages

    Slavery was the practice of taking a human being and making them do the work of another by force. This was practiced through out the ancient world and especially in Rome and Greece. Slaves were nothing more than just property to the ancient peoples. They didn't have the rights of citizens nor were they able to do what they want in most cases. Slaves had many tasks that they had to do, many of which included taking care of the masters house and kids, cooking and cleaning that house, herding the cattle for the farming families, being guards for some prisons, fighting for entertainment of the masses, and more common was sexual activities with the slaves.

    Read More

  • Slavery in Ancient Rome

    1484 Words  | 3 Pages

    The experiences of enslaved women differed from the experience of enslaved men in ancient Rome; slavery within ancient Rome can be traced back to the first century BCE and was based primarily on the chattel slave system. Slavery within the ancient roman society was highly normalised as it was considered a part of roman culture. Slavery within ancient Rome was so heavily normalised that it is considered to be described as a “slave society” Joshel (2010, p. 6) states that “For slaves living in the Roman world, there was no outside – no place without slavery and no movement that declared slavery wrong. Slavery was a normal part of life, and this was true not only for the Romans but for every neighbouring ancient culture”. Not only was slavery considered a normal part of Roman life, but it affected a great proportion of the Roman population. According to historian Walter Scheidel (2007, p. 6) “ There were somewhere between 5 to 8 million slaves in the Roman empire, some 250,000 to 400,000 new slaves were required every year to maintain the numbers”. A majority of these figures were men, children and - women; either being enslaved through birth, kidnapping or captured through war. Roman slaves were not seen as victims nor was slavery considered to be a crime at that time, as slavery was considered to be to a ‘natural law of the nations’ as stated by Joshel (2010, p.6) “For the Roman lawyer, slavery is not a crime, and the enslaved are not victims; rather, as Gaius and other Roman jurists nations. Natural law applies to all animals, not only human beings, but it concerns little more than the union of male and female, procreation of children, and their rearing”. With an estimated 5 to 8 million slaves within the Roman Empire, whether...

    Read More

  • Human Trafficking Essay

    637 Words  | 2 Pages

    Human trafficking is the second most criminal industries in the world that exploits the lives of women and children. They take the children from their home and make them work in horrible condition for hours and pay them little money. The women are some time turn into sex slaves. As stated in Kiener (2012) each year more than 5,000 women and children from Malawi for sex exploitation aboard (p.475). People sometimes put their selves in the situation to get taking, because they are desperately trying to leave their current situation. Even though slavery was banned world wide it still occurs today and millions of people are victims each year. Mam said “people think slavery ended years ago” (as citied in Kiener, 2012, p.475). Human trafficking is thriving and making money almost thirty-two billion dollars a year in profits. Shelley argued growing dramatically since the mid- 1900s, thanks to factors like the ending of the Cold War, disappearing boarders, globalization, economies and growth of international crime syndicates (as citied in Kiener, 2012, p.477). Profits are soaring because prices are so little. The need of slave labor is high and inexpensive. Since there are so many slaves the traffickers do not have to spend money or take care of the slave. The trafficker may dump or killed them.

    Read More

More about Similarities and Differences in Ancient and Modern Slavery

Open Document