Rosemarie Garland Thomson's Extraordinary Bodies

761 Words2 Pages

In her 1997 article “Extraordinary Bodies: Figuring physical disability in American culture and literature” Rosemarie Garland Thomson explores the spectacle that was the 19th and 20th-century freak show. According to Thomson, the American freak show served as a “figure of otherness upon which spectators could displace anxieties and uncertainties about their own identities” (Thomson). The stars of the show were seen as freaks of culture, often crippled by medical deformities that left them on the periphery of society (Thomson). It was these spectacles that gave the American people one collective identity, helping distance themselves from the “anarchic body” that was being paraded. (Thomson). Although the traditional model of the freak show met its death in the 1950s, the Jim Rose Circus managed to successfully reinvent the spectacle for a 21st-century audience. During the era of P.T. Barnum, the stars of the freak show were those that were visibly deformed, the more extraordinary their disability, the more successful of an act they were (Thomson). Thomson notes that eventually the extraordinary moved from “portent to pathology”, the freaks of the 19th and 20th-century became the medical specimens of the 21st-century (Thomson). As moral values shifted in modern day society, Rose …show more content…

Barnum; perhaps the most notable was the different treatment of the performers. In Rose’s shows the “freak” is celebrated, not necessarily an object to be marveled at, but a subject that can be a source of joy and entertainment. Thomson makes clear in her article that the value of the “freak” stayed the same whether or not they were alive or dead, that their bodies became pure text to be read by the audience (Thomson). Rose’s show cannot maintain its success if his performers are covered in glass and made to be a display, he relies on the interaction with the audience to conjure a repulsion that turns to

Open Document