Scapegoat Mechanism In The Stories Of Joseph Job, And Abraham

931 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Religion and violence

Girard presents the stories of Joseph, Job, and Abraham as examples of the scapegoat mechanism in his writings. Joseph grows up with twelve brothers who resent that their father treats Joseph as the favorite son. Joseph is victimized by his brothers as a result of Jacob’s favoritism and they sell him into slavery in Egypt. This demonstration of non physical violence towards Joseph characterizes him as a scapegoat. The sacrificial victim is chosen from a perceived injustice caused by the brothers’ fears and desires for respect and is intended to bring temporary reconciliation for what is regarded as inequity amongst brothers
In Egypt, Joseph gains a reputation for his dream interpretation. He reaches the pinnacle of his influence by interpreting …show more content…

Just before Abraham kills his son, an angel intervenes and provides a ram for Abraham to sacrifice instead. God tested Abraham’s faith, and Abraham responded with complete trust in God’s message. Abraham reflects the way individuals should approach the violence perpetuated by the scapegoat mechanism; rather than approaching violence with power, God illustrates that the scapegoat mechanism can be interrupted by making the gift of His love effective. It is in Christ’s death, foreshadowed by the sacrifice of Isaac, that the gift of this love is …show more content…

Resisting violence by using a sacrificial victim allows the community to victimize itself and criticize on the basis of an ideology rather than encountering a problem at its root. Accordingly, rallying a group behind a coordinated ideology and identifying a scapegoat as a dissenter creates a sense of prestige around the violence of the community (40). As the violence and victimization become associated with power, the scapegoat will admit guilt without actually being guilty in response to mimetic pressures. The Gospels illuminate the idea that the scapegoat is killed and later falsely idolized as the reason for the reconciliation of the group when, in fact, this sense of peace and unity is temporary. The structure of the Gospels parallels the structure of the myths of sacrifice, beginning with a crisis that results in a collective murder and religious revelation to further reflect the framework for the scapegoat mechanism

Show More
Related

  • Similarities Between Aqedah And Genesis 22

    799 Words  | 2 Pages

    Genesis 22 opens with God calling out to Abraham. Abraham responds, “Here I am!” (Gen 22:1). According to Levenson’s analysis, Abraham is not simply telling God his location but he is conveying “readiness, attentiveness, and responsiveness” (Levenson 67). Similarly, in the Gospel of John, when Jesus responds, “I AM” to the men looking for him, he conveys readiness, attentiveness, and responsiveness (John 18:5). But in addition, Jesus’ reply also expresses his divinity. These words are seen before in God’s call and commission of Moses in Exodus. “I am who I am… This is what you will tell the Israelites: I AM has sent me to you” (Ex 3:14). This is only the beginning of the many parallels these narratives seem to share. Fundamentally, however, Jesus’s passion clearly supersedes the near sacrifice of Isaac.

    Read More

  • Joseph: A Foreshadowing Of Jesus's Life

    372 Words  | 1 Pages

    The life of Joseph could be considered a foreshadowing of Jesus’ life since there are many similarities. Joseph was the prized son of Rachel to Jacob, which optimized the resentment felt towards him from his other ten brothers, whom later sold him to a caravan traveling to Egypt for slavery. Jesus, likewise the promised Messiah, was rejected by his family and community. Neither of their relatives could perceive the significance of these two men nor notice what God was doing with their lives.

    Read More

  • Essay On Spiritual Leprosy

    1763 Words  | 4 Pages

    You can read his story in Genesis, Chapters 37-50. The first note of him concerns his ability to dream and interpret dreams. Joseph was a dreamer and he had a dream. His dream took at least two forms. In one version of his dream he was a sheave of wheat and his family were also sheaves of wheat that had been gathered at harvest and were waiting to be carried in to be stored. In Joseph’s dream, all the other bundles of wheat bowed down to his. In another version of his dream he was a star. Again, his family were also stars and heavenly bodies. Again, all the other stars and heavenly bodies bowed down to his star in his dream.

    Read More

  • Personal Narrative: Life In The Army

    1789 Words  | 4 Pages

    Since time began there has always been conflict. Whether it be religious, race oriented, or conflict over land. Conflicts have lead countries and nations to amass armies. While some armies are small, others may be vast in size. No matter the size of the Army they all have one thing in common… their Soldiers. As Non-Commissioned Officers we would be without a profession if we did not take care of, and retain our Soldiers. Through their mishaps and mistakes it is our job to lead them as they will, hopefully, be taking over our position as they climb the ladder to becoming the next great leader we aspire them to become. However, as in life, there are always trials and tribulations that come with life in the Military. We have all had Soldiers with

    Read More

  • Trials of Jesus and Socrates: A Comparison

    1651 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hall, Gerald. "Jesus' Crucifixon and Death." Academics' Web Pages. School of Theology at McAuley Campus. Web. 26 Feb. 2012.

    Read More

  • The Army Profession

    1238 Words  | 3 Pages

    Webster’s dictionary defines the word profession as a type of job that requires special education, training, or skill. Many Soldiers would not consider the Army as a profession but a way of life. Some think the word profession belongs to everyday jobs like a plumber, mechanic, or doctor. Dr. Don M. Snider stated “the Army is a profession because of the expert work it produces, because the people in the Army develop themselves to be professionals, and because the Army certifies them as such” (Snider, D. M. 2008). In October 2010, the Secretary of the Army directed the Training and Doctrine Command (TRADOC) to lead an Army wide assessment of the state of the Army Profession. We have been at war as a Country for over a decade and the Army wanted to know how to shape the future of the Army as a profession and the effects the past decade had on our profession.

    Read More

  • Writing Styles in the Puritan Time Period

    532 Words  | 2 Pages

    Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God , "The God that holds you over the

    Read More

  • Bible Vs. Koran

    1618 Words  | 4 Pages

    In The Bible, the story of Joseph is a tale about a seventeen year old young man who was the oldest of his fathers' sons. He was also his father's favorite son. Joseph often had dreams which showed him as being a savior for his people. For this reason, he was sold into slavery by his own envious brothers. Joseph went on to make a better life for himself in Egypt, but it was not long before he was thrown into prison after being

    Read More

  • Comparing Relationships Between Gods and Men in Prometheus Bound and Job

    2391 Words  | 5 Pages

    The question of why bad things happen to good people has perplexed and angered humans throughout history. The most common remedy to ease the confusion is to discover the inflicter of the undeserved suffering and direct the anger at them: the horror felt about the Holocaust can be re-directed in the short term by transforming Adolf Hitler into Lucifer and vilifying him, and, in the long term, can be used as a healing device when it is turned into education to assure that such an atrocity is never repeated. What, however, can be done with the distasteful emotions felt about the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Surely the citizens of those two cities did not themselves directly provoke the government of the United States to deserve the horror of a nuclear attack. Can it be doubted that their sufferings were undeserved and should cause deep sorrow, regret, and anger? Yet for the citizens of the United States to confront these emotions they must also confront the failings of their own government. A similar problem is found in two works of literature, Aeschylus' Prometheus Bound and the book of Job found in the Tanakh. In each of these works a good man is seen to be suffering at the hand of his god; Prometheus is chained to a rock by Zeus who then sends an eagle to daily eat Prometheus' liver while Job is made destitute and brought to endure physical pain through an agreement between God~ and Satan. To examine the travails of these two men is to discover two vastly different concepts of the relationship between god and man.

    Read More

  • Differences Between the Story of Joseph in the Bible and Intricacies in Sura 12 of the Qur’an

    1171 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...e Biblical story weighs heavily on Joseph’s divine dream interpreting ability and the story it provides, focusing on the theme of God caring for His people and fulfilling his divine plan. The Qur’an appreciates this but sees it as a means to the end of the spread of faith to non-believers. The Christian and Jewish version of Joseph’s trials serves a greater literary purpose than the Qur’an’s version, advancing belief by showing God’s abilities and the way they may be manifested in others in order to fulfill his divine plan. However, the Qur’an expands upon the Biblical version by including additional plot points and explicitly portraying Joseph’s goals and how they align with Islamic theology. The accounts differ in functionality, but both are crucial to the holistic understanding of the story of Joseph and some of the fundamental differences between the religions.

    Read More

  • Soren Kierkegaard's Fear And Trembling

    958 Words  | 2 Pages

    Is Abraham's decision to sacrifice Isaac faith or murder? According to Kierkegaard, an action is "to be judged by the outcome (Kierkegaard, 91)." One has to know the whole story before choosing a side to support. In Abraham's story, Isaac is not sacrificed. God appears to Abraham and tells him that he can sacrifice an animal instead of his son. In continuation, Kierkegaard shows that a hero, whom has become a skándalon to his generation and is aware that he is in the middle of an incomprehensible paradox, will cry out defiantly to his contemporaries, "The future will show I was right (Kierkegaard, 91)." According to Kierkegaard, those who talk and think like him live secure in their existence. They have a solid position because they understand that everything can only be judged by the end result. These people can be seen as sure prospects in a well-ordered state. "Their lifework is to judge the great, to judge them according to the outcome (Kierkegaard, 91)."

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Holy Bible: The Parable Of The Prodigal Son

    1522 Words  | 4 Pages

    Jesus told “The Parable of the Prodigal Son" to the religious and the Jewish crowd there to help them understand that salvation does not come by works, but by the grace of God. The Lord is merciful and forgiving, but you just must be willing to realize your mistake and ask for forgiveness just like the prodigal son had done. The reaction of the crowd when Jesus spoke was most likely extreme upset and outrage, similar to that of the eldest son. Since God is gracious and loving, sinners can return to him with confidence that he will warmly welcome them. A good father only wants what is best for his children, and that is to love and be loved. Most importantly, the parable shows that God’s people should rejoice at the willingness of sinners to turn to God and the willingness of God to receive them. This parable especially exemplifies God’s redemptive grace, mercy, unconditional love and forgiveness. In addition, the author greatly incorporates character analysis to give us a good description and understanding of the parable. By using the prodigal son’s, the father’s, and the elder son’s character as analogies and symbols to compare and contrast to other concrete examples, the reader was able to understand the parable on a deeper level. Unfortunately, the parable ends without revealing what the older son did. The ending can be used as a self-check; if you were in the older brother’s shoes, how would you react? Would you be rejoicing for your younger brother’s return or would you allow the bitterness and resentment of your father’s reaction take over

    Read More

  • Joseph, The Prophet Analysis

    1003 Words  | 3 Pages

    The story of Joseph, the prophet is a pivotal cornerstone for two of the three major Abrahamic religions. In it, both Judaic and Islamic followers have crafted a story which establish God’s ability to intervene and protect his resolute followers. Throughout time, both parties have diverged on the fundamentals of this story to benefit their definition of faithfulness. As such, Both Islamic and Judaic faiths have crafted a story in which the view of God, Joseph, and the other characters present a significant example of the power of God and Allah.

    Read More

  • Character Analysis Of The New Boy

    974 Words  | 2 Pages

    Joseph as an individual started as a lost, depressed individual with no insight on what is happening in his life which leads to constant flashbacks to his father. The loss of Joseph 's father pointed out the feeling of how many children across this world might feel especially in places where conflict and war are still existent. This story did have a little bit of the plot focused on racism but the idea of being new and unique dominated the

    Read More

  • Essay On Military Experience

    890 Words  | 2 Pages

    An opinion is the formulation of personal experiences. After my four year career in the U.S Army, I can officially profess that I am one combat veteran out of very few. During my time on active duty it was constantly mentioned how only one percent of the nation’s population serves in the military. In stark contrast, the U.S has one of the best military defense yet only attracts one percent of its citizens. There must be reason for this, which led me to revise my priorities during my tour. Living in the lifestyle of a U.S soldier molded my perception on what is truly important, which is education. Education is a tool that may enable a person (such as I) to jump through the hoops of generational poverty into a life of stability. This is a component

    Read More

More about Scapegoat Mechanism In The Stories Of Joseph Job, And Abraham

Open Document