One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest Comparison Essay

1111 Words3 Pages

Ken Kesey’s tragicomedy One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest has more in common with Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 than seen at first glance. Both follow the plights of characters in a perilous setting trying to prove or disprove their own sanity. The difference comes from their characters, tone and themes.In One Flew Over Randle McMurphy transfers into a ward run by an over controlling megalomaniac known as Nurse Ratched. Over the story, McMurphy attempts to give the inmates their freedom back by returning to them their manhood in a variety of coming of age activities while also battling for autonomy from the overwhelming control of the Big Nurse Ratched. In Catch-22 the main character Yossarian tries to prove his own insanity while fighting in the air …show more content…

Both books depict themes of mental illness but, where they differ is their take on events. Even in their desperate situation and the ultimate ending McMurphy succumbs to, the tone of One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest is always subverted by comedy whereas Catch-22 takes a more serious take on the events described. The latter is arguably the more popular and effective of the two as most critics agree that the symbolic and comical nature of One Flew Over trumps the other and provides a look into the psyches of multiple emasculated, schizophrenic patients looking for escape. In One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest Ken Kesey utilizes the styles of characterization, symbolism and point of view in order to develop his themes on masculinity as related to autonomy as well as the effects of mental illness which improves the quality of his

Open Document