Orestes Brownson engaged in open opposition of Horace Mann’s vast reform policies of the Massachusetts State Board of Education. He directly opposed Mann’s work in Massachusetts on the formation of a centralized, state run school board on the grounds that state power over the educational process would result in biased and undemocratic instruction lending favor to one political interest group or another. In addition Brownson held the belief that the state normal schools which were conceived and vehemently supported by Mann would produce teachers well informed in pedagogic methodology, while nearly uninformed in the area of academic concepts beyond the scope of elementary education.
Horace Mann served as the first secretary to the Massachusetts
…show more content…
These schools were intended to be universal and state funded, making use of normal schools to train teachers especially suited to imparting education within the given state system. While these normal school trained volkschule and vorschule teachers within the Prussian schools were indeed superior to their American contemporaries, the problems with pedagogic training were not ignored, even by Mann. “The secretary was not completely oblivious to the dangers inherent in using institutions designed for an authoritarian society as models for a democracy, but he quickly dismissed them as inconsequential.” ( Tozer, S., & Senese, G. (2009) p.65) “If Prussia can pervert the benign influences of education to the support of arbitrary power, we surely can use them for support and perpetuation of republican institutions.” (Mann, H. (1844) p.23).
The application of Prussian derived normal schools set in motion a series of obviously undemocratic trends that resulted in some extent to under educated teachers. Within the new system of common schooling, what was compulsory to the unique education of an educator was the minimum academic knowledge within elementary curriculum to be taught and extensive training related to instructional mechanics and pedagogy. These were criticized as “…training technicians but not educating scholars…” ( Tozer, S., & Senese, G. (2009)
Horace Mann, the Father of American Public Education, politician, and educator who promoted educational success for the poor as well as the wealthy as a means of making America a more stable, competitive county wrote twelve annual reports during his tenure as Massachusetts Secretary of Education. Fourth Annual Report of the Board of Education Together with the Secretary of the Board 1841 The Indispensable Teacher and published ____ . More familiarly known as The Indispensable Teacher Mann’s fourth annual report voices his concerns with the present status and improvements to public education.
Many Americans do not question the credibility of the education system within the country because they believe it forms good citizens and creates a stepping-stone to success. John Taylor Gatto is an American teacher who has experience in the classroom for thirty years and has now devoted his life to critiquing American schools exploiting his own experiences. In his essay “Against School”, he argues that the 12-year system of school may not be necessary, due to its curriculum, and that it may be a tactic of manipulation from the government to promote obedience. I agree with his argument because there are many paths to individual success outside of public education, such as homeschooling or vocational school.
An institution that is large has a group of individuals or situations that shapes what it becomes. Without a doubt the American education system has had multiple examples that have shaped what it is today. There have been individuals that have placed emphasis such as Mann that brought the common school concept to light. In addition, there were landmark court cases that allowed minorities to also receive equal educations. Furthermore, there has been strong political influence over the years of American education development. This paper will focus on the importance of Horace Mann, John Dewey, the Science and Math Education Movement, and the No Child Left Behind Act.
Germany was now being led by Adolf Hitler, a high school drop out who aspired to become an artist and was strongly anti-intellectual. Before Hitler, German universities had been considered some of the best in the world, but under Hitler’s rule, many young people living in Nazi Germany where very hard behind their peers from other western countries. Western education became secondary to teaching the youth mysticism, speculation and collective thinking toward a common goal and of course, the pursuit of a glorious future for Germany.
In early Roman literature, some writers contrasted the life living in urban Rome with the life living out in the countryside. Horace gives a much more positive view of the country, as in the story of the country mouse, Horace writes, “The hayseed gasps, ‘This life I don’t need, goodbye! My woods and cave will guard me from all snares, and plain vetch will be my consolation’” (Horace, 2.6.115-17). Horace contrasts the idyllic, simple life in the country to the bustling city of Rome. The city mouse promises the country mouse more food in the city than he can imagine, but the mice end up going back to the country after being scared by loud noises and dogs. This signifies that however promising the city may seem, the comfortable life of the country is much preferable. Also, Horace’s preference for the country in prominent in his Satire 1.9, such as when the bore states, “I’ll work for you, I can be a great second player and take the minor roles, just make some contacts for me, that’s all. I’ll bet my life you’ll outdo everyone you know” (Horace, 1.9.45-48). The poet then tells the bore that he doesn’t understand how poetry is done and implies he is shallow and annoying. In his satire featuring the poet and the bore, the bore asks to see
Jeynes, William. American Educational History: School, Society, and the Common Good. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications, 2007.
This practice certainly left some students without specific representation in a time when denominational clashes were commonplace. Additionally, Mann’s new system of central school board control over appropriate curriculum books and material took local decision making power and commandeered it, taking along with it the power of local influence within the arena of formal education. This was perhaps the most extreme measure against democratic procedure and social mobility, and was considered later to be an attempt at hindering basic social liberties. “We object also to the sanction of the school board because it is an approach to a censorship of the press.” (Brownson, O. 1840). Censorship in schools showed students nationwide only what the centralized board deemed appropriate, however this method was not practical at a local level, from either a social or economic
The Prussian vision of education depicts many reasons a student does not develop his/her career. They are being tamed without them knowing it, and also they are being forced to follow authorities’ steps. When following these steps the student leads to consumerist and fails in intelligence. The competitive world would have been better to follow another vision, a vision that supports education and that really demands intelligence rather than knowledge like Thomas Jefferson’s model.
Labaree discusses how the United State’s education is in a school syndrome, as people in America want schools to teach society’s ideals as well as let people express their individuality. These two demands are polar opposites that cannot be achieved. As the focus goes towards balancing these in hopes of improving society as a whole, the bettering of actual student learning is put on pause. Labaree talks about the beginning of education reform, in the 19th century, being the most successful in developing society; however, as education reform continued throughout time, its effectiveness wore off. He then addresses how the desire for education reform is more about improving society than it is about learning. He finishes his argument by providing possible solutions to fixing this problem, but states that fixing this problem will never happen because no one is willing to give up both demands. Overall, Labaree goes in wonderful detail explaining the problems of education reform. What made me choose this article was that he addressed the desire that people have on school systems in promoting both society normality and individuality. This correlates well with my topic in whether public school systems promote conformist ideals or individuality.
Teacher Unions are one source of controversy in Education because of how it seems that Teacher Unions have allowed poor performing teachers to remain. In “The Teacher Wars”, it articulates, “Teacher Union movement was (and remains today) a pragmatic, even sometimes
In John Gatto’s essay “Against Schools” he states from experience as a school teacher that are current educational system is at fault (148). He claims that classrooms are often filled with boredom manufactured by repetitive class work and unenthusiastic teachings. Students are not actively engaged and challenged by their work and more often than not they have either already covered the concepts taught in class or they just do not understand what is being taught to them. The children contained in classrooms have come to believe that their teachers are not all that knowledgeable about the subjects that they are teaching and this advances their apathy towards education. The teachers also feel disadvantaged while fulfilling their roles as teachers because the students often bring rude and careless attitudes to class. Teachers often wish to change the curriculums that are set for students in order to create a more effective lesson plan, but they are restricted by strict regulations and consequences that bind them to their compulsory teachings (148-149). An active illustration of John Gatto’s perspective on our educational system can be found in Mike Rose’s essay “I Just Wanna Be Average” (157). Throughout this piece of literature the author Mike Rose describes the kind of education he received while undergoing teachings in the vocational track. During Mike’s vocational experiences he was taught by teachers that were inexperienced and poorly trained in the subjects they taught. As a result, their lesson plan and the assignments they prepared for class were not designed to proficiently teach students anything practical. For example, the curriculum of Mike Rose’s English class for the entire semester consisted of the repeated reading of ...
Conant is responsible for having most of the Prussian education system in most of US high schools like the nine months of school years, and the attendance of thousands of students that go to the same high school (Gatto 36). The Prussian’s system wanted to manipulate a person’s abilities to favor the government, to damage the students’ critical thinking by implying their own standard to create a governable society (Gatto 36). The standardized testing leaves students who didn’t have a good score in the test to be placed in low-level classes. Gatto says that government 's purpose is to assign a group of people to complete the mission of watching over and controlling a society whose expectations are low so that the government can lead without being challenged or questioned (37). In that case, parents and teachers should work together to encourage every student to do their best to not let the government put a hold on their dreams and
Commonly referred to as the Gilded Age, the end of the nineteenth century was a period of social issues and political unrest. Following a period of Reconstruction after the Civil War, the Gilded Age was ridden with problems surrounding the countries recovery. Presidents such as Ulysses Grant and Rutherford Hayes were viewed fraudulent and incompetent leaders for the nation. Meanwhile, Congress was mostly ruled by large enterprises, allowing for little political representation of the masses. Additionally, the nation was plagued by an overwhelming amount of social issues including child labor, immigration, women and minorities, and rapid urbanization. Overpopulation was particularly troublesome for the state of democracy as most voters were
John Taylor Gatto, who was a teacher at the public school for twenty-six years, and the writer of the essay “Against School” that first appeared in Harper’s magazine in 2001, censures and blames the American public school’s educational system in his argumentative essay with various convincible supporting ideas. Gatto argues that the demands of public education system’s schooling are essential problems in “Against School”. Gatto shows some positive examples of the educating without forced schooling and shows models of the ‘success without forced modern schooling’. Indeed, the writer insists that historically forced schooling is not related to intellectual and financial success in American history. James Bryant Conant, who was the twenty-third
Illich argued that whilst schools have become recognised as the institution which specialises in education, he saw the role of schools as a tool of social control, spreading existing political ideologies and preserving the status quo of society (1971). Ideology was maintained through teachers who took on a powerful role, dictating how and what was taught to their students. It was common belief that education could only be supplied by a properly qualified person (1971). This attitude is what Illich used to support his theory that schools have become bureaucratised. To further this notion, Illich made a distinct difference between schooling and learning. Schooling was related to bureaucracy and teaching, and learning occurred independent of the former (1971). This idea is easily understood if one considers where most of their learning occurs – outside of school, during daily life experiences and encounters with other people.