Science Fiction: Close Encounters of the Third Kind and Independence Day

953 Words2 Pages

The genre of what is called science fiction has been around since The Epic of Gilgamesh (earliest Sumerian text versions BCE ca. 2150-2000). The last 4000 years has evolved science fiction and combined it with all categories of genres comprising action, comedy, horror, drama, and adventure in many different ways. From chest bursting aliens, to robot assassins sent back in time science fiction has successfully captured the imagination of nearly everyone that has been introduced to it. The movies Close Encounters of the Third Kind and Independence Day are both examples of films created with the idea of advanced life existing outside the boarders of our own world. The foundation for each film in view of how extraterrestrial life will affect human affairs, however are very different.

While observing these two movies, excluding the idea of first contact with another intelligent life form from space, these films are not that similar. But there are a couple noticeable resemblances. The first of which is that they both employ a government cover-up. Independence Day’s version of a cover-up played on the real-life superstitions many people have of the secret military installation known only as Area 51, in the film not even the president of the United States was aware of the base or the existence of an alien space ship in the United States possession. Close Encounters of the Third Kind does the cover-up a little differently. After the government isolated the whereabouts of the aliens in Idaho, they had to frighten away the human populace in the area. In the plot, the government let out news that a train carrying canisters of anthrax had crashed, releasing dangerous nerve gas in the area. This proved effective at relocating most of the civil...

... middle of paper ...

...s?" and " Welcome Make Yourselves at Home". Of course, when those people were vaporized, the people’s response rapidly turned to horror and mass panic.

Close Encounters of the Third Kind, a blockbuster film from the 1970’s that utilized drama as a good technique to spread the idea that creatures from beyond our planet could have the healthier qualities of humanity, resembling kindness, compassion, and the pursuit for understanding the universe. However, this plot doesn’t make a thrilling 1990's summer blockbuster. The word of the 1990’s was action, and Independence Day demonstrates that nothing gave quite the movie-going action as planet annihilating, life annihilating aliens. More than likely, differences, however measured, between these films are actually a reflection of the changes in the values of our civilization in the 20 years from the 1970’s to the 1990’s.

Open Document