Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Transgenderism in sport
Transgenderism in professional sports
Transgender restroom issue
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Transgenderism in sport
What would it be like to walk into a public restroom or locker room, and see someone of the opposite sex? Probably a little alarmed or confused. How would it feel like to be denied the bathroom of the sex you unwillingly identify with? Unfair and singled out one would assume. Both of these questions must be asked when the debate over transgender people and public bathrooms takes place. One side believes a person must use the bathroom which corresponds to their gender given at birth. The other side thinks a person should be able to use whichever restroom they wish, as long as they identify with that gender. Like many other debates in our world today, there is no correct answer to this question, and there is no clear solution. The subject of …show more content…
This is true for Galvin who was denied use of the men’s restroom after two incident-free months. Galvin, a transgender male student, claimed “he is not making a ‘choice’ any more than a gay or straight student chooses his or her sexual orientation” (Sanchez). If laws can be made to support and benefit the gay community, then there should be no problem doing the same for transgenders in this case. In fact, Mary Sanchez, a writer for the Kansas City Star newspaper, explains that many schools around the country are making attempts to open up to their transgender students and help other members of the school understand their situations. The more educated people are the better off this situation will be. Another factor in restricting the use of gender identity when choosing a bathroom is the singling out of these individuals. Looking back on Galvin’s case shows that he was required to use the bathroom in the nurse’s office (Sanchez). This may have caused inconveniences or even been embarrassing for Galvin, and it all could have been prevented if he was allowed to use the men's restroom. The article “Transgender People and Bathroom Access”, a post on the “National Center for Transgender Equality”, confirms that it would be quite troublesome to require separate bathroom in public facilities. It also “reinforces the idea …show more content…
There is no better example of this than what happened in a Seattle swimming pool in February of 2016. After the conclusion of a girls swim team practice, many of the girls became very startled when they saw a young man casually sitting in their locker room. This man, who dress and presented himself as male, was asked to leave the pool. He told the pool staff “the law has changed and I have a right to be here” (qtd in Rhoads). He was not wrong though, because the state of Washington gives people the right to use the bathroom of which they identify with (Rhoads). This is obviously a situation that needs to be avoided, but without clear laws people are able to bend the rules. Later on the pool admitted that they had no rules on how a person would distinguish their gender, and that they “relied on people's physical appearance or verbal claims” (Rhoads). Theoretically this form of assessment would be quite simple, but at the same time it could seriously offend many transgender people. Rhoads points out that many women reject the modern stereotypes set by society, and he cautions that “it can be impossible to guess the gender identity of someone who is biologically female but mannish in appearance”. So perhaps physical appearance may not be the best way to sort out the bathroom room issue. But even if
The question as to which bathroom transgender people should use has been a huge debate over the last few years. Some people claim they should use the bathroom of whatever gender they identify with while others claim this will result in them harassing cisgender people using the bathroom and that instead transgender people should use the bathroom according to their assigned gender at birth. Another solution that is often suggested is to institute a gender neutral bathroom for either just transgender people or for everyone to use. In general transgender men and women are men are simply that: men and women and they should be able to use the bathroom that best correlates with their gender identity.
Controversy has spread and gone around the world for so many years and especially recently. The question bears, should transgendered people use the bathrooms based on their gender that is on their birth certificate or the gender they identify with? Based on many opinions and a lot of stories people debate online or in person whether this should or should not be a thing. Many stories lie with people talking of harassment and other negative situations, yet people still do not agree with some statements. A story from a student follows the lines of the issues dealing with bathroom rights states, “Greenlee is a transgender student, who was born a female, but has taken on a male identity since the beginning of freshman year. ‘I had no bathroom that I could go to,’ Greenlee said. ‘The bathroom that I'm going to now is a storage unit" (koamtv.com). Transgendered people should be allowed to use the bathrooms in which gender they
In order to answer whether transgender children be allowed to use the restroom they identify with I would first like to identify what transgender means. According to Merriam Webster’s dictionary “The Medical Definition of TRANSGENDER.: of, relating to, or being a person (as a transsexual or a transvestite) who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the person 's sex at birth.” I believe the knowing what transgender means is important because there are misconceptions about someone being transgender. This definition is also important as it helps support the pros and cons of my argument. I was confused about transgender individuals before doing research for this paper. However, based on the article “From Jack to Jill:
When a transgender person uses the bathroom that corresponds to their gender identity, it boosts well-being. It is legal to for transgender individuals to use whichever bathroom they feel to be is more beneficial. Many schools and states are trying to appeal this law. When the South Dakota House of Representatives were faced with the option to veto this law they chose to keep the law in place (“South Dakota House”). New York has also reinforced transgender individual’s right to choosing a bathroom (“New York mayor”).
Anton Marino says, “…fueled the unequal treatment of a not just transgender person, but also female, lesbian, gay, and bisexual people. As a result, the use of public workplace restrooms, one of the last spaces segregated on the basis of a sexual binary, has created glaring psychological and physical harms for members of the transgender community. Moreover, because the discrimination faced by members of the transgender community is indelibly connected to the issues of gender and sex, workplace bathroom use and sex-specific workplace attire emphasize how innate identity and the way others perceive the trans-identity are in direct conflict. …Use of a restroom is an inherent part of one’s identity. Thus, transgender individuals’ workplaces have developed into battlegrounds on which the fight for transgender equality has, in large part, been disastrous” (Marino
Recently, in a poorly written article for The Federalist, Mrs. Nicole Russell let her feelings about allowing transgender people in the bathroom that best matches their gender identities known. In her uneducated opinion expressed in “The Sexes: Don’t Put My Five-Year-Old Girl In A Bathroom With A Transgender Boy” Mrs. Russell claims that transgender people should stick to the gender, and by default, the bathroom that was assigned to them at birth.
Many people are arguing over the transgender bathroom situation, even here in our very own school system, Grace Christian Academy. Some say one should use the restroom of his/her biological identity, while others say one should have the right to use the restroom they gender identify with. Now the issue is starting to arise in public and private school systems, since the law now states every school has to have at least one transgender bathroom available on school property. As a parent with a child in your school system, I would like to express my opinion on this matter with you. Even though this is a private Christian school, and I am a Christian myself, I do not see a problem with having a transgender bathroom on school property for multiple reasons. For example,
Furthermore, as there are only male and female identities on the ID cards, and there are only male and female’s washrooms, many transgender people have faced serious insults and discriminations in the public. These serious insults happen almost every day in their life and it has caused severe mental stress on them, which would lead them to have emotional disorders and depressions. They are facing unequally in the public utilities and services. The transgender community should have the right to use the restroom of the gender they identify with or have an alternate choice. Transgender people deserve the right to have access to a comfortable, safe place to go to the restroom just as any other human being. Yes, it could potentially be a dangerous liability, but remember the feelings of the people who live in the wrong body. A safe way for the trans community to use the restroom would be to give the option of a gender neutral facility. The problems that the transgender people are facing are not just some emotional harmfulness; it is some problems and inequalities that would seriously endanger their lives, like health cares and life-threatening behaviors which are caused by the ongoing
If this happens, nobody will know who is telling the truth if the person was a transgender or just pretending or even a person of that actual gender. Another thing will be that the person accused of the crime was just trying to use the public bathroom, and someone does not like their lifestyle choice and that is why they are being accused of sexual harassment. As stated in, The Battle Over Bathrooms: A Solution Without a Problem, “We are also warned about “predatory males” who, sensing an opportunity, will don women’s clothing to prey on innocent and “defenseless” women and little girls in restrooms.” Nobody is going to feel comfortable sending their child or wife to use a public bathroom when transgender people are allowed to use the same one for this reason and many other reasons.
By only giving the choice of using a Men’s or a Women’s bathroom it has further enforced the gender binary: “In the moment that one must choose between two doors—one marked “men” and one marked “women”—the binary construction of gender is never more blatantly enforced” (Herman, 2012, p.25). When someone is presented with only two choices of restrooms, it is enforcing the ideals that those are the only two options a person can be. Also these gender binaries are shaming anyone who does not fit into them. These gender binaries are so normalized and engrained in society that they lead to inadequate bathroom access for transgender people throughout the United States. The trans people are the ones who do not fit society’s gender norms and they are being isolated, because of
The United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) notes, “Discrimination against an individual because that person is transgender is discrimination because of sex in violation of Title VII. This is also known as gender identity discrimination” ("EEOC - Sex," n.d., para. 3). According to Canas and Sondak (2014), many states have adopted legislation that supports transgender people as a protected class. Colorado passed legislation extending protection to transgender people in 2008 (Brinker & Maza, 2014). However, one of the biggest controversies surrounding transgender individuals is which bathroom should they use? Zanin (2009) notes, “bathrooms remain one of the most acceptable gender-segregated spaces in cities which can present problems to those who do not conform to gender norms…” (para. 1). The question, then, is should transgender people use the bathroom that most closely mirrors their biological gender or the gender they identify with? While individual beliefs may vary greatly, legally, there is less of a gray area. This paper will address the recently decided Colorado case involving a transgender six year old child, Coy Mathis, and her fight to use the girls’ bathroom at school. In addition to this, legal issues and implications employers should be aware of will also be discussed.
Gender is seen as a spectrum, and one can fall anywhere on this spectrum. Again, according to Sam Killerman, being transgendered means living "as a member of a gender other than that expected based on sex assigned at birth. " Just because a person is born with male genitalia does not mean they have to be male. There are many different gender identities and gender neutral bathrooms affect more than just Trans people. People who are not transgender also have trouble when it comes to bathrooms.
Being transgender refers to having a gender identity that differs from one’s assigned gender. Therefore, one can be male biologically, but behavior and feelings are of the female gender. In a move to ensure equality of all persons as stipulated in the constitution, there have been discussions mainly targeted at the issue of bathrooms in schools. Transphobia has affected how transgender people relate with other people, and the bathrooms can be used to prevent it at an early age. Also, some other advantages have been identified with unisex bathrooms for instance reduction of bullying and drug abuse in male bathrooms. Transphobia can be reduced by the introduction of unisex bathrooms in both secondary
The issue of gender neutral bathrooms and transgender bathrooms is a hot topic right now in North America. Some people are strongly for it and others are going to great lengths to stop it. The majority of public bathrooms in Canada and The United States of America are gender segregated. Public bathrooms are one of the last places to still be separated by gender. Men and women work with each other, sit next to each other in restaurants, use public pools together, and much more. A bathroom with a locked stall, or single occupancy washrooms with a lock, should not be much different. When the idea was raised by the LGBTQIA*+ community to have transgender bathrooms or gender neutral bathrooms, North America was divided. There were those with no
Recently, there has been an uproar of debates on the topic of gender neutral bathrooms. Most of the debates have had to deal with the LGBTQ+ community trying to use the bathroom they identify with. However, these debates have mainly focused on transgenders, “transgender is a term used to describe people whose gender identity differs from the sex the doctor marked on their birth certificate” (GLADD). There has been several bills that “have been filed in three states to prevent transgender people from using bathrooms consistent with their gender identity” (Tannehill). Kentucky has tried to pass bills that target transgender students, but the bill in Texas and Florida would apply to everywhere (Tannehill). There are many different sides to this