Politicization Of Intelligence Essay
analytical Essay
2328 words
The Politicization of Intelligence in the Korean War The role of intelligence in policy making has always been an ambiguous one. On the one hand, the intelligence community must be independent from policymakers, so the intelligence community can do its job objectively and unbiased. On the other hand, policy depends on intelligence for providing relevant information usable for policy production and implementation (Gookins, 2008). Betts (2002) states that because of this paradox, politicization of intelligence is inevitable. He defines politicization as “to give a political tone or character” or “to bring within the political realms”. Gookins’ (2008) definition is more specific, stating that politicization of intelligence “refers to the influence of partisan, bureaucratic, and personal politics on intelligence analysis”. In this paper it is studied how the strains of intelligence producers and policymakers can express itself in practice. A case study is used to demonstrate this strained relationship. The case that is studied is the lead up to the 1950 Korean War, where intelligence played a crucial role. The research question of this study therefore reads as follows: How did the politicization of intelligence affect the action taken by the US concerning the Korean War in 1950? After a brief analysis of the relevant literature on the politicization of intelligence, the case of the Korean War is outlined. Next, the literature is applied to the case and, lastly, the research question is answered in the conclusion section of this study. The Politicization of Intelligence As mentioned before, it seems that intelligence and policy cannot live with and without each other (Betts, 2002). The intelligence community and policymakers need to ... ... middle of paper ... ...wered by stating that the politicization of intelligence affected the action taken by the US extensively. The decisions taken by Washington concerning the situation in Korea were based completely upon the intelligence they received. It was because of the incomplete and distorted intelligence reports that the US did not prepare for war and, consequently, was taken by surprise when the North Koreans and Chinese attacked. Because of bad intelligence, the Korean War started with thousands of casualties on the side of North Korea and the US. Therefore, it would only be logical to assume that these casualties, or a great deal of them, could have been prevented if the intelligence community had done its job right and remained objective and unbiased, even if that meant an angry General MacArthur. This case illustrates how bad intelligence can have devastating consequences.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the politicization of intelligence affected the action taken by the us concerning the korean war in 1950.
- Analyzes how the politicization of intelligence affected the action taken by the us extensively. the korean war started with thousands of casualties on the side of north korea and us.
- Analyzes how the politicization of intelligence affects the action taken by the us concerning the 1950 korean war.
- Argues that intelligence and policy cannot live without each other. betts (2002) describes the kent and gates models of how intelligence should relate to policymaking.
- Explains how north korea was occupied by communist soviet forces and south korea by right-wing us forces after the second world war.
- Analyzes how the intelligence community and the cia had timely access to warning signs at the tactical, operational, and strategic level, indicating that north korea would start a war with south korea.
Related
- explanatory
- analytical
- argumentative
- The Invasion of Panamaexplanatory essay... Intelligence and Security. Ed. K. Lee Lerner and Brenda Wilmoth Lerner. Vol. 1. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 312-315. Gale U.S. History In Context. Web. 13 Dec. 2011. http://ic.galegroup.com:80/ic/uhic/ReferenceDetailsPage/ReferenceDetailsWindow?displayGroupName=Reference&disableHighlighting=false&prodId=UHIC&action=2&catId=&documentId=GALE%7CCX3403300213&userGroupName=mlin_s_hullhs&jsid=2be90fb974b37f6aca36a57ec3c49ff7
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the invasion of panama is an example of presidential foreign policies that involve america in foreign affairs.
- Describes the panama invasion as the beginning to better decision-making, but had faults of its own, that followed through to the persian-gulf war of 1991
- Explains that the drug enforcement administration, or dea, was facing an uphill battle in its beginning because drug use was less common but more deadly.
- Explains the connection between drugs and arms and terrorism on september 11, 2001. the push force a stop to drug trafficking began when the u.s policy of foreign affairs and interventions changed under reagan.
- Explains that the u.s policy for foreign interventions from 1946-81 was to shift of support for right-wing regimes, and cut off aid to dictatorships. president reagan reversed this by launching operation urgent fury on grenada.
- Cites encyclopedia of the american military: studies of history, traditions, policies, institutions and roles of armed forces in war and peace, by john e. jessup and louise b. ketz.
- Explains that americas, modern u.s. security policy and interventions. encyclopedia of espionage, intelligence and security.
- Explains that knight, judson, and brenda wilmoth lerner's encyclopedia of espionage, intelligence and security. gale u.s. history in context.
- Explains that operation just cause pamphlet was published in american decades primary sources. gale u.s. history in context.
932 wordsRead More - Summary Of Knowing One's Enemies By Ernest Mayanalytical essayThe other 15 accounts show the issues with intelligence analysis. Sometimes the intelligence is tainted and based on preconceived notions or preferences. However, May’s collection points out that most issues are related to interpretation, perception, prejudice, avoidance, outside distractions, and how leaders react to the information. As well, the idea that intelligence agencies are vulnerable to deception and insider threat is a risk, so always retain skepticism and consider the source. Finally, the collection points out that military intelligence collect is very good, yet operations intelligence is not so
In this essay, the author
- Explains that ernest may was born in 1928 and was a history professor, dean, and history department chair at harvard university, until he retired in 1979.
- Analyzes how may's book, knowing one’s enemies: intelligence assessment before the two world wars, takes the reader on a 30-year intelligence adventure the few years prior to the two world wars.
- Analyzes how kahn's u.s. views of germany and japan articulates the need for intelligence collection.
- Analyzes how may's collection points out that most issues are related to interpretation, perception, prejudice, avoidance, outside distractions, and how leaders react to the information. military intelligence collect is very good, but operations intelligence is not so good.
- Explains that organizations should not constantly change their intelligence collection and analysis tactics, but build continuity in their current framework instead.
491 wordsRead More - Tet Offensiveanalytical essayIntelligence failure was one of the main reasons why the Tet offensive happened. The allies undergo a failure of intelligence before Tet, a failure that helped plan the stages for changes in the strategies of the US. The four parts of intelligence are crucial in determining the actions of the enemy. The four tasks consist of collection of information, the analysis of the information, the decision to respond to a warning issued in the analytical stage, dissemination of the order to respond to the field co...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the tet offensive was a major turning point in ending the vietnam war. intelligence failure, johnson's over confidence in the war, and its profound impact on american attitudes about involvement
- Explains that intelligence failure was one of the main reasons why the tet offensive happened.
- Explains that the enemy government goes through great lengths to prevent accurate information from reaching their enemies. general giap, in charge of the nva, began battles in the outlying country away from cities.
- Explains that the intelligence organization was unable to accurately predict the tet offensive on january 30th and 31st 1968.
- Explains that president johnson and the american public were fed false information from general westmoreland and joint chiefs of staff that we were winning the war.
- Explains the fourth stage of intelligence is dissemination of the order to respond to the field commanders. the us military recognizes the lack of engagement and the reduction of communications between the enemy troops as a sign that something may happen around sigon and other major cities.
- Analyzes how the american's were surprised when the vietcong and nva attack due to a failure of the intelligence gathering effort.
- Analyzes how skepticism was pervasive at the white house. the nva and vietcong objectives seemed unrealistic based on the mood of the south vietnamese population.
- Describes how the chicago tribune and many nation newspapers brought the shocking news of the tet offensive to american homes the morning of february 1st, 1968.
- Compares the tet offensive to the battle of the bulge where the german caught the us off guard. the united states almost reverted to isolationism of post wwi.
1044 wordsRead More - Problems, Solutions, and Future of Law Enforcement Intelligenceexplanatory essayThe use of intelligence within law enforcement intelligence agencies is not always perfect. There may be a way to safeguard against the misuse of intelligence processes to assure proper use it at all times, but it has not yet been discovered. The only way that agencies can try and control the misuse of intelligence is to study the historical failures of the past.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the use of intelligence within law enforcement intelligence agencies isn't always perfect. there may be a way to safeguard against misuse, but it's not yet discovered.
- Opines that it is of most importance to protect united states citizens’ right to the freedom of speech.
- Explains that the fifties were a good example of how the government could abuse the law and compromise the freedoms of the citizens. mccarthy was at the spearhead to try and squash out the threat of communism.
- Explains that the extremist movement within the united states is formulated out of citizens that are enraged against improper governmental control.
- Explains that intelligence is a specialization, critical, measurable, rarely seeks publicity, targets organized crime problems that are often ignored by other, and requires attention to detail.
- Explains that intelligence can be lost due to hasty deadlines or lack of analyst present. valuable information on police reports must be processed in order to maintain and file away for possible future use.
- Analyzes the loss of intelligence seen in the drug wars. the wealthy cartels have a great amount of money, which is sometimes overwhelming to some police officers.
- Explains that covert operations are given one of the highest security levels in order to protect the lives of those members of law enforcement that are serving undercover.
- Opines that it is up to the officers in charge to ensure that all members of their unit are properly trained and understand that information that is discovered must be shared with any other agency that needs it.
- Explains that the regional systems sharing system (riss) was designed to encourage the sharing and cooperation process among law enforcement intelligence agencies.
- Explains that the high intensity drug trafficking areas program is a federal program that provides funds to help fight against the drug problems that are the result of drug trafficking.
- Explains that even though these organizations exist, they will not provide the law enforcement agency with intelligence products all the time. software applications are only the storage and presentation arenas for information.
- Explains that criminal intelligence databases and applications help analysts store their information in an easily accessible filing system to retrieve it for later use or to help them share it with other agencies.
- Explains that terroristism is one of the problems that america is facing on an international level, but terrorism also exists on a domestic level.
- Explains that law enforcement agencies face counterfeiting, prostitution, narcotics, organized crime, and many more challenges. the intelligence analysts of the twenty-first century have an outstanding weapon that does not require range practice and doesn't have safety hazards.
- Opines that the future of intelligence is bright as long as we keep heading in the right direction.
- Cites peterson, m.b. intelligence 2000: revising the basicelements.
1456 wordsRead More - Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) a consequence of the Bush Doctrines and the loosely defined nature of the “War on Terror”analytical essayTiffen, Rodney. "The Public Case of War: Australian use of Intelligence and the Case of war in Iraq." In Intelligence and National Security Policymaking on Iraq: British and American Perspectives, edited by James P Pfiffner and Mark Thythian, 106-126. Texas: Manchester University Press, 2008.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that after many months of hibernation, looking at the beautiful world of geopolitics, full of intrigue and confusion, the new emergent threat isis caught their attention.
- Analyzes caroll bogert's statement about human rights in the war on terror - are we safer since 9/11.
- Analyzes how the gao defines terrorism as "politically motivated violence to coerce a government or civilian population" and webster's dictionary defines it as the state of being terrorized or the act of terrorizing.
- Analyzes how president bush defined the enemy as an infinite enemy who poses an opposite view than the followers of the bush doctrines, and the western views.
- Explains that president bush's policy of pursuing nations that provide aid or safe haven to terrorism is a hostile regime. the deployment of troops to iraq was the execution of the bush doctrines.
- Explains that president bush introduced the concept of an 'axis of evil' comprising iraq, iran and north korea, and the administration has reached a crisis point with each nation.
- Analyzes how the war on terror is doing in the global geopolitical theaters scrutinizing the various implementation of this doctrine is in need.
- Opines that despite the common belief and hope under the western eyes of democratizing nations as iraq, they can only be united and sustained by a strong militaristic leadership that presents its own pros and cons.
- Analyzes how the us intervention founded on the loosely defined war "the war on terror" created more chaos, paving the way for rouge groups that were once under the check to challenge the vacant seat of power.
- Analyzes how the bush doctrine with its "war on terror" following the domino theory through fear added to the nation's foreign policies in par with the axis of evil list more and more nations, which the administration perceived as a danger.
- Concludes that the us regional policies of the war on terror are causing more damage than good in their efforts of suppressing the fractions of global terror.
- Concludes that the islamic state in iraq and syria is a result of toppling the domino's of the "war on terror". the us must reconsider its execution of foreign policies in finding the underpinned reason for these radical threats.
- Cites caroll bergert's "reflections on the patriot act, guantanamo, abu ghraib and beyond." our search for security post 9/11.
- Describes bush's speech on terrorism, and clinton’s state of the union address, titled “axis of evil”.
- Explains crotty, william j., davis, eric, and cambridge's domino theory.
- Introduces fuller, james, in america, war and power: defining the state, 1775-2005.
- Describes the gao's report on combating terrorism interagency framework and agency programs to address the overseas threat.
- Cites girdner, eddie j., goldstein, joshua, and moisio. structural setting for global enviornmental politics in a hierarchic international system: a geopolitical view.
- Cites jackson, richard, mcgeough, paul, and manne in their book, "the sheikhs, the u.s. and the future of iraq."
- Cites scheller, bente, and tiffen, rodney. the public case of war: australian use of intelligence and the case of war in iraq.
1624 wordsRead More - Intelligence Collection and Analysisexplanatory essayThis paper will detail how I would explain to my policymaker what the psychological barriers are for intelligence collection and analysis. Next, I will provide an argument as to what types of rigors are needed to improve intelligence analysis making it more reliable. Finally, I will persuade the policymaker to support my argument in order to receive more funding in order to implement the type of improvements I have defined.
In this essay, the author
- Explains how they will explain to their policymaker what psychological barriers are for intelligence collection and analysis. they will provide an argument as to what types of rigors are needed to improve intelligence analysis making it more reliable.
- Explains that analysts face psychological obstacles in four key stages of the analytical process — making judgments, coordinating judgements and confronting organizational norms.
- Explains that expertise prevents imaginative explanation of the gaps from consideration. analysts are blindsided when an anomaly in behavior happens that leads to a surprise.
- Opines that the biggest factor for an analyst is time, which can be resolved by increasing the number of analysts on staff, and receiving more direction from the policymaker.
- Opines that an analyst's mindset and overconfidence would be mitigated by judgments that include an alternative explanation for the same collected evidence.
- Opines that policymakers need to allow additional time, increase analyst-staffing levels, and provide better direction to analysts so that judgments will become sounder.
- Describes the works of george, roger, bruce, james, and richards heuer.
1139 wordsRead More - Morals and Intelligenceexplanatory essayThe morality of secret operations has been questioned since intelligence first began. The President of the United States must decide at the highest level which secret operations should be conducted and which are not ethical. The problem that has happened in the past is that the President has looked at the Director of Central Intelligence as his “personal advisor” when it comes to advising on intelligence affairs (Johnson 292). President Kennedy looked to his brother Bobby when making decisions of national security, and President Reagan set up his personal friend, Walter Clark, as his National Security Advisor.
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the united states must maintain the highest standard of morals during intelligence missions.
- Explains that morals and intelligence are related to finding the right person to conduct a mission. the mossad exploits personnel that work around classified information as well as those in the position to observe the behavior of said personnel.
- Explains that the agent is not allowed to collect, analyze, or disseminate any information that may be incidentally collected on a united states citizen.
- Explains that the president must decide at the highest level which secret operations should be conducted and which are not ethical.
- Explains the problem with secret operations is that sometimes there is only one method to prevent the oppression, injury, or death of many. this objective was a strong motivation for u.s. involvement in vietnam during the 1960s, which most moralists ultimately opposed.
- Opines that a high moral professional and personal standard should be present when accomplishing intelligence missions.
706 wordsRead More - US Foreing Policies: The Power of Knowledgeexplanatory essayIn order to effectively act on a controversial issue or problem, whether in a position of power over others, or simply day to day decision making, it is often essential to advancement when making decisions to gather information relevant to the decision before acting. This lesson can be learned from issues throughout the Cold War era, and used in today’s political tension and riots that are currently raging in Egypt. During the Cold War, there were incidents where United States (U.S.) intelligence could have saved many soldiers their lives, whether they were American, Cuban, or Vietnamese. Three key events in the Cold War cost lives, and aided in wrongful decision making. These events were the failed Bay of Pigs invasion, and the vague Gulf of Tonkin incident. The third event, however, demonstrates the superiority that comes with Gathering information before acting on it, and is the tense time of the Cuban Missile Crisis.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that it is essential to advance when making decisions to gather information relevant to the decision before acting on a controversial issue or problem.
- Explains that the bay of pigs invasion was a prime example of where u.s. intelligence, if appropriately gathered, could have saved people’s lives.
- Explains that lyndon johnson was able to launch america in war because of the gulf of tonkin resolution, developed because a u.s. destroyer was shot down by north vietnamese torpedo boat.
- Explains how the u.s. intelligence was crucial to the advancement and protection of the united states in the cuban missile crisis.
- Opines that the lessons learned during the cold war can still be used to avoid conflicts, resolve situations, and find a solution.
- Opines that gathering information beforehand can be used to avoid conflicts. the gulf of tonkin incident, and the bay of pigs invasion prove how problems can occur internationally without gathered information.
1168 wordsRead More - Intelligence Failures: 9/11 and Pearl Harborexplanatory essayThroughout history there are multiple intelligence failures such as 9/11 and Pearl Harbor. These failures are due to intelligence collected which was either delayed or misdirected to the rest of the intelligence community. Both events had catastrophic consequences and yet these tragic events has allowed the intelligence community to develop better security like warning signals and combat readiness to protect the United States. Pearl Harbor is still considered one of the worst intelligence failure in the history of the United States to date. During the upcoming months before the attack the U.S Naval Fleet intercepted and deciphered vast amounts of encrypted messages from Japan’s Imperial Navy. Due to manpower and at the time Japan being perceived as not a threat intercepted messages were disregarded or were delayed in being read. “The United States did not perceive the Japanese ability to attack the United States Naval Fleet at all and thus to bring the U.S into war- a step in which logically appeared to be a gross strategic miscalculation, as it indeed was” (Grabo, 2004). But ...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that 9/11 and pearl harbor were the worst intelligence failures in the history of the united states. the u.s naval fleet intercepted and deciphered encrypted messages from japan's imperial navy.
- Explains that the united states had very little signit intelligence, humint or imint intelligence because overflights of soviet territory were impossible. as the cold war raged on, the intelligence community along with working in tandem with the u.s government started to develop better technology.
- Opines that as wars rage on technology will become more advanced. the united states military and intelligence community also showed their ability to adapt to different situations.
541 wordsRead More - Non Coercive Interrogation Analysisargumentative essayInterrogation Ethics in the Context of Intelligence Collection is written by Michael Skerker. This chapter mainly discussed the ethics of coercive and non coercive interrogations. Non-coercive interrogations is primarily based on oral tactics (i.e., direct questioning, self questioning), deceitfulness, and trickery. Coercive interrogations uses threats and force in order to get honest confessions from a detainee. Both interrogations technique help with protecting the United States from harm and terrorist acts. In chapter ten, Guarding against Politicization: A Message to Analysts is composed by Robert M. Gates. It generally explained that roles of the intelligence managers and analyst in politicization. Chapter eleven, Memorandum: One Person
In this essay, the author
- Opines that the intelligence agency based their actions on the information they have gathered, while policy makers depend on what the people need or what they think the right thing to do.
- Concludes that the government is a huge influence in the people's perspective. the intelligence community gets the blame on the immoral methods of protecting their country.
- Concludes that the intelligence agency is composed of many personnel with a goal of protecting their citizens and upholding the national security.
- Analyzes the ethics of coercive and non-coerced interrogations in the context of intelligence collection.
884 wordsRead More