Analysis Of 'Seduction Of The Innocent'

1133 Words3 Pages

The ‘media effects’ model has been classified as a rudimentary argument that isn’t taken seriously amongst modern day Media Scholars. The origins of the model can be found in Frederic Wertham’s ‘Seduction of the Innocent’ (1955) articulating that media texts produce cognitive dissonance, causing audiences to have a shift in their actions and thoughts. However, contemporary critics believe that the model is limited as the experience of media is much more complex and informed by a number of diverse factors. The Audience studies approach is far more applicable towards the complexity of media texts, as it portrays a consideration and analysis of reactions and behavioural activity of individuals. There are a number of complications that undermine …show more content…

It fails to consider violence on the nightly news, against seeing fictionalised violence in films or television. Also, it does not look at the role of violence in constructing a narrative and character, whereby depictions of violence may be personified in films that reflect violence in society. For example, the Hulk in the Avengers personifies greed and anger; two characteristics that exemplify a cause of violence. The media effects model takes the depiction of violence out of its context and intensifies its power without acknowledging the role it plays in …show more content…

The model provides a framework that explains how people interact with the media, in order to satisfy their needs. Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in his paper ‘A theory of Human Motivation’ (1943) stipulates that a need is a state of felt deprivation, and it is through this model that Blumler and Katz (1974) argue that people use the media for this purpose. The study shows that people are not passive, but active consumers, and use the media for benefits. For example, individuals feel the need to develop social skills and interactions. Media texts fulfil this as it allows families and friends to discuss and share their experiences and opinions about a particular media form. This differs from the Media effects model, as it explores how individuals interpret messages to benefit

Open Document