Montessori vs. Traditional Education

1145 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: 3 basic elements of the montessori approach to education

Education is very important especially in this day and age. What school one attends and how they perceive school to be is a huge factor in one’s life success. There has been research done in the past few years proving that students who receive a Montessori education will prosper academically more so than those who receive a traditional education (Ryniker and Shoho, 2001). Traditional schools typically follow teacher based philosophies and the Montessori education is student centered. On average, children enjoy student based philosophy classrooms. Therefore, they are much more in tuned to what they are learning and that benefits their educational career. Having fun while learning is the key to keeping children engaged.

Maria Montessori was the founder of the Montessori educational method. Maria Montessori graduated from the University of Rome Medical School and was working with “mentally deficient” children (Scotty, 2009). She always had a great aspiration to help children. The Montessori methods came about from her observations while working at the Casa dei Bambini (a daycare center in Rome). She saw how children learn naturally by things around them. Maria Montessori believed that children learned best by doing things individually and teaching themselves (Lewis, 1992). In Montessori schools children learn to deal with real life problems and how to overcome life’s obstacles. The teachers provide the children with freedom and independence.

There are basic Montessori methods. They are: The teacher must pay attention to the child, rather than the child paying attention to the teacher, the child proceeds at his/her own pace in an environment controlled to provide means of learning, and Imaginative teaching materials are the hear...

... middle of paper ...

...o receive a Montessori education will succeed academically and will know how to handle real life situations more so than those who receive a traditional method of teaching.

Resources

Kramer, R., Maria Montessori. Retrieved November 18, 2009 from the World Wide Web.

Lewis, J.J, Maria Montessor. Retrieved November18 ,2009 from the World Wide Web.

Ryniker, D.H., and Shoho, A.R., Student perceptions of their elementary classrooms: Montessori vs. Traditional Environments.

Sadker, D.M., Sadker, M.P., and Zittleman, K.R.,(2008) Teachers, Students, and Society (8th ed.).New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Schapiro,D., New Study Finds Success for Public Montessori Program.

Scotty, J., What is Montessori? Retrieved November 18, 2009 from the World Wide Web.

Wendy, R. (2006). Culture, Race, Diversity: How Montessori Spells Success in Public Schools.

Show More
Related

  • Montessori Eduacation Approach

    883 Words  | 2 Pages

    Watching a small child discover how to operate his or her favorite plaything is awe inspiring. The look of wonder at the item as it's carefully chosen from amongst their belongings and studied ever so carefully for each and every nuance. How that little face lights up with each new discovery no matter how large or small. The sounds of delight an even dismay at an unwanted result are beautiful. Consider an educational system that would continue to utilize a child’s natural curiosity, unyielding ingenuity and thirst for knowledge. Montessori education creates that environment for children by allowing them the freedom to not only gain knowledge in a natural progression, but also provide a basis on which to continue to grow no matter where future educational paths lead.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Powell And Montessori

    501 Words  | 2 Pages

    They soon come to realize that their having a hard time and they only way they know when this is happening is to act out and hope they will get the attention and the help that they are craving. On the other hand, Montessori’s view on structure is the total opposite of Powell’s. Montessori goes to say that “Let us have endless patience with his slow progress, and show enthusiasm and gladness to his success,” meaning that we should just let kids take their time with the experience until they are finally able to understand it for themselves. She uses the words like patience to show that when dealing with children it takes patience. People can't just come up and rush the learning process. Children need to learn for themselves, even if it takes a long

    Read More

  • The Montessori Theory

    753 Words  | 2 Pages

    An educator is to provide a specially prepared environment that promotes activities that aid children in the teaching of themselves (Larson, 2010). They are to conduct this Montessori practice by being responsive to the children’s interests and needs. Once there are educational activities that relate to the children’s interests, the children are able to develop focus and concentration for sustained periods of time. As a result, educators are to be responsive and plan for extended, uninterrupted periods for the children to work (Larson, 2010). The teacher 's goal is to guide and support the children, allowing them to develop confidence and independence (Edwards, 2002). There are no formal lessons in the Montessori pedagogical practice; however there are intentional teachable moments. The educator waits and observes children, allowing them to explore concepts and materials before assisting the child and moving them to the next stage of development (Lillard & Else-Quest, 2006). These teachings are often in a small group setting or one-on-one and consist of the educator modelling an activity or material and build on the initial interest so that the children will later use that material independently (Feez,

    Read More

  • Development of the Montessori Method

    3902 Words  | 8 Pages

    The paper I prepared begins with a description of the Montessori Method and a historical narration of the professional career of Dr. Maria Montessori. I also included some biographical information as to her origins and the identity of her parents. I then drew a comparison of her methods for developing the Montessori Method and her career to the ISD model. I compared significant events in her career to the analysis phase. Explaining that her experience with children lead her to develop her programs. Then I drew a comparison to her work with the design and development phases, citing her materials that she uses in her classrooms and the classrooms themselves. Finally I compared her implementation and subsequent discoveries to the implementation and evaluation phases in ISD. I concluded with my own personal opinion, that Maria Montessori was an innovator and mostly responsible for modern education. I used four directly quoted sources, one solely paraphrased, and one merely for research and background information.

    Read More

  • Waldorf Education Essay

    1552 Words  | 4 Pages

    Rudolf Steiner (1861-1925), was an Austrian scientist and philosophic, his was established new forms of architecture. Steiner Waldorf schools provide a distinctive form of education that fosters personal and social development not just the mind, but the soul, body, and spirit as well, believing that the cognitive, social behavioral, and emotional, and based on the view of the child as a spiritual being. Maria Montessori (1870-1952), She was the first woman to practice medicine in Italy. She is a medical doctor and anthropologist, opened the first Casa dei Bambini (not “school” but “house of children”) in Rome, Italy in 1907. Montessori worked with children with learning difficulties and from this experience, she became the head of a state

    Read More

  • The Montessori Method

    1359 Words  | 3 Pages

    Education is a constantly changing industry that has adapted throughout history and continues to adapt. America’s current public education system, however, has stayed static and dissatisfactory despite many attempts to reform how children are taught. One of the most progressive attempts to reform education has been the Montessori Method. The Montessori Method is a type of schooling that encourages children to be eager to learn on their own through hands-on learning. There are specific materials and structures that the Montessori Method uses. This specific method is based on the observation of the development of children’s minds and environments that they learn and grow best in. Although it is more common for American children to go to public

    Read More

  • Maria Montessory´s Methods and Theories

    600 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...or a child’s natural psychological development. Although a range of practises exists under the name “Montessori”, the Association Montessori International (AMI) and the American Montessori Society (AMS) cite these elements as essential.

    Read More

  • Two Key Perspectives Of Physical Development: Arnold Lucius Gesell

    1338 Words  | 3 Pages

    Maria Montessori was born in Italy in 1870 and influenced childcare massively in the 20th century. Montessori believed that children learn best through using their hands. She felt that one of the main factors that contributed to the child’s development was the ‘prepared’ environment. Children learn through exploration and the adult’s role is to create an environment where they can do

    Read More

  • Maria Montessori: Italian Physician and Educator

    837 Words  | 2 Pages

    The first woman that became an acceptation concerning women and education was Maria Montessori. Thinks to Maria Montessori and her efforts in education, women all over can be inspired to achieve an education in any area that they aspire. The reason why Montessori is so important is because of her philosophy that children should be taught and treated respectfully. “Perhaps this stemmed, in part, from her school experiences”.4 When Montessori was a child, she developed this way of thinking that grownups should respect kids, after overhearing a teacher talk about her. As she became older and wiser, in 1896, Montessori achieved one of her greatest accomplishments by becoming the first woman to earn an MD in Medicine. Montessori was a caring person and wanted to dedicate her time to both educating and assisting kids, specifically special needs children. This led her to start working with special-needs students, “developing principles that would promote the achievement of disenfranchised children”. Finally, after a prosperous journey, Montessori opened the "Casa dei Bambini" in Rome in 1907, a school for –After achieving such great success, Montessori would become a two time Pulitzer Prize winner.

    Read More

  • Aistear: High/Scope and Montessori Pedagogical Methods

    1561 Words  | 4 Pages

    ... such a manner that its curriculum framework is open to interpretation enough to be adapted to most if not all child-centered early years educational approaches. Montessori has a structured curriculum, which while not as flexible as High/Scope can still adapt to Aistear’s framework into their own set curriculum using already established Montessori exercises. In addition, Montessori and High/scope both share an emphasis on the importance of the prepared environment for the children, which is in accordance of Síolta, without which the Aistear framework cannot be successfully undertaken.

    Read More

  • Difference Between Dewey And Dewey

    1019 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first difference between John Dewey and Maria Montessori’s approach to education and the impact they had in the sector lies in the scope of operation. Dewey appears to perceive it on a much larger scope, bringing the entire life of the student in school, under its purview. On the other hand, Maria Montessori approaches education strictly from the perceptive of classroom learning. Montessori developed a new training perspective for children that focused on

    Read More

  • Mini Audit

    638 Words  | 2 Pages

    In preparing my analysis, I considered evidence from several sectors: student data, teacher observation, administrative interviews, artifacts and memoranda from training, published curriculum and research, student work samples, and personal experience. Many of the resources I used to form a conclusion can be found in the appendices of this paper.

    Read More

  • Essay On Montessori Education

    502 Words  | 2 Pages

    Montessori education “is a unique educational approach that nurtures a child’s intrinsic desire to learn. Montessori school system was created by Maria Montessori in the 1900s. “There are more than 5,000 Montessori schools in the US, and around 600 in the UK, where they are privately funded.”(5) Montessori focuses on the whole child his cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development.”(4) Montessori schools creates the child to be more confident and motivated all on their own the children use materials in the classroom to learn by manipulating them in different ways. “Children work with materials at their own pace, repeating an exercise until it is mastered. The teacher may gently guide the process, but her goal is to inspire rather

    Read More

  • Essay On The Montessori Method

    1215 Words  | 3 Pages

    In 1952 Maria Montessori passes and her son Mario Montessori take over as General Director of the Association of Montessori International. Rambusch discovered the writing of Maria Montessori and was very interested to talk with Mario Montessori. Emily Chertoff describes in her article The Great Montessori Schism (2012) In 1953, Nancy McCormick Rambusch, an American teacher, went to an education conference in Paris, where she first met the Montessori method. After training in Britain, she returned to the United States to open a Montessori school in Greenwich, Connecticut. Up until that point, Montessori had taken off in countries around Europe, but unlike other imported European methods like Waldorf, it hadn 't made much of a dent in the US (n.p.) Nancy Rambusch was interested in bringing a more contemporary look of Montessori to the United States. Her colleagues in AMI felt as though the method was rock solid and didn’t need to sway with the trendy changes that most method were. However, these “trends” weren’t short lived and continued on. There was a change in views of parents and educators at this time post war. As mentioned by Gisella Gisolo, it was at this time that (2005) traditional educational methods were being scrutinized, and many parents were willing to play an active role in decisions about their children’s education (in fact, it was not unusual for Montessori

    Read More

  • Biography of Dr. Maria Montessori

    926 Words  | 2 Pages

    In conclusion the Montessori Method of learning has been very successful. Maria Montessori was a very good teacher and her method has been really beneficial. Educators remember her as a very important lover of children who did her work for them. Her Method challenges children to learn and develop. When I have a child I would put him or her in a Montessori school. I know he or she would learn well there. Maria Montessori was a woman that changed the learning world. She is remembered every time a child graduates from a Montessori school.

    Read More

More about Montessori vs. Traditional Education

Open Document