Should You Give To The New York's Homeless By Paul Cantor Analysis

1163 Words3 Pages

In the article “I Need a Dollar: Should you give to the New York 's Homeless?”, published on Gawker.com on July 28, 2014, Paul Cantor argues the issue of whether or not you should give money to a panhandler. Like Cantor, I have been approached several times by people asking for money. Often times I wondered, "how did you end up in this situation?” More often than not I find myself leaning towards the negative connotation; that it is their fault they’re in these circumstances. However, I generally feel that I can spare a buck or two. Cantor suggests "maybe nine out of every ten panhandlers are lying." Even if every dollar you hand out goes to something it shouldn 't, what is it really hurting? I agree with Cantor. Americans spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars a year on coffee …show more content…

"I hoped I could just rely on the kindness of people," Roger Blondell exclaims. How can you say no to this man only asking for spare change after you hear his story? This article challenges the reader with questions and dilemmas. Can I go without my daily cup of coffee to offer hope to someone in need? Should I spare this man a dollar if all he plans on doing with it is buy booze or get high with it? Can I actually spare my money? I am sure she’s only homeless because she is addicted to drugs! Cantor did not mention these questions or dilemmas in his article, he didn 't have to. My mind automatically thought of them when remembering past experiences or thinking of my next experience with a panhandler. I believe each reader has developed ideas in their mind as to what actions they will yield in their future experiences. “The decision is ultimately yours to make,” concludes Cantor; I say let’s get these people off the streets, into homes they can afford, and acquire food for them to eat so we don’t have to be concerned with whether or not we desire to spare a little change.

More about Should You Give To The New York's Homeless By Paul Cantor Analysis

Open Document