Mandatory Vaccinations

870 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Mandatory vaccine policy argument

Public Health or Personal Choice? Most Americans have been vaccinated long before they have any knowledge or concept of modern medicine; likewise, many people world wide believe in the effectiveness of vaccinations to help build the immune system and prevent the spread of communicable diseases which can at times be fatal. Where the debate over vaccinations arises is in mandated policy requiring vaccinations. One side argues for mandatory vaccinations, taken from the Center for Disease Control's (CDC's) list of recommended vaccinations, for children entering public schools as well as for most health care workers with a focus on protecting public health and safety. The opposing view argues in defense of the individual's freedom of choice …show more content…

The debate over mandatory vaccinations is much more complex than a pro-con discussion of policy constitutionality. The Supreme Court of the United States has ruled that laws promoting public health and safety fall under a stat's police power and an individuals rights may need to yield to the state's authority to preserve order. (1) Every court to hear challenges to vaccination laws have the let the statutes stand. Neither the claim to religious freedom or the liberties of parents to control the upbringing of their children has justified a constitutional exemption from compulsory vaccination. (1) The Mississippi Supreme Court ruled that religious exemptions included in vaccination policies are unconstitutional because only members of recognized denominations could obtain these exemptions. (1) However, all fifty states and Washington D. C. grant medical exemptions based on the recommendations of a licensed physician. …show more content…

(1) It is ethically held that health care professionals should be vaccinated regardless of personal beliefs to protect the interest of patients. (7) Advocates of vaccination claim there should be no exception to compulsory vaccination on the basis of religion or conscience or for any reason other than medical necessity. The government's interest in protecting children and preventing the spread of communicable diseases justifies mandates. (1) Compulsory vaccination is viewed as crucial to protect those who cannot be vaccinated, such as infants and persons with compromised immune systems.

Show More
Related

  • The Controversy of Mandatory Childhood Vaccinations

    1192 Words  | 3 Pages

    There is a war going on against parents that refuse to vaccinate their children. It is coming from the government that makes and enforces laws requiring parents to vaccinate their children, hostile parents of vaccinated children, and doctors that refuse to see unvaccinated children. They are concerned about the potential health risk unvaccinated children pose to the public. These parents aren’t lunatics but are concerned parents that are trying to make the best choice for their children. In fact, these parents aren’t fighting alone; a number of pediatricians and medical experts are apart of this crusade and have taken the lead. They will tell you there is an agenda, “Vaccine manufacturers, health officials, medical doctors, lead authors of important studies, editors of major medical journals, hospital personnel, and even coroners, cooperate to minimize vaccine failings, exaggerate benefits, and avert any negative publicity that might frighten concerned parents, threaten the vaccine program and lower vaccination rates.” 4

    Read More

  • Vaccines: Annotated Bibliography: Vaccines

    1498 Words  | 3 Pages

    The article “People Should Not Be Allowed to Refuse Vaccination” focuses on the dangers people who choose not to vaccinate are opening to others. The argument stems from the ease with which disease can spread through an unvaccinated community and the threat this poses to those who cannot vaccinate. Because of this danger the author of the article believes vaccination should not be left to choice, but required for the good of public safety.

    Read More

  • Should Vacination be Made Mandatory to Enter School?

    1001 Words  | 3 Pages

    Eradication is the concept that a disease is entirely eliminated in a region. (Carter n.d.) Only one infectious disease to date, smallpox, has been categorized as eradicated worldwide (CDC 2010). How did this eradication occur? From 1958 to 1965 all fifty states enacted legislation to mandate school age children receive the small pox vaccine (College of Philadelphia). Consequently, by 1971, no small pox cases had been reported in the United States for 20 years. The last known smallpox case in the world was in Somalia in 1977 (CDC 2010). Even though small pox is the only listed eradicated disease, the Carter Foundation has listed six other diseases as having the potential to be eradicated: lymphatic filariasis (Elephantiasis), polio, measles, mumps, rubella, and pork tapeworm. In addition to these previous listed diseases are to date the following diseases which are considered preventable by vaccination: chicken pox, diphtheria, Haemohphilus Influenza type B, Hepatitis A and B, HPV, Influenza, Measles, Meningococcal Disease, Mumps, Pertusis, Pneumonia, Polio, Rotavirus, Rubella, Shingles, Smallpox, Tetanus, Yellow Fever, and STDs (Carter n.d.).

    Read More

  • Vaccinations: Know the Risks and Failures

    1626 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Vaccinations are causing a major upsurge in childhood diseases, adult maladies, and even deadly ailments such as Gulf War Syndrome and Lou Gehrig’s disease” (Blaylock). Every now and then an individual’s doctor calls telling them about the latest vaccine they should receive. The person immediately schedules a time to come in and get it done. But do they even give a second thought about it? Have they ever thought that maybe they do not need another vaccination? Many people have not taken the time to seriously think about the process of immunization. The truth is, there are many dangers that the average person should be unaware of. Rarely do vaccines actually accomplish what the public has been told. In fact, a lot of vaccines contain harmful substances that have been linked to disorders such as autism. The lack of education and dishonesty from doctors are putting people in danger of health problems without even realizing. Many parents feel obligated for their children to get vaccinated because of school, not knowing they have the alternative option of refusing immunization.

    Read More

  • Vaccine Pros And Cons Essay

    1310 Words  | 3 Pages

    The use of vaccinations has been a major topic in the news lately. The decision to or not to vaccinate your child is a decision that parents face each day. For some the decision is an easy one, a no-brainer. For others, it’s a very difficult one to make. People that are pro-vaccine believe that they are protecting their children and the future generations by vaccinating them against diseases that they could potentially get. People that are ant-vaccine believe that by choosing not to vaccinate, they are protecting their children and future generations from the serious side effects that they could potentially get from the vaccination.

    Read More

  • Mandatory Vaccination in Children: An Ethical Dilemma

    1563 Words  | 4 Pages

    Vaccination was first introduced globally for small pox and later on extended to other communicable diseases which are now known as vaccine preventable disease. Vaccination is beneficial both for individuals and community. This bring us to the ethical dilemma - Vaccination of a healthy child with the intention of protecting both the individual child and the community at the same time exposing the child to the theoretical risk of exposure to disease products whether live, attenuated or killed. There was a time when people never questioned the government or their physicians. Now because of more public awareness and accessibility to medical information, they are questioning the safety aspects of vaccines.

    Read More

  • Compulsory Vaccination: Safeguarding Children and Society

    1098 Words  | 3 Pages

    Parents must be forced to vaccinate their children. The detrimental effects of failing to vaccinate a child can be spine chilling for not only your child but you and your loved ones around. Despite our best efforts to keep our children safe, their lives are unhygienic, a proverbial germ fest some might argue. Children must be vaccinated as they are unaware of their surroundings and a vaccination will save their life; only the child’s but also the people around them.

    Read More

  • Why Should Vaccines Be Mandatory?

    812 Words  | 2 Pages

    Through the years, controversy has surrounded vaccinations such as, whether or not they have harmful side-affects, are a government scheme, or simply unnecessary. Parents today have a choice whether or not to vaccinate their children, but should vaccinations be choice? By mandating vaccinations, fewer people are likely to contract diseases. Although vaccines have been subject to scrutiny, vaccines have worked for many years, are not harmful, and use safe ingredients.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Vaccines

    1882 Words  | 4 Pages

    America looks at disease as a war. Illness is the enemy, vaccinations are the weapons, and the unfortunate cost is that some innocent civilians may lose their lives. A vaccine is a substance used to provide immunity against a disease. In some cases, vaccines have done more harm than good. Ignoring this fact, vaccines are mandatory in every state, and some states are trying to take away the parent’s right to deny them. The disadvantages, diseases, and disabilities caused by vaccines justify the parent’s right to decide against the risk of vaccination.

    Read More

  • Why Should Vaccines Should Be Mandatory

    1157 Words  | 3 Pages

    “Vaccines are the most effective tool we have to prevent infectious diseases… Most childhood vaccines produce immunity about 90-100% of the time” (Vaccines). If it weren’t for vaccines we would be having bad epidemics like we did in the earlier 1900’s. Vaccinations have been proven useful and highly popular among societies. Immunity is much higher when majority of the community is vaccinated. We started to have vaccines around 1885 with the rabies vaccine. Throughout the 1930’s antitoxins and vaccines were made for diphtheria, tetanus, anthrax, cholera, plague, typhoid and tuberculosis (Vaccines). The CDC (Centers for Disease Control) estimated that 732,000 American children were saved from death and 322 million

    Read More

  • H2N2

    2496 Words  | 5 Pages

    The issue before the court in this case concerns the constitutional legitimacy of requiring specific categories of people to receive vaccination and of restricting access to the vaccine for people outside of those categories. For its categories to be legitimate, the state must have some rational basis for requiring the specific groups to receive vaccination while not mandating it for the population at large. The state must also have a rational basis for restricting voluntary access to the vaccine until the target groups have been inoculated. In general, the court affirms both the vaccine mandates and the mandatory vaccination ban in the New Jersey statute. Before discussing several specific cases and caveats as to how the law applies to specific groups, it is necessary to justify the decision to hold these classifications only to the level of ordinary scrutiny.

    Read More

  • Vaccinations: Vaccines Should Be Mandatory For All People

    1002 Words  | 3 Pages

    Vaccinations are designed to help people go through their everyday life. A country doctor, Edward Jenner, who lived in Berkeley, England, first administered vaccines in 1796 (Health Affairs). Throughout history, vaccinations have become better to where they are safer for the human body. Everyone should get vaccinated against certain disease to stay healthy. Vaccines have been proven to make people immune to serious diseases (Childhood Immunization). By being vaccinated the person is not only helping themselves but others around them too. Vaccines are an important tool for preventing disease and should be mandatory for all people.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay Vaccines

    1411 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many people come to the United States of America in order to live freely and make choices based on their personal morals. Considering the fact that America is known for being the “land of the free”, people should be able to choose whether or not they want to get vaccinated. People should have the right to reject vaccinations for whatever reason it may be, whether it’s religious beliefs, health concerns, or lack of belief in the vaccination systems. Personally, Vaccinations have benefited me and my health, and I choose to get vaccinated. I choose to get vaccinated because I strongly believe in a way it helps build my immune system and keeps me from getting sick or catching diseases. However, people have different beliefs than mine. Therefore

    Read More

  • Should Child Vaccinations be Mandatory?

    1230 Words  | 3 Pages

    Each year, about 2.1 million people die from vaccine-preventable diseases. Many children may not receive their necessary first year vaccinations because of lack of availability, religious beliefs, and safety concerns (Healy, Rench, and Baker 540). The dictionary definition of a vaccine is a biological preparation that improves the immunity to a certain disease (Healy, Rench, and Baker 540). Although all 50 States in the United States require children to be vaccinated to certain diseases before entering school, the states also have exemptions for these vaccinations (Lu 870). Parents often choose not to get their children immunized, and it has proven harmful to the health of the global population. It is important for parents to have their children vaccinated against diseases such as measles, mumps, and polio because it is important to promote the welfare of the human race (Parkins 439).

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Vaccines

    2296 Words  | 5 Pages

    Despite the important and positive benefits of vaccinations, some people believe that vaccinating their children can cause serious health problems. Psychological, social, and cultural factors can also play a role in the parents’ decision in whether or not they wish to vaccinate their child (M. Ruijs., 2012). I feel that is it personal responsibility of all parents to vaccinate their children. Despite any pain or discomfort that a child may experience from the given injections, vaccinations are in the best interest of the child. It is very important to vaccinate children as it will protect them against many serious and potentially fatal diseases. Vaccinations are fast acting, harmless to the recipient, and extremely effective.

    Read More

More about Mandatory Vaccinations

Open Document